News
Obama UN address angers Palestinians
Elior Levy
Published: 21.09.11, 21:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. Could it really be?
Steve   (09.22.11)
Is it possible this charmer desparately needs Jewish money and support for his re-election so that he can continue his assault on America, Israel and the region? His statement today (for the first time ever), "The Jewish people have forged a successful state in their historic homeland," has got to have the Muslim world fuming! The Palestinian Authority has been doing everything in its power to deny Israel's connection to the land. Arafat said Jesus was a Palestinian and there was no Temple on the mount, etc. They even destroy artifacts on the Temple mount in order to erase any historic Jewish connection to our land.
32. ARABS HAVE NO LEGAL, HISTORICAL, OR MORAL RIGHT TO BE IN ISR
Ray ,   U.S.A.   (09.22.11)
Arabs/Muslims say because at some point in time (when Israel was under occupation and rule of Muslim countries) they were the majority, they should own all or a big chunk of Israel. This argument is useless for the following reasons: 1. The last Muslim country that ruled and occupied Israel was Turkey. Turkey (the Ottoman Empire) imposed severe restrictions on Jewish immigration and land purchase by Jews in Israel and actively invited Muslims from other parts of the Ottoman Empire to settle in Israel, including Circassians and Bosnians.  As a result, Arabs/Muslims became the majority. However, even then the land was mostly empty as reported by Mark Twain; Arthur Penrhyn Stanley, the British cartographer; James Finn, the British Consul General; and others because of Turkey’s neglect of the land. 2. There is no universal right of citizenship by birth. People who were born in countries that are not based on common law, e.g. Japan, Germany, and France, do not become citizens of those countries. So because some Arabs were born in Israel, they do not get automatic right of ownership and citizenship of Israel. 3. Arabs caused the Holocaust. In 1920, 1921, 1929, after Arabs rioted against Jews and murdered several hundred Jews, the British created the White Paper law in 1930, which banned Jews from coming to Israel. As a result, six million Jews were murdered by Europeans because they could not come to Israel. Furthermore, Arabs, in particular Arab occupiers of Israel, collaborated with Nazis to massacre the Jews. 4. In 1948, when Jordan and Syria captured the West Bank and Golan Heights, they deported Jews to Israel and massacred any Jew who remained in the West Bank and Golan Heights. So Jews have the right to do the same i.e. deport Arabs to their own country. 5. Israel is the ancestral home of Jews. Israel is not the ancestral home of Arabs/Muslims. 6. Before 1948 the West Bank and Golan Heights did not belong to Arabs. Arabs acquired those areas (for 19 years) after they attacked Israel in 1948. Before it, the West Bank belonged to England and Golan Heights belonged to France. 7. Arabs say because of Resolution 181 they own the West Bank and Golan Heights. Resolution 181 was a non-binding recommendation to partition Israel, whose implementation hinged on acceptance by both parties - Arabs and Jews. Since Arabs did not accept the resolution, the West Bank and Golan Heights became No-Man’s Land, which was part of the ancestral land of the Jews. In addition, Israel is a small country; they should not just give a big chunk of their prime land to the Arabs. 8. If Arabs/Muslims are permitted to stay in Israel, they will be a serious threat to the Jews because every Arab family has 10 children. Once they become majority, they will join their comrades in Gaza, West Bank, and the rest of the Arab/Muslim world and will massacre the Jews. For the above reasons Arabs/Muslims should be deported to their own country.
33. #16 tatas again? Need a brassiere?
Puzzled   (09.22.11)
Are you a half-wit... or merely a nitwit? Why are you forever posting something about your tatas (boobs?). Do you need a new brassiere that badly? Perhaps you missed your meds today? This is certainly not the appropriate forum for any of your inane rants...BTW, no one cares about your anatomy and your irrelevant posts about chest-related problems!
34. Abbas' occupied territories Crap
Brod ,   USA   (09.22.11)
What 'occupied territories' is Abbas talking about? The Land of Israel belongs to Israel since Ancient time.
35. #1 120 is ok. How about 3000?
Danny Kaysi ,   USA   (09.22.11)
The Israeli argument for becoming a nation was based on the fact that the Jewish people lived there THOUSANDS of years ago... and you consider referring to something a couple hundred years ago strange somehow? Get real...
36. Beware.. Of my hunger And my anger!
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.22.11)
I do not hate people Nor do I encroach But if I become hungry The usurper's flesh will be my food Beware.. Beware.. Of my hunger And my anger! Mahmoud Darwish.
37. Just a hunch
Bill ,   New York, USA   (09.22.11)
I think one intended target of the speech was Turkey. At a moment when Turkey was making disturbing comments, the Obama administration came to understand that perceived weakness in the US-Israel alliance was inviting mischief, with varying mobs and potentates competing to be the most anti-Israeli of all. But why would this apply to the Israel-Palestinian issue? Precisely because it is the weak point that Turks, Egyptians etc attempt to use as leverage. Shutting this down is intended to communicate that mischief will not be toleated on other issues. The real question now is not what the Palestinians do, because it is not very important. It is what Erdogan will do now that the US has communicated that his aggression will not yield fruit.
38. #21 Are YOU serious?
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.22.11)
Abbas has stated that he will not give up on any demands regardless of any treaty. What kind of treaty is that? That ends everything before it begins. So much for being serious.
39. Arab character of east Jerusalem
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.22.11)
King Abdullah II of Jordan: claimed that a crisis would arise "from efforts to annihilate the Arab character of east Jerusalem," This 'arab character' came about much because of his kicking the Jews out of Jerusalem in 1948, destroying anything jewish, and convincing arabs to settle there in their stead.
40. Why can't they say it
Howell LS ,   Dallas, USA   (09.22.11)
Why can't the Palestinians just say the words? They recognize Israel's right to exist and it's wrong to kill Israelis. If they left no doubt, it would give them a much stronger case. Even in Israel public opinion would be affected. Instead they maintain the double talk. They tell Western audiences one thing and tell radicals at home they will never accept Israel.
41. United Nations doesn't Matter
Ezra ,   San Diego   (09.22.11)
Really, no matter what protocol is used to communicate the request for Arabs to re-invent philistine (Palestine), the message is simple; Israel is the homeland of our people. HaShem is our G-d, and Israel is our land.
42. Nothing to negotiate
Zev ,   Israel   (09.22.11)
The Arabs are not interested in peace with Israel. They are only interested in how much land they can take away from Israel without giving anything in return. They negotiate and Israel gives them more land for nothing in return. When they are ready to recognize Israel as the Jewish state and end all of their claims to all of Israel that will be the time to start negotiating.
43. obama is a snake! asking palis to wait just another year.
mira ,   israel   (09.22.11)
and american jews will be too dumb to understand it as always.
44. 36 Beware
(09.22.11)
Beware of losing your handouts. Beware of losing your electricity. Beware of losing your water. Beware of losing your trucked-in supplies. Beware of losing your medical care. Beware of losing the West Bank. Beware of Israel.
45. #36 Look where that got him
Cynthia ,   USA   (09.22.11)
Look where it got the Palestinians. All those decades of terror, hate, self-destructive behavior to perpetuate the conflict. Beware, the Palestinians cannot cheat their way to statehood or simply rant about their anger when they have nothing to offer.
46. #31
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (09.22.11)
#31: Obama's admission of the Jewish connection to Israel will not anger Muslims: it is written in the Koran.
47. Isreli Stupidity
22.09.11   (09.22.11)
Why do the Israelis not see what they got in return when they pulled out of Gaza for the arabs? Wakey, wakey israel! You lost your strength when the older generation died out, and what do you have now.... a bunch of school-boys it would appear!
48. Steve at 31
macktheknife   (09.22.11)
Don't worry Steve. The Americans are not arabs and know who and what Obama is. Obama is dead againt the Jews and only took their side hoping to remain in power for another 4 years. In arabic he has told the Arabs what his real plan is.... another 4 years in Office and then the "Palestinians" will have ALL of Israel, including the slaughter of all Jews living on their own land. I hope the Jews are truly aware of this!
49. #1 Henry of York: So, when Israel is 120 years years .....
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.22.11)
we can slaughter the Arabs! By your comment, you said we can! The Americas were stolen by the Europeans. Australasia by the British and Greater Israel was stolen by the Babylonians, the Roman, the Crusaders and the Arabs. Jews have been year for 4500 years not like the USA from 1492 to the present a mere 519 years! So who belongs where? Arabs have their own country. Arabia!
50. number 36
barney ,   usa   (09.23.11)
get the real story from number 32. Israel is for the Jews. ALL OF ISRAEL. always has been always will.
51. #37 Salma, you sound liike mad cannibals
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (09.23.11)
Do as you Arabs usualy do, hate and consume each other Libya, Yemen, Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Egypt (I know Iran isn't Arab,it's Muslim) same mad beast Yes, does does encroach, Darwish is claiming land that isn't even mentioned in your Koran Now, for my part, you & Darwish can go consume each other with your hatred
52. I dare you to post this!!!!!
Edithann ,   USA   (09.23.11)
Jews didn't earn Israel...it was gifted by the 'goy' to get them out of their hair once and for all. Just as you Jews wanted to be alone..so too the goy...or at least free of the troublesome Jew.... Is the Roman destruction of the Second Temple the 'revenge' motive for the Jewish destruction of the US? http://www.gilad.co.uk/writings/gilad-atzmon-american-tragedy.html#entry12945533 As the Titanic has shown, we will 'all' go down with this ship! TATA
53. The US/Israeli TITANIC!
Edithann ,   USA   (09.23.11)
Is the Roman destruction of the Second Temple the 'revenge' motive for the Jewish destruction of the US? http://www.gilad.co.uk/writings/gilad-atzmon-amer... As the Titanic has shown, we will 'all' go down with this ship! TATA
54. #48 mack
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.23.11)
And where is this written? Where did you read this? Being anti-anything is permissible. Fantasies are not. Let’s try and keep this real, ok?
55. #52, #53 LOL ! tata
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.23.11)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article