News
Egyptian reporter: I did not take advantage of Shalit
Ynet
Published: 19.10.11, 12:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
54 Talkbacks for this article
31. Egyptian idiot
dick sterling ,   metula Israel   (10.19.11)
response to 27....................bullshit
32. Darwin award for journalism
Janis ,   Silkeborg, Denmark   (10.19.11)
1st place if there ever was one - for worse ethical, idiotic and heartless interview.
33. He wasn't set free yet so it wasn't the 1st interview...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.19.11)
:^P
34. 29 Do you have any idea what you wrote?
A ,   Belgium   (10.19.11)
Or are you just as stupid and ignorant as your "journalist"? "IDF succeed in makeup op to hide signs of torture," If I understand your poor English, the IDF put make up on Shalit before the interview so that...so you have any idea what you wrote, moron?
35. Dont worry the world will believe you
the mad zionist ,   sf, ny   (10.19.11)
If it was the other way around there would be UN condemnations, arab league emergency mtgs, catherine ashton yelling at israel. But dont worry news woman the heartless, the amti semites, and every single arab in the world and lefty yahoos support and believe you. This is how backwards everything is. People dont even condemn you when they know.youre lying!
36. #27, is it possible the black hole was explosive wired?
noa ,   israel   (10.19.11)
As far as killing those in Gaza, Gaza bombed Israel first, for 8 solid years. Did they really expect that Israel would sit back and do nothing? Did you?
37. If the.hamas militants arm holding shalit down
the mad zionist ,   sf, ny   (10.19.11)
Wasnt enough of an.indocator that it was forced then you need to check your head. Any sensible person is not going to believe her, shes an idiot but not a complete moron. Just look at the.picture and god only knows what else she saw and isnt saying. But.its easy for them to say anything, jew haters amd pro pali people will believe anything they spew or any anti osrael garbage anyone.spews. Jake
38. Hand of Hamas
DocHolliday ,   Trinidad & Tobago   (10.19.11)
This is for you 'the mad zionist', look good again or you need a pair of spectacles....the hamas militant was not holding Shalit down, it was resting on the chair back..... Look again....
39. #36 rockets were in retaliation
observer ,   Egypt   (10.19.11)
The Israeli government steadily sought to break down the ceasefire, not just in Gaza since early November, but also in the West Bank. Israeli forces have carried out an average of 33 incursions, 42 arrests or detentions, 12 woundings and 0.84 killings a week in the West Bank during the ceasefire. On 13 May 1948, Najd was occupied by the Negev Brigade as part of Operation Barak, before Israel was declared a state and before any Arab armies entered Palestine. The villagers were expelled and fled to Gaza. In 1951, the town of Sderot was built on the village's lands. According to UN Resolution 194 and also the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 13, Section 2, the villagers of Najd have a right to return home to their personal property and to their native village.
40. bizarre showing-off
bernardo ,   munich/germany   (10.19.11)
Hqving done many interviews it's clear to me that so-called interview was never ever such thing but a political staging under the auspieces of hamas terrorsit and potential killer in the background. This egomaniac lady, called a journalist, is nothing but a puppet on a string controlled by a masked hamas stooge. How weired, insane, stupid and grotesque this islamo-fascist show was. This bizarre showing-off of this poor boy was the dishonourable ending of five years captivity in terrorist's hand. My friends in Israel, be watchful. This riff-raff doesn't even have a glimpse of an idea what real honesty means, they'r just criminals against humanity.
41. Doc halladay you are right
the mad zionist ,   sf, ny   (10.19.11)
I looked closer, I was wrong, but still a little too close for comfort ayyy. Im sure just the presence of hamas around shalit was enough to intimidate him. You gotta admit though doc, the interview had to be forced,.right? Truth, but then again they could.have asked shalit and he probably would have said yes out of fear. Did you believe the intervoew was the right thing? It was done for two reasons. One to show the naive world that gilad is saying that he is well and is for releasing pali prisoners and 2. To take the thunder away from israel so israel can.score.no.points in the international arena, but 2 backfired, well it should have atleast.
42. ISRAELI DIPLOMATS WERE SLEEPING AS USUAL
David ,   NJUSA   (10.19.11)
omebody in Israel should by this time be smart enough to understand how far more sophisticated our enemy is than our leaders. I understand that Egypt did this for propaganda and did not alert us but somebody in the gov't should have brought an interview issue to the bargaining table beforehand. ISRAEL DESERVES PROFESSIONALS, EXPERIENCED DIPLOMATS WHO CAN PROTECT ISRAEL'S BRAVE AND BEAUTIFUL MEN WOMEN AND CHILDREN. CAN ISRAEL'S LEADERSHIP ADEQUATELY PROTECT ISRAEAL'S VITAL INTERESTS????
43. A CAT TOYING WITH A MOUSE
David ,   NJUSA   (10.19.11)
44. arab interviue
Michelle Wayne ,   Sydney Australia   (10.19.11)
what ells you can expect of Arabs, feelings? they don't know the meaning of it when it comes to non Muslims, lies! lies! lies! from her and the prisoners who where realised.Go to hell! you miserable woman!!
45. He spoke well, despite being under tremendous pressure.
Joe Frazier   (10.19.11)
Kudos to Gilad. He rose above this amateur's unprofesionalism. She belongs on public access TV at best.
46. Even in Romania was clear as daylight
Lou ,   Bucharest, Romania   (10.19.11)
that Gilad was an innocent victim , pale and frightened in strong contrast with the happy animals released from prisons where they were fed and taken care of. I don't have nothing with Arabs, actually I like very much Christian Arabs but where there Islam there is the past, the Dark ages.
47. Note
LoL ,   Uk   (10.19.11)
Who gave gilad this nice shirt? i think hamas was good with him.hhhhhhhh
48. Like it was some sore of game....
Ezra ,   San Diego   (10.20.11)
Amin acted like it was some sort of game, and she wanted to know how it felt to be released now that the game was over. Not at all entertaining. Bad taste totally.
49. She said "you look good Shalit." And go help the Palestinia
Sami ,   New York, USA   (10.20.11)
She said "you look good Shalit." And go help the Palestinian prisoners.
50. Shalit Interview
Michal ,   Milwaukee USA   (10.20.11)
Wake UP Woman! Israel isn't accusing you of this, the entire WORLD is saying this. She needs to examine her tones & inflections which were deplorable. Arab culture talks about this jealousy crap as a way of not being accountable. Try Accountability, It works.
51. Never heard of this woman before
Sunshine ,   Germany   (10.20.11)
and hopefully she will never ever appear on the screen again. Stupid like toast bread.
52. picture of Shalit at egyptian interview
jan ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.20.11)
look closely at his eyes flled with fear and hunched over shoulders! of course, a masked man with a machine gun behind him doesn't make him feel any more comfortable!
53. She must be related to Idi Amin.
Susi Goldstein ,   ISRAEL   (10.20.11)
What a witch. She knew very well that the man was weak and had trouble breathing. This was done to procrastinate - just to kick Israel in the teeth.
54. I stopped watching CNN long time ago
Niels Jørgensen ,   France   (10.28.11)
This is NOT new. CNN and their Parrent Time Magazine is so biased that I have stopped watching / reading them. But Hamas made one major error: After this ANY IDF-soldier will know that Israel will do evenything for them. If IDF was strong before, they are even stronger now.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article