News
Rabbi Motti Elon indicted for indecent acts
Aviad Glickman
Published: 02.11.11, 16:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. let's get this criminal convicted!
(11.02.11)
2. Give me a break!
Gill ,   Montreal   (11.02.11)
If anyone knows rabbi Alon...they know it's one big conspiracy against him. As well they know his actions as a "regular" rabbi don't apply...a lot more open minded and free to act more normal....touching and hugging his students is a crime only when it is for sexual desire. Not in this case. Anyone remember rabbi shlomo carlebach ztl... Well in some area people consider him a pervert. And he was the greatest holy man of our time.
3. I make no judgment about the facts
andyboy ,   Israel   (11.02.11)
but I am curious why it took 8 years from the alleged incidents for a claim to be made. This time element of many years between alleged offence and accusation has occurred in a number of high profile cases Internationally. The Most recent only yesterday in America involving presidential hopeful Herman Cain. Any explanations?
4. Innocent until proven?
Arad ,   Bs As   (11.02.11)
I donĀ“t know why, but I have the feeling that at the end everything would turn out to be a false acusation, they would not find any probe. Buy his reputation would not be restore. Probably this is more related that he is a religiuos zionist and some party from the other political spectrum want to smear him. Some left groups already staged "zionist crimes" by torching with the palestinians olives trees themselves
5. if true : THE GREATEST SHAME IN ON YOU ELON
Scorp   (11.02.11)
criminal !
6. Let the man to have his day in court...
split ,   US   (11.02.11)
... a rabinical court ;) ,...
7. rabbi elon
shaya ,   usa   (11.02.11)
yes, blame everyone except this low life of a man.
8. WHAT NONSENSE
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (11.02.11)
Total bunch of old tosh .Somebody has a serious grudge against the good Rabbi . He has been set up,possibly by anti religious bandits.
9. is he catholic
ramallah ,   ramallah   (11.02.11)
check his background of being chatholic ,
10. May justice be served.
Josh   (11.02.11)
No matter what the case, may justice be served. If he has been framed, what is the likelihood he participated in similar? What is the liklihood the ones framing him (if this is the case) will one day get punished in similar ways? How many unjust shunnings have been perpetrated over the years and gone unpunished? It is said the unseen sins are for G-d. I would rather man punishes than G-d as man has yet to understand how severe a sin adding to Torah is. May justice be served and if he is innocent and his sins found few, may he escape injustice. One law. The last question about justice is Do people who ignore the Torah and send their children into harms way, have a responsibility to recognize a cursed individual when and if they see one? (Devarim 13) If a leader cannot operate in a chose a blessing life, why should one follow his lead?
11. How easy it is to accuse somebody
AB ,   TheRock   (11.02.11)
Everybody who knows Rav Elon knows what a special human being he is. Yes, he is very loving but not in a sexual way. Like he says, his warmth has been misconstrued. Everybody knows he's a warm person and so it is easy to distort reality - there are certain figures who wish they were as popular as he is and have personal agendas. They are behind all this.
12. #2 sit down his peers offered him a deal after...
(11.02.11)
gathering all of the evidence and the cocky fool (oh sorry, I mean the good Rabbi) said "No!"
13. @6 the rabbinical court found him guilty
u r behind the times   (11.02.11)
14. #5 Scorp- Sjhame on YOU!
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.02.11)
You witnessed EXACTLY NOTHNG & are relying on scuttle butt, which makes you a vicous rumor monger who should have hands disabled To be a false witness against our neighbor basically means to falsely accuse someone else of wrongdoing. In the Torah, false witnesses were dealt with very harshly. We see in the above verses that if a person was found to be bearing false witness against another person, they would be given the punishment that the other person would have received if the witness was true! With such a righteous law, we can understand why 'by the mouth of two or three witnesses' every matter truly was established. If anyone rose up as a false witness, they would be given the same punishment they thought to give to their neighbor.... risking their own life! With such a thing facing them, they would be very careful, yes?" "
15. #8 Lawrence in denial
Haim ,   TA   (11.03.11)
Hate to break it to you buddy, but the acusations came from 2 yeshiva students aged 17 at the time of the offence ( your anti religious bandits) . Amazing how you are blinded by what is really going on . The eveidence will be presented in a court of law, and he will be judged accordingly. If found guilty this is a serious crime and highlights the wide spread sexual abuse amongst the ultra orthhadox community. Protectecing a child molester is immoral and you should know better.
16. SHAME ON ALL YOU WHO KNEW
ZIMBI ,   NJUSA   (11.03.11)
17. #15
shadoil ,   Jerusalem   (11.03.11)
get your Jewish goegraphy right man. He is not ultra orthodox, he is dati leumi at its peek. not to say there isnt stuff going on in both camps but dont pin this one on the haredim(ultras) when it isnt.
18. #13 ur r full of bull
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.03.11)
Where and when was the decision of the "Rabbinical Court" posted, I wasn't able to find it, you should have suppllied a link in the first place
19. Would you mind his having a trial
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.03.11)
BEFORE you bring out the ropes to lynch him? Did it ever occur to any of you that the two students making the charges were pissed off because they received bad grades and were looking to get even? It's been done many a time before; students seeking revenge concoct a story to get even for their own failures and shortcomings
20. #18 Haim, put up or shut up!!
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.03.11)
Where and when was the decision of the "Rabbinical Court" posted, I wasn't able to find it, you should have suppllied a link in the first place Would you mind his having a trial BEFORE you bring out the ropes to lynch him? Did it ever occur to any of you that the two students making the charges were pissed off because they received bad grades and were looking to get even? It's been done many a time before; students seeking revenge concoct a story to get even for their own failures and shortcomings
Back to article