News
Barak: I'd want nukes if I were Iranian
Ynet
Published: 17.11.11, 00:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
61 Talkbacks for this article
31. Barak shut up & go home.
Wise Saba ,   Ma'agalim   (11.17.11)
32. Barak: I'd want nukes if I were Iranian
yoav ,   israel   (11.17.11)
1 and 2: Actually I found his answers quite intelligent! If he said otherwise he will be seen as deceitful and cunning. He has no power of giving or not giving “rights” for others to carry out any such activities. It is about time that Israeli officials fix the image of “liars” in the international community. Israel should not divert from being ht symbol of democracy in the Middle East. Arabs are slowly realising this fact and accepting it.
33. So how can you blame Iranians for that?
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.17.11)
and why do you seek new Iran sanctions if you think that it is necessary and important for Iran to have nuclear capabilities ? no logic there, isn't i ?!
34. #1 robert
solomon ,   bklyn   (11.17.11)
Israel has never threatened anyone, and if they were really going to use them they would have, especially during the Yom Kippur War. Iran wants nukes (and supports Hezbollah, Hamas, others throughout the world, and assisted in the killing of US Marines and French soldiers in Lebanon, not to mention supplying the Iraqi and Afghan extremists with bombs and weapons) to start another Caliphate (after they annihilate Israel). These are only ‘details’, right? You always ignore them.
35. top of the website news?
Brian ,   California, USA   (11.17.11)
36. Straight talk from Ehud Barak.
Michael ,   California, USA   (11.17.11)
What the Defense Minister says about Iran is absolutely correct. Iranians are old and proud people. They don't want second hand role and being inferior to anyone. They want to be leaders even if it means bringing the world to the brink. Hello there Israelis, we are exactly like those Iranians, and Ehud Barak deserves recognition for acknowledging the truth.
37. Too bad he's not Iranian.
Chatich   (11.17.11)
We could use a man like him on their side.
38. Silence is golden.Barak has never
Eric.. ,   Israel...(isreal)   (11.17.11)
heard the expression.I just hope that after the next elections, we never hear or see Barak in public service again.
39. Barak is no Idiot
Norbus ,   Jerusalem   (11.17.11)
The man is deluded ; afflicted with a messianic tendency he thinks he can walk on water, especially when G-d is talking to him. He is not psychologically fit to stand guard outside a cinema, let alone be defence minister of Israel at a critical time. He has no principles of integrity either , I have seen him in London begging from wealthy businessmen for his pathetic politics. Idiot, no; a disaster waiting to happen ?? I pray we will be spared
40. "If I were...."
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (11.17.11)
"....a Palestinian, I'd have been a terrorist." "....Iran, I'd want nukes." Well, you're Israeli and, G-d help us, our most decorated-ever soldier! Can you not remember these facts, stop the yucking it up for such poisonous anti-Israel media outlets as PBS, and STFU? If I were Bibi, I'd gag you.
41. #21 Chaim -excellecnt assessment. He's gotta go.
Bernie ,   Erehwon, USA   (11.17.11)
The corruption of the parliamentary process that would put such a dimwit in a place of national power and responsibility needs an overhaul as well.
42. Shame the old and proud Persians need to be disarmed...
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (11.17.11)
so ignominiously. And Ahmadinejad thought he was helping them.
43. Of cause Iran Wants the Nuces !.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (11.17.11)
They would not dare to come for Israel as they intend, without the possession of Nuces. They know they would be Nuked to defeat without a retaliatory Capability. With possession of Nuces Iran dont think any power in the Mideast has the conventional capacity or will to stop them, and that will make Iran achieve its Goal. Arn.Sweden.
44. Nr 2.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (11.17.11)
Barak is none of my favorites but, what he says or not regarding Iran, has no impact or effect on Iran regarding Nuces. Iran is set upon to achieve Nuces because they think they need them för their Religious Goal to come for Israel, this has nothing with Barak to do. Arn.Swden.
45. MR. DM! WHAT ARE YOU SMOKING?
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (11.17.11)
First you say Iran would be dangerous to the world with nukes and then you say you don't blame them for getting it? Are you ok?
46. LET'S REMOVE HIS OFFICE TO ESHKOL
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (11.17.11)
Maybe this way he will shut up and stop giving stupid interviews.
47. #27 KAM
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (11.17.11)
Iranian goverment is a stooge of Russia now, don't you agree? They paraded for 32 years against the great satan "USA". Now, they have to ask for permission from Putin if they want to go to the bathroom. Russia killed more muslims in Afganistan than USA. Where is outcry there? Your fairy tale of free ME NUKES will work in the perfect world and not the world we live in at this moment. A mullah with nukes is far more dangerous than IDF with nukes. Iran is directly arming and helping our enemies. We either stop them or loose a lot of lives on our homefront. Stop dreaming, my freind! Do something about before it's too late.
48. BARAK BLUNDERS !
Mark ,   T.a. Israel   (11.17.11)
1) The RUNAWAY from LEBANON BORDER by night ! 2) Giving the order to stop operation CAST LEAD before we could finish HAMAS ! 3) Planning the MAVI MARMARA in such a manner that we can't still remove this thorn from our ass ! 4) And now the UNFORTUNATE declaration on IRAN NUKES which is very SENSITIVE issue
49. Baraks a strange bird except too bad hes a military genius
Yossi Tossi ,   Boston   (11.17.11)
But Israei is probably safest with him watching over them. He was an ELITE SPECIAL FORCE!!! Hes the bad boy Leroy Brown of Israel. Barak can defeat Iran, Barak defeated the intafada when he was PM Yossi Tossi
50. Stupid is as stupid does
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (11.17.11)
The Mullahs want to subject or kill all "infidels". It's as simple as this.
51. What an idiot!
Observer 1 ,   Chrangbegbo, Ghana   (11.17.11)
I mean, how come so dangerous a psychopath is allowed to be any country's (and especially Israel's) DM at all? This is beyond words!
52. FAD from Egypt is very smart
Daniel ,   Efrat   (11.17.11)
Hello Fad, I like writing to smart people. Are you really Egyptian ? Write me ! Daniel globalbullandbear@yahoo.com
53. Barak's disclosure vindicates Iran
Nour ,   Palestine   (11.17.11)
Iran must and will have nuclear weapons, unless the Zionist Entity gives up its nuclear armament and joins the NNPT. Is that in the cards? Thought so.
54. Ehud Barak, unexpected supporter
Marek ,   Czech Rep.   (11.17.11)
of iranian revolution
55. What is...
aline silverman ,   israel   (11.17.11)
Barak's agenda...?.or maybe he is just " not all there". Remember a while ago he said something similar about the terrorists,,,,,
56. No.13
Ram ,   London   (11.17.11)
When was the first or the last time the USA fought for Isreal? Having trouble answering that? Let me help you. As a client, Israel BUYS tools from the US which it uses to proect itself with.
57. #4 Israeli
(11.17.11)
Thanx for showing your true Jewish colors...
58. #13 chris - you are right
solomon ,   bklyn   (11.17.11)
Yes, you have been saying all along that everything is Israel's fault (ignoring all the wars the arabs started, Israel withdrawing from Gaza and getting rockets in return, etc). And all along you have been wrong.
59. response to #27 in Iran
Ron from NJ ,   Newark, NJ   (11.17.11)
You write: " . . entice those who already possess such weapons to cease threatening Iran." Neither Israel nor any other country is threatening Iran. The only nation in the middle east that is threatening another state is . . Iran! You write: "The region must be void of any enslaved stooge governments who are subservient to outside forces . . ." I guess you mean by this that Iran should stop interfering in the internal afairs of Lebanon, Gaza and Iraq. I'm waiting to see if Iran stops provoking Israel via its proxies Hezbollah and Palestine Islamic Jihad.
60. #21 Chim, Barak is among many that should stay retired.
Michael ,   California, USA   (11.17.11)
You are correct by saying Barak's stupidity as a politician amounts to complete idiocy. While I think Barak is honest in what he said, it doesn't mean I agree it needed to be said by a DM. Barak was among the worst PMs in Israeli history. As a DM he is proving himself, but only when he sticks to the basic work of defending Israel. He should definitely keep his political mouth shut because it is clear he doesn't know what to say and when. Let's face it, Barak is among many poilticians in Israel who came from the ranks of the military after finishing his service. Those "generals" come out with reputation that rarely adds up for a politician's career. Barak would do much better as retired military person than as a soon to be retired (finally!) politician. Likewise for most of the retired military persons like Barak.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article