News
Iran presents 'US spy drone'
Dudi Cohen
Published: 08.12.11, 19:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
1. this unbelievable somebody must take responsibility and
ralph   (12.08.11)
pay for this including obama for not having the brains to send in forces to destroy it. total in competence and cowardly.
2. treasure trove of high tech info for iran
reza shah ,   tehran   (12.08.11)
Like I said before very soon you will see or "not see" a reverse engineered copy flying over cracking some fire works any time of the year
3. The year's best so far
Golani ,   Israel   (12.08.11)
Hahaha... It's not that we're so smart - it's that they're so stupid...
4.  right time and a wrong time to activate booby trap
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (12.08.11)
Just because an explosive charge hasn't been activated to destroy the drone,it doesn't mean one isn't lurking inside.Maybe it isn't yet the right time to activate for maximum dividend. Strange how undamaged the drone looks after crashing or being shot down.I don't think that I'd be too keen to stand over it. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
5. THERE WAS SOMETHING INTELLIGENT IN THAT PLASTIC MOCKUP???
stude ham   (12.08.11)
lightly injured? any blast against any real drone would have disintegrated the craft... and if not any crash of the drone would have broken it up into useless fragments. this is pure iranian propaganda. why does YNETnews waste its resources on such bull waste?
6. #4 - I hope it's booby trapped
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (12.08.11)
Debka.com - very reliable source of info posted an article that states that Iranians were able to inpersonate / intercept control of the drone and guide it from flying over Pakistan to Iran via Afgan airspace. It was not shot dowwn - otherwise we would be looking at bits and pieces of it. It was guided to land and thus its totally intact.
7. Are we supposed to believe this photoshopped nonsense?
Hakim ,   Palestine   (12.08.11)
8. Why don't the drones have self destructive
jason white ,   afula,israel   (12.08.11)
devices for situations like this? Whoever designed this without a self destruct or whoever approved of it should be fired or court martialed. The fact that b.o. and panetta did not sent in a commando force to recover it or to bomb it from the air shows their lack of intelligence or they just wantto help the enemies of the U.S.
9. maybe fake
moti ,   usa   (12.08.11)
left side wing looks little off than the right wing, could be in the crash left side of the aircraft was damaged
10. Don't Overestimate Reverse-Engineering
Ron Saunders ,   Seattle WA, USA   (12.08.11)
It's can take a very long time. By the time they get to 90% reverse engineered, it'll be obsolete. I hope the US includes auto-destruct in the next design.
11. As I said in my previous post ,to some nut unbeleivers
Merkava Hunter ,   Lebanon   (12.08.11)
that Iran will post picture for that drone.This is a major blow up for the stealth technology and the drone technology developed by US and Israel cooperation.If any plan exist for a potential strike against Iran's nuclear program , the capture of this drone intact , will put that plan dormant for a while. the condition of the done prove it was downed by a cyber attack and not a malfunction as it was claimed . Hopefully that will help us putting down some of the Israeli very soon here in Lebanon.
12. #2 - It has taken 65 years for you . . .
SE ,   Boston, USA   (12.08.11)
to create a nuclear weapon. So I guess you will have a drone in 2075. I am sure it will be state of the art when you decrypt and reverse engineer at that time. US and Israel will have invisible drones by then!!
13. look what's really there
hwi ,   germany   (12.08.11)
both wings must have been cut off and reattached not too successfully. There is a dent on the front of the wing on the right side, there is a hole at the base of the right wing hump, covered by ugly yellow stuff. Why are they hiding the landing gear behind mesh? And look at that crazy redesign of the American flag! It's an amazingly childish piece of propaganda. If you search "beast of kandahar" you'll find a few photos of the real thing and it is very entertaining to play "spot the difference"!
14. Nice Paint Job....
Koose E Mack ,   NY USA   (12.08.11)
Do we send drones out painted in that color? I always thought our drones were gray or black? I hope that this is a hoax...If not, our military engineers need lots more time on the CAD programs! Either that, or we have greatly over-estimated our technical prowess, and underestimated that of Iran, Russia, and China.
15. They might have the remains of the aircraft but not in the
Benjamin   (12.08.11)
i don't believe this is an aircraft hanger (look at the reflective floor) this is rather a local 'gym' or something (also note the walls). , If this aircraft has minimal damage then why is it rebuild/setup in a gym where it probably had to be taken apart to get inside? with the lower half covered up with silly banners ? They might have the remains of the aircraft but not in the condition it is presented/suggest in this way
16. BHO
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (12.08.11)
Barakah Hussein Obama should give Ali Khamenei the key of the Oval Office and step down.
17. reza shah # 2
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (12.08.11)
As another poster pointed out so well earlier "Iran can't reverse engineer indoor plumbing" You can talk the talk Mr. Shah but you can't walk the walk as they say. You guys are all show and no go. Iraq was a good example of that.
18. Shot Down?
Dan ,   Florida   (12.08.11)
For a drone that was "shot down" it looks to be in remarkable condition. Is this a fake mock-up and the real drone was destroyed upon impact?
19. Either a fake, or drone was soft-landed, not "shot down"
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (12.08.11)
If the images from Iran are of a real RQ-170 and not a propaganda fake, its virtually intact state demonstrates that it was guided to a soft landing under full control, not shot down or crashed. The stealth aircraft can not glide when fuel runs out and require constant computer stabilization to be able to fly at all. If the craft was hit by a weapon, it would show massive damage and would have certainly have then gone out of control and splintered on landing impact. The stealth aircraft are fairly fragile machines. If the Iranians captured one this intact, it was not shot down or lost due to control failure, but was guided to a soft landing by Iran [did they hack into the control system, maybe with Russian help?] or was deliberately flown to a landing in Iran by one of the CIA technicians acting against the US [not impossible - consider the Aldrich Ames and Hansen spy rings]. There is no other explanation. An out-of-control stealth aircraft can not fly itself to a perfect landing, they are inherently unstable. The CIA has some explaining to do.
20. The drone is the CIA and the Mossad at work
Maxim ,   FREE WORLD   (12.08.11)
Relax! things will get pretty hot soon. Get your popcorn and beer ready for action packed show time. It will look great on your 60" flat screen TV.
21. #10 Reverse enngineering isn't the top issue here
Merkava Hunter ,   Lebanon   (12.08.11)
Iranian will use this drone as bargain to get from the Russian the log time waiting missile defense system S-300 in exchange to let Russian engineers inspect the drone. Getting these systems will put all your dreams about military strike against Iran to blow up like a soap bubble.
22. Fake! It's a "Horten Ho 229" from 1944.
(12.08.11)
23. Obama gave away American state secrets
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (12.08.11)
to the enemy...he MUST be impeached and put to stand trial !
24. This aircraft wasn't shot down.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (12.08.11)
There is one ding in the wing from hitting the ground in all likelihood. Something interfered with the planes signal or with the planes fuel supply to bring the plane down. If Obama wasn't such a worthless President.......the plane would have already been destroyed by cruise missiles.
25. Iran 4 - CIA 0
Yehuda ,   Ashdod   (12.08.11)
change in the team. IDF enters CIA goes.
26. Maybe it is sending signals back?
Jose ,   Tanzania   (12.08.11)
Insteady of insulting Obama, think that may be, may be, the Americans landed it in Iran to gather more intelligence? I would imagine that the CIA factored the possibility that the drone may fall into the hands of the enemeny. Iran, China and Russia will gain nothing from the drone.
27. RQ-170
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (12.08.11)
Aren't these drones controlled via satellite uplink and encrypted communication? Sounds really strange.
28. USA exported high tech to Iran, free of charge!
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (12.08.11)
Now USA most advanced technology in hands of Iran, besides they are not alone, China and Russia will help them, to reverse-engineer the drone. Turkey should order next batches of Drones from Iran not Israel. Israeli drones were not working and 8 of them sent back to Israel for revamp Soon Nasrallah, Lion of Lebonan will have one private drone to visit Israel! Good job, Congrats USA.
29. Obama's Gambit?!
Z.Z. Coltrane ,   USA   (12.08.11)
Where was the remote self-destruct mechanism. Just another Obama scew-up. And, I think, on purpose so to delay Israel in attacking. If some reports are right, in that this technology could interfere with Israel's plans, then, of course, Obama screwed-the-pooch on purpose! We all know how he loves his Muslim brothers' (freakin' animals)!
30. With friends like the US you are in trouble......
who cares   (12.08.11)
The middle age minded mullahs downed the most sophisticated drone of the US ? If true - Israel should look for other friends than the USA.......friends who are more capable and mainly more reliable than a USA with Barak Hussein Obama as President......
Next talkbacks
Back to article