News
Cabinet debates Shalit deal
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 11.10.11, 21:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
71 Talkbacks for this article
61. Pathetic
Mary snow ,   USA   (10.12.11)
This poodle of Obama let's go these terrorist. How many men women and children will die because of this stupid act. I have no faith in bibi and barak defending the Jewish people and Israel
62. major victory for...
yoni ,   tel aviv   (10.12.11)
Israel is crazy and committing mass suicide against itself. The arabs near me in Jerusalem are currently all openly celebrating as if they just won a war. They are openly honking and shouting singing and dancing in JERUSALEM. Do you get that? They all identify with the release of murderous terrorists and with Hamas. To release 1027 terrorists is sick and hurts our security in a very very serious way especially in morale and mentality.
63. THIS IS GREAT !... and how mischievous the usual suspects he
eporue ,   europe   (10.12.11)
re are... gilad risked his life for you, but when you have to take a very small risk (as your army commanders say - its no risk, actually), then you get quiet... you dont want to do anything for others, just take it... just expect that green idiots to risk their asses for you, and your extremism... your masks are off anyway, for long already...
64. #60, john from alaska... are you saying "...and to avenge hi
eporue ,   europe   (10.12.11)
s loss accordingly..."... i thought you were a christian ? does the concept of "avenge" fit with it? what do you think would be a permitted, appropriate avenge in this case ?
65. I just called my sons in Israel telling them its time to
Al   (10.12.11)
come home. I dont want them to scrifice their lives defending a nation of losers whimps and Auschwitz candidates. You are on your own...Shalit the boy will come back to you but you better prepare the body bags. You are going to need a whole lot of them. My sons are not going to be your korban...they will come back to Canada to live as free thinking Jews. You are a nation of slaves, fools and hasbeens. Good luck to you all. I'd rather my sons and I live and die amongst the goyim than live amongst a nation of slaves that is waiting to board a train to Auschwitz.
66. Lets get Pollard out too.
Efroim ,   Washington DC   (10.12.11)
Israel should blast the palis hard when they act up again.
67. And What Happens if One Israeli is Wasted?
Noah Lev ,   LosAngelesUSA   (10.12.11)
2 tragedies have occurred. The first was the capture of Shalit, w/o immediate carpet bombing by the IDF of the Strip.24/7, until he was released, with the condition that he be in good heath. The second, is this latest appeasement of Arab thugs, murderers and terrorists..by releasing 1,000 Muslims for one person, albeit, we do all feel sympathy for him and his family. Many prisoners at Gitmo, went back to their old terrorist groups..to fight on. Israel's history issimiar..with released murderrs doing similarly,and becomin heroes. When the first Jew is killed, by one of the 1,000 releaed..there willbloodon the hands of Bibi, the cabinet and the Shalit family. What will the FAMILY of the killed Israeli think? This is a black day in Israel's sordid history. I ask, would Gurion, Shamir,Begin or Dayan have releaed 1,000? Maybe one to one? And will this stop further kidnappings for the remaining thousands? Israel's plight has become worse with this move. The ans: capital punishment for convicted murderers or accomplices to murder. 25 to life for felonies (3) with no parole or "deal". BTW, what about Pollard, who still languishes in jail...and whose crime was giving info to an ally about terrorists and was persecuted by of all people, a Jew? Until Israel understands its at war for its survival...this farce wil; l continue.
68. Israel Needs a New Sheriff inTown
Noah Lev ,   LosAngelesUSA   (10.12.11)
Fellow Zionists, I am today ashamed to be a Jew and life-long Zionist. Can anyone imagine here in California, 1,000 prisoners released if a cop were captured by a gang of protestors, with blood on their hands? Thousands of low level criminals (drugs, etc.) are being released from federal prisons..and state convicts are being released or send to local jails...The police have warned all of US about this release. Wtih thousands of street people..what next? These are dangerous people..still addicted. Look, I pity Shalit and his family and friends. But going into the IDF or any enforcement service takes on risks. I was in law enforcement for a long time, and was warned that the job was risky, due to the nature of the work. I understaood the dangers from the get go. Israel needs an Arizona type sheriff to supervise prisons w/o frills. It needs to arrest protestors..who use public space. It needs to change its laws to include ANY CAPITAL CRIME for the 12.00 noose. Every terrorist is another Eichmann..only the opportunity is different. One Jew vs 100,000...its all the same to the person killed. Some say the families should not undergo the trama of appeals. I say, all of Israel is now undergoing a trama of released murderers. Females can kill too....guys. A female can slit a babys throat. This is a very sad day for Israel and world Jewry, which, could be solved easily... If another Jew is kidnapped..Israel must bomb 24-7 until released, in good health...get it!
69. Shalit
Amos Picker ,   Fremont, CA   (10.12.11)
It is a full win- win situation. The 1000 Arabs in the Israeli jails are expesnsive to keep the Shalit release is a happy ending to us all and his family and HIMSELF. Go ahead, and relase 2,000, 3,000. Who needs them in Israel? If they start shooting, just shoot back to kill, not to capture.
70. An addendum to my last post
John ,   Alaska   (10.12.11)
I hope that my post did not ound callous. This is not good news; it means that one aspect of the Covenant is something we see happen after another Arab monster is stupid enough to take an Israeli life. we have no pleasure in what happens next. We are so glad that G-d keeps His word forever, and that His word is for my blessing. And that G-d is taking away more and more of the monsters.
71. To #65 Al
John ,   Alaska   (10.12.11)
Don't leave just now; you're leaving at the end of the introduction. The Arab monsters took one of your own, said that one Israeli is worth 1027 monsters. The monsters demanded that you Jews agree with them about this rate or exchange. The head monsters and the head Jews both agreed, and the rate was set. They created a new thing, and the manner of its creation determined the manner in which it happened. The monsters gave the life of one Jew to Israel. The Israelis are giving the lives of 1027 monsters to the monster place. Okay it's happened before G-d's eyes, it was done by Israel's enemies, the demanded exchange rate was made by Israel's enemies. All that the Jews did was agree to it. So, dear Al. The Jews are not at fault; they were robbed and on top of this, they are forced to agree. You've seen not Israel but only the Arabs sew the wind, If you stay you can see these Arab monsters reap their promised whirlwind. Ha'Shem saw this with His own eyes, The monsters are already crowing about the rate the demanded and got, and about the 1027 monsters for one Israeli. Ha'Shem is all about honoring a covenant, even that which one is forced into to save a life Baruch atta Adonai Elohenu, Melek ha olam, shomer Kol b'ritim Am Yisrael.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article