Jewish Scene
Thousands of Hasidim dance for Shalit
Eli Mandelbaum
Published: 15.10.11, 09:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. Maybe he should have prayed for a better deal :)
ron ,   Melbourne, Australia   (10.15.11)
2. baba miskolc
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.15.11)
either the baba started praying very late, or he is praying very slow,and given the extra demands by hamas, the baba will have to do some more prayinng.
3. CHAI GILAD! CHAI GILAD! CHAI GILAD! CHAI!
David ,   NJUSA   (10.15.11)
4. Israel = 12 Tribes....NO "JEWS" !!!
Anthony Clifton ,   Texas   (10.15.11)
*Comments containing incitement, slander, racist slurs and inappropriate language deemed to violate our terms of uselessness won't be published. ...The ASHKENAZIM "PROSELYTES" to Talmudic Judaism are not Hebrew, NOT Israelites, and Not from the tribe of Judah....Ipso Facto...There Are NO "JEWS" in the Old Testament....See Schlomo Sand, Gilad Atzmon, Benjamin Freedman, Arthur Koestler....& Deuteronomy 32. *Stupid will never change true....Khazars need to make Exodus to Khazaria.
5. Prayer, Unity?? Only a believer in a Big Invisible Daddy in
tom ,   tel aviv   (10.15.11)
the Skies can utter such nonsense. How about united stupidity that binds Israeli people and the Israeli government in a constant dance around the Golden Calf of Peace ?
6. fitting reality to beliefs really befits believers
izzy d   (10.15.11)
7. the power of prayer and a zillion prisoners
iselin ,   Oslo, Norway   (10.15.11)
Yeah, right. The power of prayer - that plus a zillion Palestinian prisoners will get Shalit back (I hope). Why didn't all that prayer work a couple of years ago? Or did it have a cumulative effect? Who is fooling whom?
8. Gilad Shalit Pidyon Nefesh
Rabbanit Ruth Alfas ,   Tzfat, IS   (10.15.11)
This past Sept. 15, 2011 my husband, haRav haMekubal Yehudah Alfasi, rosh kollel - Yeshivat haMekubalim Kol Yehuda v'Eliyahu in Tzfat, performed a pidyon nefesh for Gilad Shalit. This beit din of mekubalim was assembled at the time Rav Yehudah determined was best. Video in hebrew, shavua tov v'chag sameach www.yeshivathamekubalim.com
9. Dance?
Lila ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.16.11)
Will you be dancing at the funerals of the victims of the released terrorists? Don't you hear the blood of the kidnapped and murdered soldiers and teenagers, the grandmothers killed at the Park Hotel, the baby burned alive in Sbarro?
10. ma ichpat lahem?
sara g nili   (10.16.11)
They don't serve in the army. Wow! Giborim....not. They don't need to rush back to the base after a quick regilah( if they were indeed lucky enough to have one) as our religious soldiers do/did last night.
11. #4 in Texas
Steve ,   America   (10.16.11)
You are a fool! I suggest you get on some medication for delusional thinking....real quick
12. # 4 12 tribes
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.16.11)
Anthony ! Judaism is not a tribe, but an idea, tightly connected to a place called the Land of Israel,for the last 35 centuries.
13. Profound lesson here
Avi ,   NYC   (10.16.11)
Jewish unity is important. I don't agree with everything Haredim do or think. But here are group of Hasidim that are overjoyed that a fellow Jew (A secular one at that) is on his way home from captivity by a bunch of thugs. To all of you who profess to hate traditional religious Jews, let this be a lesson to you!
14. # I will join the dance but stop praying
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.16.11)
15. Gilad Shalit…
BA ,   Sweden   (10.16.11)
…is not yet home. Will he come? Will he be alive? Does anybody but the kidnapers know? Or, is it a matter of "no breira, we'll have to trust them"? …
16. 15 BA, Sweden: Gilad Shalit will meet with IDF officers in
Rivkah   (10.17.11)
the Sinai before the prisoners are released, to confirm he is alive and well and not at the point of death.
17. 9 Lila, Jerusalem, Israel: HaShem hears the blood of the
Rivkah   (10.17.11)
slain who were murdered. The blood cries out from the ground and HaShem hears it and avenges it. He does not avenge it as you would like Him to, immediately, but He does avenge.
Back to article