Jewish Scene
Jewish groups worried by Vatican gesture
Associated Press
Published: 18.09.11, 08:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
31. Who cares about what the Vatican says
George ,   Mantua, USA   (09.19.11)
They need to sort out there own problems before butting there nose in others business. I stand with israel.
32. Why are you surprised ?
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (09.19.11)
Vatican - Sponsor of the Inquisition Vatican issued Passports to escaping Nazi's The present Pope was a Nazi when he was younger So, what's new about their present stance, it's just a continuation of the old traditions
33. It is just a distraction
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (09.19.11)
to divert the public attention from the Pedophilia that the Church allows to run wild and has done so for years It is no wonder that the Church has lost so many followers, they don't feel like shelling out their hard earned money so the Church can hire lawyers to defend their deviant priests
34. Christians
Gina ,   Pensacola, USA   (09.19.11)
I pray the Jews know that Christians and Catholics are not always the same thing. I am a Christian - not a Catholic and I support Israel wholeheartedly. Please, do not let the actions of the Pope and his subjects change your opinion of Christians. We stand with the Jews.
35. I constantly tell Christians
Roslyn ,   Las Vegas, NV USA   (09.19.11)
that Jesus was a Jew, never a Christian. They don't seem to understand. No, I am not a Jew. I am not a Christian. I am an agnostic. It is the only path that is both intellectually honest and also makes sense. Atheism? Just one more religion. A religion of "no God." Can't be proven, doesn't make sense.
36. It was CATHOLICS who stopped HITLER
TomHagen ,   Chicago US   (09.19.11)
What a joke to hear that there will consequences to relations between Jews and Catholics...does that mean CATHOLICS will stay home if there is a NEXT TIME?
37. Vatican Response to Schismatics
Arnold ,   Ashland, OR USA   (09.19.11)
As a Christian it saddened me to see so many bigoted responses to the article posted here. Also, some of the comments quoted in the article were blatantly false and constituted intrusion into another religion's internal affairs. The Catholic Church does not dictate to the Jewish community who it includes within its ranks. Bishop Williamson will likely not be among those who reconcile with Rome should such reconciliation come about. Further, none of you know the terms of the proposed agreement and are jumping to conclusions and throwing insults at the same time.
38. Sadden
Ariel ,   USA   (09.19.11)
I am a Catholic and consider the Jewish people as my brothers and sisters. This is terrible news. Be assured that most of us stand with you and are happy of the progress our two faiths have made in the last few years. I hope that good men in the church's leadership do not make the mistake of letting this society back in without accepting the document.
39. re: Jewish Groups Worried by Vatican Gesture
Juan Oskar ,   Phoenix, AZ U.S.A.   (09.19.11)
I think that Jewish groups, the Anti-Defamation League etc. can relax because the Catholic Church teachings are not going to go anti-Semitic. Any right minded orthodox Catholic in the U.S. or Europe is not going to hate Jews and Israel but support. Liberal Catholics and other left wing Christian and Euro groups are the ones to worry about. This "Traditionalist Bishop Williamson" is a racist dope, but remember the Church has an 'outreach' to everybody. Even Islam. Don't get me started.
40. Jews
jaydee ,   arroyo grande,ca   (09.19.11)
Jews don't know who their friends are but in spite of this their friends remain loyal. Democrats are on the left..the left is allied with islamists..American Jews are Democrats...I rest my case and remain supportive of Israel
41. Our German Shepherd
B16 is my homeboy ,   Chicago   (09.19.11)
O God, the Shepherd and Ruler of all Your faithful people, mercifully look upon Your servant Benedictus XVI , whom You have chosen as the chief Shepherd to preside over Your Church. We beg You to help him edify, both by word and example, those over whom he has charge, that he may reach everlasting life together with the flock entrusted to him. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
42. Vatican
Junior   (09.19.11)
Don't live to be angry.
43. Vatican
HPS ,   Joliet U.S.A   (09.19.11)
I am Catholic but for reasons such as this I no longer go to church.. they don't read the BIBLE or they wouldn't be doing what they are doing
44. Chris #12
Brod ,   USA   (09.19.11)
Chris, thanks for your comment. I have a good response for your Post #8 but they did not put it in. Yes, Jesus was a Jew. But He is more than that. The Prophets Isaiah, Daniel, etc prophesied about Him. Don't equate Papism with Christianity. Papism is Paganism!
45. Chris #12
Brod ,   USA   (09.19.11)
Yes. Unfortunately, they keep censoring my earlier response to your post.
46. So when are you guys leaving America and Europe?
NowSwimBack ,   Allen Park, USA   (09.19.11)
Take the hint already.
47. Jezus part of Israel. Catholicism Roman, as name Palestine.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (09.19.11)
48. rettenmoser...
captaindawg ,   SC USA   (09.19.11)
you are one whack dude . hmmmmm. No, that's it, really. whatever.
49. Wrong Document
Richard ,   Santa Clara, USA   (09.19.11)
Nostra Aetate has never been a Vatican II document SSPX has taken real issue with. They are more reserved about Dignitatis Humanae - on religious freedom.
50. They Rape Little Boys
Reality Check ,   USA   (09.19.11)
and their leader was Hitler Youth. Just the facts. Who cares what the vatican says.
51. 50
David   (09.19.11)
And jews, muslims, atheists etc do not?
52. Jumping too soon
Lucy ,   Columbus, USA   (09.19.11)
Everybody is jumping to conclusions. Pause and observe.
53. Vatican
Biff ,   New York, Nrw York   (09.19.11)
Worry more about Iran, Egypt, Turkey and PLO terrorists, not the Vatican. You have to be kidding me.
54. #44, Brod, Jesus was only a MAN, NOT
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (09.19.11)
a GOD...COME ON...! To worship a man is IDOLATRY...!!!
55. #17 - he'll search the Vatican cellars,
seadog1946 ,   Arthur Kill, NJ   (09.19.11)
find a couple of old "Temple money changers'" coins and buy an admission ticket for a 3rd Temple Grand Opening tour?
56. #52 Lucy, we paused and observed
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (09.19.11)
As the Catholic Church stood by and did nothing while our six million were killed
57. Jesus not Christian
W Wikoff ,   Dallas Tx. USA   (09.19.11)
Your point? Christains are called "Strangers", Gentiles in the Bible. Even so, He knows us also.
58. Amen
Richard ,   Culver City, CA, USA   (09.19.11)
Amen to your comment. There is a lot of ignorance on in this feedback about the Church.
59. Catholics need to read
James ,   Greendale USA   (09.19.11)
If the Vatican and the Catholic people would read their Bibles; they would see: 1 - It was a Roman who passed sentence. 2 - It was a Roman who drove the nails. 3 - How do you kill the Son of God who could have called ten legions of angels to his defense. 4 - Most importantly read John 10:14-18.
60. CAN A LEOPARD CHANGE IT'S SPOTS ?
Marcel ,   Florida   (09.19.11)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article