News
'US mulled commando operation in Iran to retrieve drone'
Ynet
Published: 08.12.11, 09:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let me see if I have this right
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.08.11)
The United States "mulled" a commando operation to recover a downed drone, but rejected it in favor of gifting Iran with technology it could not hope to otherwise acquire. I cannot wait for November 2012. The idiot-in-chief in the White House REALLY needs to go. Or are we still engaging in "hands-across-the water" with Iran while they scream "Death to America" and burn American flags?
2. No.1, ***Sarah***that story is SICKENING !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (12.08.11)
Obama and Panetta are the most despicable slimebags anyone could only imagine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They once again BOW to the mullahs....
3. NO,YOU DON'T HAVE IT RIGHT........#1
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (12.08.11)
As the article is just a guess work on the part of the media to ensure that USA did not totally ignore the loss of an absolute fantastic technology readily delivered.If you,for a moment,are under the impression that USA mulled covert action,be assured that the USA had no clue for the first 48 to 72 hours of the whereabouts of this drone. Besides,we have some intelligent people who tend not to think like you.
4. Obama administration and Israel have different objectives.
Ypip ,   Canada   (12.08.11)
5. #1 Sarah B , U.S.A. / Israel
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (12.08.11)
The Iranians are not even able to reverse engineer indoor plumbings.
6. NO 1
Linda ,   Jerusalem   (12.08.11)
You have the gut to call someone an idiot, pls think before you write. You are the wisest in the whole wide world.
7. IDIOTS - IF IT IS TRUE.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (12.08.11)
I Quote - According to the newspaper, US officials considered sending in a commando team to recover the drone, sending in a team to blow it up or destroying the wreckage with an air strike. Comment - Why dont they have Destruction devises on them. Further - Officials decided not to carry out the missions fearing it would be considered an act of war. Comment - If this is True, those Cowards say they have an Military option against Iran ?. That is all lies. Further - It was hoped the drone had crashed in a remote part of Iran and therefore the remains would not be recovered. Comment - The US has Satelites for to discover the downed Drone and a Couple of Cruise Missiles could destroy it. The Leader of the US is an Selfinflicted Lame Duck at the Least. God bevere of theThoughts of the US President. Arn.Sweden.
8. Nr 1 and 2.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (12.08.11)
Well - there are Prophesies which is interpreted as a Personality called Alexander The Great, who will Conquer the US without War. Those Interpreters says it is Obama. SO - He will sit another Period. Arn.Sweden.
9. The U.S. can always reassemble the
jason white ,   afula,israel   (12.08.11)
neutron bombs that bush had taken apart. Then drop one on the drone during the public display. b.o., panetta and the new head of the c.i.a. are incompetent idiots or are geniuses at helping our enemies.
10. #1 Right on as usual. At every turn the Obama led US gov
Hippocrates ,   Earth   (12.08.11)
is fumbling and bumbling their way in foreign policy. I won't even get into the bigger issue for Americans- the economy. Thx Obama. You've turned friends into strangers, and enemies into greater enemies, peace talks into complete non starters. So much for high IQ winning the day...
11. #6 Linda, Jerusalem
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (12.08.11)
"When I see a bird that walks like a duck and swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, I call that bird a duck." - James Whitcomb Riley The same applies to the Muslim in Chief.
12. NO.11
Linda ,   Jerusalem   (12.08.11)
The fact is that Isreal hate the truth, it always wants to be supported whether by fair or foul means. Gone are the days when certain actions or issues can be swept under the carpet and noone talk about it. Now the ME is on the spot light, and if a nation can not stand criticism, you dont start it.
13. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.08.11)
Well, you have just articulated rather nicely the reason why Israel chooses not to entrust its safety and security to the United States. The United States -- certainly under the current administration -- make the Keystone Kops look like special forces. I now understand full well while certain U.S. military training manuals are published in the form of comic books.
14. To: Albrecht at No. 5
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.08.11)
Well, that would certainly explain why most Iranian homes don't have indoor plumbing. Or, for that matter, electricity.
15. #6, It doesn't take much wisdom to discern an idiot!
Robert ,   New Jersey, USA   (12.08.11)
16. America in decline !
Yisrael ,   Jerusalem, ISRAEL   (12.08.11)
Just another nail in the coffin of a once mighty country ! No one even considered that the drone might fail or fall into enemy hands, so no self destruct was built into it . Wow ! Rest in peace, America ! The rest of us certainly won't !
17. Stop fooling yourselves.
Gabe ,   Canada   (12.08.11)
The US commandos are getting ready. The delay is just temporary. They will be ready as soon as they learn how to tie their shoelaces properly.
18. #5 Albrecht Klein
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (12.08.11)
Aha, but the Chinese can and will They're knocking off so much American technology & software the USA is really hurting It could very well be that the U.S. Administration remembered what happened in 1979, when it when in to Iran to recover or destroy a downed Helicopter, that was a total disaster Besides, it takes Obama at least a week before he contemplates a bowel movement
19. Early XMAS Gift
max ,   washington dc   (12.08.11)
One technological advantage the US had was just "gifted" to Iran which will give Russia and China acess to understand and develop counter measures to our stealth technology. The captured drone should have been immediately destroyed by "whatever means necessary".
20. Drone was hacked
Pedro ,   Brazil   (12.08.11)
If the drone in the video is true, the explanation is that somebody hacked the drone, take control and landed it. I remember that few days ago was noticed that Americans drones were infected by computer virus. Maybe the events are related and other countries like China already were involved in the drone capture since the virus infection.
21. @ 1 bet you never thought you would see this
Sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (12.08.11)
The first I can ever say I would agree with Sarah B. I wouldn't go so far to say I would approve a commando raid, however an airstrike would of been perfect as long as they used the F-22.
22. Agree with #1and #23
Alexander Bernal ,   Panama   (12.08.11)
Obama as US president is the best it could happened to Iran's interest. He lacks of the "cojones" needed to lead the most powerful country of the world.
23. How can Panetta be so dumb?
Samuel ,   Israel   (12.09.11)
Instead of lecturing Israel to sit on the damn table in order to make sacrifices,why does not Mr.Panetta sit on the damn table & discuss with his general staff the importance of the most clssified technology falling into the hands of enimies like Iran,Russia & China.In a situation that occured, Obama & Pannetta should resign & let Pollard free.
24. #23 Samuel
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (12.09.11)
Don't kid yourselv, Panetta is far from dumb, or he wouldn't be in the position is and the positions he was You only have to check out his bio, he's a left-winger, like Obama, from way back
25. Hmmmm - 1+1=2 or so I'm told
Aaron1975   (12.10.11)
Ok, we have a drone that certainly wasn't, by looking at the pics, shot down. Nor did it crash from any height, or at any speed. Quite frankly it looks like it was put down after a malfunction with a view to recovering it. Now, destruction would be the preferred option if it were in Iran, so that is out. If it were in Afghanistan or Pakistan, possibly, a high chance of recovering the multimillion dollar airframe means they'd try it. But it appears someone else got there first... Now, looking at the pictures of it in Iran, it was trucked (that would explain the wings being taken off). Probably not practicable in Afghanistan due to checkpoints, etc. But in Pakistan... The Military is corrupt, treacherous and stupid enough to try it. Let's say it was crashlanded in Pakistan, say anytime in the last few weeks. Presumably the US troops would have tried to recover it. If Pakistani troops tried to prevent them doing so, there would have been a firefight between US & Pakistani troops in the last couple of weeks. If that had happened, it is quite likely that an attempt would have been made to destroy the airframe, probably by an airstrike regardless of where it was. Hmmmm, it isn't like there has been any Pakistani troops killed inside their bases by not one, but two, accidental, cross-border airstrikes (the first in 10 years to hit a base, and then 2 in one night) is there? Something smells funny AZ
26. America in decline
Nahum Froumin ,   R.HaSharon   (12.11.11)
#16: So if America is in decline then it started when a previous Democratic President Jimmy Carter thought he could rescue all the USA hostages at the USA embassy in Tehran with just 8 helicopters. Israel can't go up against any current world empire (Bar Kochba and Rabbi Akiva were the idiots who went up against the powerful empire of the day - and then we lost everything). It's time to learn to speak Chinese and also learn to be respectful and polite in that language. NNF Israel.
27. #5 The truth comes out
Robert ,   Australia   (12.14.11)
"The Iranians are not even able to reverse engineer indoor plumbings". If that's what you believe why are you in a tizzy about Iran producing nuclear bombs? It takes a little more expertise. It seems you and your ilk want to bomb Iran just because her leaders don't like you as it is evident you don't believe Iranians are capable of producing a nuclear device. There are many more states to direct your wrath against if that's what makes your day.
Back to article