protecting this turd..that makes me screem. To my sons..come home..enough of this BS..they dont deserve you there. They dont respect your values of nation, people and true grit. Come home...you will do better in a Canada. I have had it..This was my last straw.

We shall be a persecuted minority in a sea of haredim, fanatics, Arabs and parasites? And you were former IDF intelligence chief? How many thinking like you are there? If there is only one more, it is one too many.

Now, get the H- - - out of Israel! You are are no longer needed. What a shamefull Sinat Chinam!

A few radical settler youth threw rocks at IDF soldiers but wounded no one. For this Saguy wants them shot. Palestinians have hurled razor sharp rocks at IDF soldiers at Bil'in and wounded 130 since 2010, with some soldiers seriously wounded just a week ago. If the IDF shot at them Saguy would likely demand their court martial & imprisonment for their 'crime'. I also notice his complete failure to ever utter any protest in the media when the Palestinians injure or kill IDF soldiers or civilians, or to call them terrorists. For leftists like Saguy, Jewish blood is seemingly worthless unless it's from ultra-leftists, while the blood of Palestinians who attempt to murder Jews must be spared. He invited Yehoshua Leibowitz to address "my soldiers" because he fully shared his philosophy. Leibowitz referred to IDF soldiers as having a Judeo-Nazi mentality, and advocated the surrender of the Golan, the entire West Bank and much of Jerusalem including the Kotel to the Palestinians, in exchange for nothing. For Saguy, this outlook and prophecy is 100% on target. Saguy ends his article with “terrorists should be shot”. It’s clear from his record that to be fully accurate, his statement requires the addition of the words “provided they’re not Palestinians and only Jewish settlers.”

we hear you

I am proud to have fought in the Six- Day War. I am not proud of Jewish supremacy fanatics with their messianic mission. In '67 none were fighting with us. I agree with Saguy completely. Jewish terrorists, like Arab terrorists, should be shot.

Uri Saguy incites here to assassination and should be arrested and treated as a criminal. The place of criminals like Uri Saguy is behind bars unless they are let out roam free in the society and perform put into practice their criminal thinking.

You are a consummate fool. If you agree that all terrorists should be shot, just imagine the body count at Bilin. And define "terrorist," please. I do not think that a Jew living in greater Medinat Israel meets the definition. You, like Saguy, would probably be much, much happier living in Ramallah. Why not move there? You'll have a shelf life of a few hours. Do you realize that?

#30. Judea and Samaria are not only the more than 3,500 year old ancestral heartland of Jews. Judea and Samaria legally belong to Israel. Countless international law experts have proven this incontrovertibly. Avramele, your "morality" is a fraud. It has nothing to do with Judaism. Nor Zionism. It is far left lunacy in a very thin disguise. Elections and polls prove the vast majority of Israeli Jews know the difference. Almost 80% of Israelis oppose ceding our ancestral heartland, according to recent polls.

what do we do about all those settlers living in Tel Aviv on occupied arab land. I say in the name of peace, expel each and everyone of those occupiers. Show them no mercy! I will be happy to come to tel Aviv and assist the soldiers. I want to live in peace with our good arab neighbors.

when you said that it is too late to save mentally ill, leftist lunatics from controlling Israel for the past 60 and some years. That boat is indeed sinking...and it will sink deep never to surface again. But there will be a better Israel as a result of return to the Torah and its ways. Not destruction and chaos as you so much fear. 1) The Israeli Supreme Court will go 2) The Knesset will go 3) Only Torah loving Jews in favor of greater Israel will be allowed to serve in the new IDF.

Beauchard is not even a Jewish name I am secular you Moron I disagree with a lot of the extreme religious views but this is about the right to have secure borders and our right to settle and have our religious sites on land that is legally Israel's under International Law read Eugene Rostow. Constant giving up of territory have led to more war not peace but you want a Civil War when there are politicians in Israel who are probably working for the American Government who would love to see one.

This man is instigating a civil war and should be immediately fired and tried for sedition against the state of Israel. What an incredible danger such a person is. Don't think that many in the Israeli public don't know, plenty do. While I would never justify violence on either side, this article you wrote is criminal, is this what you want, to shoot other Jews, more extra judicial hits? I call for calm and sanity, stop fighting, stop antagonizing the right and as for the right, stop the price tags, both are a hilul HaShem and extreme danger to our country and I bet obama is luvin it.

For instance, frequent live fire at the demos that happen every friday?

The settlers are wrong in attacking TSAHAL who is their mother - Yes,it is. But to dare to write that settlers should be shot at is at best a sign of unfathomable stupidity.

Morals Schmorals . There is nothing moral in jews being cheated out of their inheritance i.e their land .Your moral compass sorely needs recalibrating.

At least we learn where YNet stands and to whom it listens......Media-works have long ago become a sort of prostitution and a tool for manipulation. Nazi Germany showed it very clearly : propagande is a core issue odf those who seek control.........

"I fear these domestic threats more than I fear the Iranian threat. At this time, we are in the midst of a messianic, delusional process that is violent, belligerent, intolerant, and also un-Jewish." You are afraid of a few religious Jews who had a little riot more than you fear the prospect of a nuclear Iran? I may not be religious, but for gods sake! What on earth is this idiot talking about? Israel was founded to be a JEWISH state, not a Hebrew speaking socialist Switzerland in the Middle East. It may be considered "Un-Jewish" to advocate the murder of fellow Jews that have a different religious and political outlook on the subject. Throw this moron in prison were he belongs! Not because he is a secular leftist. No no, put him in prison for a good reason: incitement against citizens of his country.

We should learn from our mistakes in the past and we lost against rome because we were not united and quarrel each other with the consequences that we lost our independance and were spread among the nations.Am israel stay united and nobody can destroy us.

Why lump us all together because of a few hot heads. there are 6 or 7 million people here and these nutcases are less than a percent.

Mr. Saguy, you seem very concerned about the settler violence, and you conveniently lump all settlers with the radical few that attacked the soldiers. You are wrong on many points: 1) You voice not a word of worry about the Left wing radicals who attack soldiers as a rule, not an exception. 2) From the reports of the settlers this was an unexpected moment of rage. And most of those there were not settlers. 3) Excessive force was used against the settlers in Amona. I'm surprised this doesn't satisfy your blood lust. 4) There was an immediate protest against this behavior by other settlers at the military base. 5) I wonder if the usual Shabak agitators weren't the ones who instigated the violence. They are notorious for edging on some radicals and then framing all settlers. As an intelligence man you should know this well. 5) Why should the settlers sit quietly as they get kicked around all the time for a bogus peace process? Why are we destroying the settler homes to begin with? And how would you react if Peace Now filed a phony petition to have you evicted from your home in Tel Aviv and the left wing slanted unelected judiciary sides with them and then the military goes ahead and bulldozes your home to appease some fraudulent Arab landowner?

jews are being punished more harshly than arabs and for less--dont shoot anybody just expel arabs to arab palestine which is jordan and maybe some leftists to new york!

I cannot believe ynet would publish such incitement.This is a very,very ugly article.

Where's the line between terrorist and patriot? And who is who in this story? Depends who you ask, but if you ask me I wonder why anyone would be surprised that people would react to their homes and communities being destroyed in middle of the night blitzkriegs by goons in black flak jackets and no ID.

Agreed. Also he should be incarcerated for all the Jewish victims he caused with Oslo.