News
Settlers, Palestinians wounded during clash
Elior Levy
Published: 21.10.11, 15:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ugly looking terrain and many stones. But the air is clean.
Michael ,   California, USA   (10.21.11)
2. Why are foreigners allowed to be violent
ACountry Gone Mad ,   Jerusalem Israel   (10.21.11)
What madness allows a country to allow foreign "activists/ anachists whatever to be provocators why arent they deported like any normal country would do ? Israel must be a magnet for every nut in the world because of their "liberal/ananarchy politically correct madness, In the past some of these foregners were involved in terrorist acts like the one in Tel Aviv at Mike's Place where an English "peacnik" was involved. No wonder many citizens here feel insecure now they have to deal with foreign terrorists .
3. if you didnt "live" there
courtney ,   usa   (10.21.11)
it wouldnt happen
4. Disgraceful, but not surprising
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.21.11)
"It's important to note that they came under the pretence of an olive-harvest, but they did not coordinate it with the military or any other body," the Esh Kodesh resident said, adding "these trees are sick and no one has attended to them in over 10 years, that’s why their only aim was to create a provocation." For all the ersatz "Palestinian" oft-stated fantasies of having maintained olive groves and fruit orchards for generations, the above proves the lie well enough. Most of them wouldn't recognize an olive tree if they fell over it. In Israel proper, they recognize fruit trees well enough. Ask some of the kibbutzim how much fruit is stolen annually as a result of Arab pilfering. Disgusting.
5. "an Esh Kodesh resident who witnessed the incident"
split ,   US   (10.21.11)
... a relible witness ;) ,...
6. I believe the settlers version
Israeli 2   (10.21.11)
7. who gains from the violence the most?
Golan ,   Modiin   (10.21.11)
its not the settlers, and its not the Arabs... its the Leftists looking for action.
8. Anarchist tactics known: attack settlers then blame them
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (10.21.11)
The leftist anarchists who organize the Palestinians are known to be provocateurs. Note well that it is not the Palestinians who organize these events, but the leftist agitators who push the Palestinians and help them create a confrontation. The anarchists take pride in the fact that they themselves reject not only their religion, but their country as well. They support the Palestinian propaganda effort, and sometimes simply drive it themselves. It's tough being a 21st century marxist-leninist with no revolution around to latch onto. The Palestinians give the closest local excuse for them to vent their puerile furies. Sadly, the rest of the "left" out there does not disown them or any other radical group that promotes actions against their own country.
9. # Sarah The B..settler..living in USA...
ali ,   villanova -PA -USA   (10.21.11)
Ynet is great for putting up your extreme posts... YOU represent the COWARDS of the extreme RIGHT wing Jewish settlers...who can't live or CO-Exist with anybody...or any where.. KEEP hiding and SPEWING HATE.. Your SARCASTIC tone is always expected.. thank you for sticking your neck out and you do not represent NICE Jews..
10. To: No. 5
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.21.11)
A lot more reliable than any Arab witness.
11. Courtney - then YOU move
Jared ,   New York   (10.21.11)
Courtney I hear the native Americans lived on land that you live on now. How about you move back to Europe where you came from. Even more recently, a bunch of Arabs attacked NYC and Washington. Well - if Americans didn't live there, it wouldn't happen. Your logic is flawed and STUPID. This is Jewish land. No Jews are moving. Get it.
12. Hine Ma tov u ma naim....
Uzziel   (10.21.11)
Wait..in whose side were the leftists?...
13. To #10 Sarah B re #5 Muslim
John ,   Alaska   (10.22.11)
Sarah, he is speaking from a perspective of Sharia law, which says that the word of a dhimmi - any non-Muslim in a Sharia state - is not considered reliable in court. Your people really should realize the danger of the Muslims who are trying their hardest to bring your country back into Dar al-Islam. You really should not allow them to have a foothold because they are trying to turn it into a stranglehold.
14. The situation calls for frontier justice.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.22.11)
As long as Bibi, or someone of his ilk, is P.M., the IDF won't properly protect Judea and Samaria. Thus it is up to residents to organize to defend their communities and administer rough frontier justice to "Palestinians" and foreign Jew baiting trouble makers. They should expect the same reception they'd get if they attacked a Texas Ranger on his ranch. Should Judea/Samaria defenders get into legal trouble for protecting their communities; virtually all of Israel would rise to their defense. They'd be rightly celebrated as heroes.
15. Legal revolution
Philos ,   Herzliya   (10.22.11)
Israel must be the only country in the world where provocation is considered mitigating enough to negate the offenses of assault, assault with a weapon and bodily harm
Back to article