News  World News
Gingrich: Palestinians an 'invented' people
Reuters and Elior Levy
Published: 10.12.11, 15:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
150 Talkbacks for this article
1. That's more truthful than any Israeli leader up till now had
tom ,   tel aviv   (12.10.11)
any guts to say. Still, it's preaching to the choir and probably, should he be elected (fat chance at that, pun intended) one of the first "ammendmends" he'd embark upon would be Renewal of the Holy Peace Process between the Palestinian and Israeli Peoples! Am I simply too old & cynical???
2. Muslim Brotherhood
Zivron   (12.10.11)
Hamas is the Muslim brotherhood and the Muslim brotherhood is Hamas.They now mus ttt absorb the Arabs of Gaza
3.  Now a Us President Speak The Truth
Tom, ,   lagos   (12.10.11)
It is pleasant to see a Us president speak the truth without regard of Arab and Islamic sentiments. These Palestinian Guys are Arabs, they are not different from the Jordanian,Egyptian,Iraqi,or Saudi Arabs, so why give them a state. Jordan has no identity in History yet it has a state and a king.Only the truth can solve this Israeli- Palestinian conflict and that is that the Palestinians have no right or Sovereignty to the land. They should choose between political autonomy within the state of Israel or immigration to their mother Arab countries where they came from.
4. I hope Obama & Co. are piddling in their pants.
Devorah   (12.10.11)
And that includes the EU, the Quartet and the Arab League.
5. Gingrich.
Michael ,   West Jerusalem/NY   (12.10.11)
This guy needs to realize that he is running to be president of the United States, not Israel. He and all the other Republicans need to stop sucking up to American/Israeli Jews, just to get more freaking votes. He sounds more like of a member of Yisrael Beiteinu, Likud etc.
6. Yet another
Mischa   (12.10.11)
Desperate candidate with no hope trying to get the Jewish vote
7. Jewish votes and money
James ,   USA   (12.10.11)
Incredible what lengths these clowns will go to for Jewish votes and money. The road to Washington runs straight through Tel Aviv, Israel.
8. The Truth???
James ,   USA   (12.10.11)
Gingrich and the other clowns like him will say the World is flat if it will help them attract Jewish votes and money.
9. Most historians?!? only extreme left and revisionists
tf ,   petach tikva il   (12.10.11)
The 1834 revolt was not even remotely a nationalist revolt much less a 'Palestinian' nationalist revolt. However, if one is going to characterize this as the emerging Palestinian consciousness, it must be remembered that Arabs massacred more than 500 Jews in Tsfat. The massacres were characterized by extreme brutality with gang rapes of men, woman and children.
10. I can't remember any other US politician saying the truth
Harry Wright ,   UK   (12.10.11)
PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein said in 1977: The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. It was in "Arab national interest" - to leave the invented "Pals" stateless so they could DEMAND a state. They are nothing more than ordinary Jordanians, Syrians and Lebanese posing as a distinct people. The Arab fraternity invented them as a people and kept them in limbo for decades and entrenched the deception and hatred for generations. The Arabs are just plain GREEDY. The UN and US were collaborators who accepted their fraudulent narrative, sought to provide them with the state they demanded and funneled billions in aid to them instead of confronting them with their lies and demanding and insisting that the Arab creators solve the problem they created.
11. like Obama did before the elections....
Daniela   (12.10.11)
he shows a big support for Israel ONLY because he wants the votes of the jews! once elected he will condemn Israel in everything! we already know the stupid game! I want Bill Clinton back ! NOW
12. "The invented Palestinian" and a mythical
DT ,   TA Israel   (12.10.11)
race - the perfect description and the tool of all haters of Israel and Jews.
13. Maybe Newt could get Eric Cantor to be his running mate.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (12.10.11)
14. Why be surprised? "Palestinians" as a concept came into...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (12.10.11)
being only towards the end of the 1960s and early 1970s. The term of course was put to use by the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) for political expediency. And, the term "Palestine" in its modern sense came into being only in the beginning of the 20th century, denoting a territory - not nationality or a state - carved out of the former Ottoman Empire. "Palestine" consists of present day Jordan, on 77% of the territory, and the remainder consists of 23% of the territory that includes Israel and its territories.
15. Newt has my vote. Long live America!
(12.10.11)
16. An American "fiasco"
Genghis Kahn   (12.10.11)
An invented people?, cela va sans dire ".And so was/ is the current President of America --- a failed experiment of a US citizenry in dire need of a leader then; a miscalculation and a flop of enormous and unforseen proportion.
17. I like people with guts
Isac   (12.10.11)
and Gingrich mostly showed that he got them. I am sick of people who want to be politically correct. He appears to be a straight shooter. No need to say that he is just looking for Jewish voters. He may actually mean what he says which is a rarity among politicians. Gingrich for President!
18. NUTTY NEWT declares me an "invented" woman!
Claire ,   Paris, France   (12.10.11)
and my family in Jerusalem since the year 900 is an "invented" family! This is new kookism - even for nutty Newt.
19. Jewish lobby and US politics
John ,   New York   (12.10.11)
Amazing and crazy what these people are capable of saying to win the elections and once elected they all revert back to mainstream which is already 100% pro israel.
20. Finally
Steve ,   USA   (12.10.11)
All the Republican candidates are pro-Israel (except Paul the Isolationist), but Newt just vaulted into the lead (in more ways than just leading in the polls). This guy will get my American/Israeli Jewish vote. Finally a politician with big balls. #5 and #6 Obama lover, #7,#8 -idiot Jew hater and most likely Paul supporter, #11 another Obama lover, the truth hurts, Gingrich will be the next US President. He tells it like it is. There is no need (Reuters) to call what he said 'controversial' as the US Arab vote is extremely minimal and they vote for Obama anyway. I'm sure your -Reuters- compadres in the mainstream media will also jump on your wagon and try to condemn him or telling this historical 'fact'.
21. # 2 Yes !
Jules   (12.10.11)
Egypt must restore Egyptian citizenship to the Gaza residents. They are Egyptians, and their Mother Country had betrayed them. That's nasty. Freedom to the people of Gaza ! They must be allowed to resettle in Egypt.
22. Canaan/Palestine before America colonies invented 1776
Palestinian   (12.10.11)
23. Thus -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (12.10.11)
I Quote - "I think that we've had an invented Palestinian people who are in fact Arabs, and who were historically part of the Arab community. And they had a chance to go many places, and for a variety of political reasons we have sustained this war against Israel now since the 1940s, and it's tragic," he said. Comment - Yes !!!. However - According to the Word of HASHEM there is a Palestinian People in Gaza Esajah 11 14But they shall fly upon the shoulders of the Philistines toward the west; they shall despoil them of the east together. They shall lay their hand upon Edom and Moab, and the children of Ammon shall obey them. Arn.Sweden.
24. #11
Nation ,   Israel   (12.10.11)
Unlike our current president, Newt Gingrich has been involved in politics for a very long time, he has strongly supported Israel long before he decided to run for president, and if you don't remember he was the speaker of the house under Bill Clinton. Newt was the mastermind behind many of Clinton's accomplishments. Daniela it's ok to be an American Jew and vote for a Republican, regardless of what you've been told.
25. Gingrich for President !
Analyst   (12.10.11)
the first one to say the truth !
26. Bless you for speaking the truth !
who cares   (12.10.11)
27. Newt and Abu Mazen
Jasmin ,   Haifa   (12.10.11)
I certainly agree with Newt Gingrich here. What baffles me is the article's "explanation": Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas has long forsworn violence against Israel... I don't recall his forswearing violence against Israel, but he *has* put it on hold for a while since that's politically expedient at the moment. The Palestinian Charter, AIR, calls for the destruction of Israel. How is this not violent? He just *looks* better in comparison to Hamas.
28. Gingrich for President ! He's more Zionist than Netanyahou
(12.10.11)
29. Remember Obamas fine words in Sderot.He hasnt been bak since
Alan ,   SA   (12.10.11)
30. 11 Remember Bill has been a "consultant" to Arab State SINCE
Alan ,   SA   (12.10.11)
Next talkbacks
Back to article