News
Shalit deal to include 1,027 security prisoners
Omri Efraim, Attila Somfalvi
Published: 12.10.11, 00:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
31. Terrorist prisoners
New Yorker ,   U.S.A.   (10.11.11)
Why even bother detaining and jailing them? Terrorists should get an automatic death sentence carried out immediately. And those who follow in their footsteps should know that theirs would be the exact same fate. No more arresting them, no more civilized prison sentences - pure instantaneous death. No more playing games with the Israeli lives; because releasing a terrorist will likely result in loss of life among innocent people - our own people! No more human sacrifice for the sake of the non-applicable "due process".
32. 1000 for 1
howard singer ,   pittsburgh, USA   (10.11.11)
This is insane!
33. Release Shalit...
Ariel ,   USA   (10.11.11)
... bring him home and then go after those bastards. Eye X eye, teeth X teeth.
34. We should sweeten the exchange
Ish Kabibble ,   Delancey   (10.11.11)
As each Palestinan prisoner is released, give him a tool of his trade, an AK 47 & ammunition, or a bomb belt full of explosives
35. Now, kill them. No more prisoners.
Yossef   (10.11.11)
36. No. 28
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (10.11.11)
WEll spoken from Miami, Roy-boy. I guess you don't have a kid in the IDF.
37. Flooding the market
Michel ,   Paris   (10.11.11)
Palestinians produce more criminals than business people. They are flooding the market.
38. Again,
William ,   Toronto, Canada   (10.11.11)
the mass media is painting nationalist groups as extremist. Why the quotation marks surrounding the words "capitulation of terror groups"? That is exactly what is going on here- on a ridiculous scale! ONE THOUSAND terrorists released to the public domain!? THREE HUNDRED that are serving life sentences!? For ONE soldier? Granted, the life of every human being is precious, and we pray strongly for Gilad's freedom, but let's be brutally logical here: One guaranteed life saved against the nearly guaranteed loss of countless, G-d forbid. With a brigade-sized amount of lethal terrorist back on the outside, that is the frightening specter we are presented with. We need some sense. We need to see who the real extremists are, and how many lives they're playing with. Call them settlers or what have you, the Nationalist camp is concerned about improving the lives of others. The pols are only concerned about their own.
39. Shalit deal
David ,   Montreal, Canada   (10.11.11)
It is understandable that one's sense of justice or fair play is offended by the scope of this swap. Nevertheless, Mr. Shalit and his family has suffered enormously and will continue to suffer the results of his forcible confinement forever. Moreover, the State of Israel will save considerable financial resources repatriating the human garbage that is being released. Finally, the Israel now has a clear mandate to kill any of this human garbage should it try to perpetrate any more crimes against Israel or its citizens. So it is written so it shall be.
40. I am disgusted with BIbi
zionist forever   (10.11.11)
This is the deal that Bibi, Barak, Olmert and Livni have refused to do for five years now because they know that it will lead to more soldiers and civilians being taken because its so profitable. Take one man hold him long enough and eventually the Israeli public will be telling their government pay any price no matter how high. The only reason Bibi made this irresponsible deal is mostly to distract public attention from all these protests. The residents are quitting over pay, the hardcore protestors like Leef are unhappy with Trjtenberg and intend to try and start the protests again possibly try and bring down the government. The unions are going to call for a general strike because they are unhappy with Trjtenberg. Labor are also overtaking both Likud & Kadima in the polls as a result of the protests and I imagine Bibi is also scared the coalition will soon colapse and he needs a big prize if he wants people to reelect him so he is doing the deal that he previously rejected. How many killers are going to be released for Bibi's election bribe? How many more Gilad's will there be in future because the arabs think the risks of snatching somebody are worth taking if they can get a pay off of 1200+ if they can get just 1 man. Time for Likud to vote for a new leader because Bibi can't be trusted.
41. Reply to no#24
The Maccabee ,   Jerusalem   (10.11.11)
Great idea!
42. Is there a stipulation that Shalit will be returned ALIVE?
Devorah   (10.11.11)
43. You damn fools, you just opened the floodgates
Cameron ,   USA   (10.11.11)
They played you the whole way down the line. Welcome to the future, Israelis. Now no Israeli will walk the streets without having to worry about kidnap & being held hostage to demands. What a disaster.
44. Truly insane! A death warrant for countless Israelis.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.12.11)
This is truly insane! It boggles the mind that the Israeli government would even consider such a deal. This deal is a death warrant for countless Israeli civilians. No wonder Hamas is so proud and happy. How low must Israel sink before we begin to rise? Does anyone in the Israeli government remember Entebbe? It is truly frightening to have Israel in the hands of such "leaders". More frightening than Israel's enemies.
45. Has anyone checked if Shalit is even alive?
Les Cowan ,   Canada   (10.12.11)
46. Horrible
Rachel   (10.12.11)
So I guess if their going to release all female prisoners this means their going to release that woman who said she was happy she murdered 15 people at the Sbarro restaurant,and smiled when she learned that 7 children had actually died in the bombing,not 3 as was previously thought. My heart goes out to the victims families.
47. FREEDOM FOR GILAD SHALIT, THE PALESTINIAN PRISONNERS, MORDEC
SJOERD RUURD VAN DER ,   MANKIND-COUNTRY   (10.12.11)
MORDECHAI VANUNU AND SO ON FOR PEACE AN PROSPERITY.
48. what would putin do
tovarich ,   chitown   (10.12.11)
If u killed them u wouldn't b in this mess!
49. Jews More Valuable Than Muslims
Cheryl S. ,   Boston, USA   (10.12.11)
1000 Muslims for one measly Jew! Just shows how valuable Jews are.
50. Does the government have "sechel"?
KW ,   Bet Shemesh, ISRAEL   (10.12.11)
Has the government thought through making sure he is alive BEFORE handing over 450 terrorists?? Even if "only" 150 will stay within Israel, I am not sure if they can trust the temporary Egyptian government to be honest as hopefully Mubarak would have been....If not I hope people will inundate the government that they should not let out even one terrorist unless they have a way to make sure Gilad is and gets to Israel ALIVE!!
51. No.36 I have 2 sons in the IDF Dorothy
Roy ,   Miami   (10.12.11)
Dont think its easy for me to write this. I think we should have smoked whole of Gaza to get Shalit back in Cast Lead. The leaders of IL are to blame for this. They have no guts.
52. 231 new murders. Blood is on your hands to those that voted
hippocrates ,   earth   (10.12.11)
for this. You fools in charge have a long tradition of being idiots who arms your enemies, and release thousands for a few dead bodies. You kill 231 innocents to save 1? Thats what you did with tanenbaum. Simple solution is capture the most senior hamasniks and their families, give them solitary confinement. offer to trade them for gilad. Good chance of working...
53. Let out jewish "terrorists" too
moshe ,   usa   (10.12.11)
54. its a good deal... everyone seems quite happy with it...
eporue ,   europe   (10.12.11)
well done everyone...
55. It is a sad day
Rick ,   United States   (10.12.11)
I remember better days when Israel refused to negotiate with terrirists. 1000 for 1, land for peace or any copmpromise will only ensure more heartache. You cannot reason with the unreasonable.
56. more Shalits will be kidnap in future!
mary of Bethany ,   singapore   (10.12.11)
more "Shalits" will happen in the future! as you catch more terrorists, bring them entered prison at the front door, Hamas will kidnap some more "Shalits" and demand releases terrorists thru the back door. some of these very 400 release terrorist might be the very ones that will be kidnapping more soldiers in future! so Israel can forget about catching terrorists in future, since they WILL BE RELEASED in future. Prison will just be a 3 stars motel to terrorists! so, more parents of soldiers in future will go thru what Shalit's parents go thru. i know it sound cruel, but if i am Shalit, i will prefer to die in Hamas hands, then to live thru life knowing more soldiers will be kidnapped because of "my freedom". if i am Shalit, how can i live thru live in this guilt? if i am Shalit parents, how can i look into the victim's parents' eyes which killers are released because of "my son"? The parents of those sons died in terrorism don't even have a full body to bury, they can only scrap bits and parts of the blew-up bodies and buried them. anyone dare aliyah in future? bringing their sons into Israel to be kidnapped? and the greatest joke is: you are going to send the terrorists right back in to Judea and Samaria, E Jersualem? what madness?
57. shalit
sad ,   israel   (10.12.11)
a pigua on the way b 4 shalit returns.
58. Hamas sure has struck a fine deal.
Judas Iscariot ,   London, England   (10.12.11)
What a fantastic deal. Hamas has pulled off. Once these prisoners are released, Hamas shall begin on phase two - kidnapping more Israeli soldiers. Then there will be another round of negotiations, but this time for the "bigwig" prisoners. The funny thing is the Israeli politicians are totally at the mercy of Hamas. Yet they claim that they coerced Hamas into showing flexibility, My backside, is all i can say! Hamas has whipped you. Cannot wait for another 1000 prisoners to be released.
59. 1=1027
leon ,   new york   (10.12.11)
1 israeli solider = 1027 terroist palestinians. 1 israeli novel prize scientist = 10000000000000000000.5 arabs.
60. Think of the money we could save
Sam   (10.12.11)
Israel should dismiss all of their police, prosecutors, and judges since they have been shown to be worthless. If murderers need not serve their sentences and will not be punished for their crimes then why bother with the farce of a ceremonial justice system?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article