News
MK Ben Ari: Establish Palestine in France
Boaz Fyler
Published: 20.09.11, 21:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. Good idea. France has 3 times as many Arabs as Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.20.11)
Ben Ari's idea of creating a Palestine state in France is a good idea. The French always go out of their way to express sympathy for "Palestinians". Thus they should welcome the opportunity. Moreover, France has more than 3 times as many Arabs as Israel. So France would be a excellent choice for the State of Palestine.
2. A lie told 10000000 times is still a lie, Ms. Zoabi.
Scott ,   NY   (09.20.11)
3. Kick this women out of israel, she can join bishara and
Judah ,   Israel   (09.20.11)
others who are to follow
4. Judea means where Jews live...
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (09.20.11)
So the so called settlers are right!!!! They are settling in their own Land,like kenians in Kenia(except Obama,he fake is burnt place)...he is not even proud of been an African... Africans should live in Africa and Jews in Judea...
5. By the way...Israel flags are beautifulllll
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (09.20.11)
...so keep taking them around....
6. zoabi
jew from the east   (09.20.11)
madam,do you realze what a cretin you are?according to you Israel is a criminal state.what are you? a MK of this "criminal state",which state pays you a good salary and guarantee you rights you never have in any arab country.
7. Create Israel in Germany or Poland or Russia
christianpalestinian ,   hong kong   (09.20.11)
That would make a lot more sense.
8. Nadal Named Zoabi.
Oleh Chadash ,   Israel   (09.20.11)
Why does the gov't allow this terrorist to participate in our gov't. Are we trying so hard to be a Western democracy, that we have a Freudian compulsion to recreate their problems when have no need to? If a terror happy, Arab, Goebbels like this served in the US Congress the American people would demand she get twenty years in the electric chair. At the very least, they would lock her up and throw away the key(like Ramsee Usef), which in her case, would be extreme leniency for the heinous nature of her crimes.
9. zoabi is tenacious
mohson   (09.20.11)
while zoabi lies, distorts, screeches, and at times smacks israeli knesset personnel, she is tenacious. She doesn't give up. She would 100% like to dismantle israel and become a minister under PM Haniyeh. She does lots of travelling assisting israel's enemies. maybe she doesn't have to come back.
10. #7 Israel is real, "Palestine" is fake
Menachem ,   Israel   (09.20.11)
Modern Israel exists in the ancestral and eternal homeland of the Jewish nation. "Palestine" has never existed outside of the arch terrorist Arafat's sick head.
11. 3 times dozens vs 50 (incl Zoabi)
rebecca ,   Modiin   (09.20.11)
Please tell me I'm not the only one who got Ynets leftist swing "Dozens of settlers... while (no number) pro-Palestinian..." So the numbers show "settlers", despite being working people, had more support than the professional trouble maker Zoabi. Ynet dont try using BBC style reporting.
12. Museum
zichron   (09.20.11)
The Palestinians ought have a museum at the Nazi Retreat in Berghof whith Photos of their Great Leader The mufti of Jerusalem Husseini meeting adolf hitler and creating the bosnian ss divisions .
13. I wish France were pro-Israel
Alex ,   USA   (09.20.11)
No no no!! As someone who loves France I hate this idea. They would just ruin France too. France is already having big problems form its Muslim population, riots in the banlieus, 700 no-go areas, the recent law in Paris to take back the streets. France needs to get its head up and stop being dumb.
14. Zoabi= Crime Preacher
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.20.11)
Zoabi is an exceptional out of norms of democracy in civizated world and a result of deficiency of Israeli deomocracy. In fact Zoabi should ask her/his self : -How despite all the odds the Jewish state is economical succeseful and around in Arb world everything is fading and fall apart. - Libia, Syria inoccent killing is not calling a crime ??? - Shite kiliing in Pakistan is not a crime? - 1.000.000 Armens killed by Turks is not crime You have a long list of crime comitted and one or other you'l be take accountable crime preacher.
15. Why dump on Canada - One of Israel's best friends
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (09.20.11)
"We are in favor of the establishment of a Palestinian state in France or in Canada..." I wouldn't wish the Palestinians on any decent country, and certainly not on Canada, which has long been quite friendly toward Israel, especially since Harper became its Prime Minister.
16. White "Jews" are not Native to the region
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (09.20.11)
...and they should go back to their white countries of origin, Russia, Europe, America.
17. to # 16
jew from the east   (09.21.11)
STEFANO BENASSI, where is your country of origin? bella Italia?
18. I can see France giving up some of their land
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.21.11)
Let's face it they are the 2nd largest colonial power after Great Britain and have colonies all over the world. They have 640,000 sq km vs our 22,000. Population 65 million vs our 7.7 million. Which means they have 101 people per sq km and we have 350 people per sq km. Works for me.
19. France is not bad actually
palestinian ,   westbank   (09.21.11)
if you convince them, i would rather live in a peaceful country than in this shit hole excuse of a holy country no offence ..!
20. Transportation
I guess ,   Jerusalem   (09.21.11)
MK Ben Ari and his followers believe that no Jews are merchandise for export. They imagine that banishing people bring redemption. Redemption of who? The next step is perhaps the creation of a new settlement, a Circus with lions and gladiators, Ben Ari, empresario, Ben Gvir, the clerck in the tickets office, and in the tribune a thirsty public, the HillsYoungs.
21. #7 Christian Paletinian remember the Arab saying...
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (09.21.11)
..."Sunday follows Saturday"
22. #16: You are very deserving of your name...
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (09.21.11)
"Ben Ass". Your stupidity and your braying are testimony to why you got that name.
23. arab go to canada jews go back to germany and that's it
Jalal ,   Gaza   (09.21.11)
i prefer canada and jews can go back to germany russia and what ever else and the land will be clear from people and that's wonderful for our mother earth no killing no bad ideas no stupid politics just peace
24. #1 Arabs?
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (09.21.11)
Only that Muslims in France are not Arabs. They come from North Africa. They are from Maghreb. They have genetically nothing in common with Arabs and Palestinians. Next time, document yourself instead of telling stupidities.
25. #19 - "palestinian" from westbank
(09.21.11)
another prime example that arabs here only actually have one goal, and that's to terrorise israelis, they don't really give a shit about the land.
26. Zoabi the Traitor
David ,   Haifa, Israel   (09.21.11)
Arrext and improsion this traitor and her family!!!
27. A second alternative : Norway !
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/isreal   (09.21.11)
28. What about Borobidjan?
Rami   (09.21.11)
I hear it's lovely there this time of year
29. Burning flags is illegal - against the law.
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (09.21.11)
30. A bit of history: Jewish autonomy under Napoleon in France.
Michael ,   California, USA   (09.21.11)
About 200 years ago Napoleon offered Jews full autonomy within the French empire. He communicated to heads of the various Jewish communities in France that his government would view favorably establishment of a Sanhedrin and self rule of Jews. All he asked in return was that Jews support Napoleon's policies. He asked Jews to join the military draft and to pay taxes to the French treasury. Well, Sefaradi Jews didn't want a Sanhedrin with Ashkenazi Jews. Most of the Jewish parents did not want their sons to serve in the French army, and certainly they did not want to pay taxes. Jews proved to Napoleon they did not want an autonomy under his rule in France.
Next talkbacks
Back to article