News
Turkey accuses France of genocide after Armenian bill
Reuters
Published: 23.12.11, 21:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
31. Erdogan is Absurdly Childish: Outrageous
iNetFraud ,   USA   (12.24.11)
Personal attacks on the Fench Presidents Father!? Calls of racism & islamophobia!? Over recognition of the Armenian Genocide!? Pathetically Purile & Sophmoric. How anyone can take this man seriously? He is unfit for leadership: an ignorant, childish fool with tremendous emotional weaknesses. But as the saying goes: Karma is a bit€h. His payback will certainly be "Koranic". Lol!
32. what do israel wait to recognyze the armenian genocide ?
dovdevan ,   ashdod,paris   (12.24.11)
we as jews shoud support the recognition of the armenian genocide not because we have bad ties with the turk but because this is a moral duty
33. By the way, Turkish media
Yosi   (12.24.11)
has found a way to blame the Jews again. Pointing out that Sarkozy has Jewish roots and Ottomans had welcomed them escaping from Spain, they blamed ``the people`` for being ungrateful to Turks and being enemy of the Turks.
34. War Crimes in Armenia and Algeria - guilty on both counts.
Max   (12.24.11)
For sure the Turks committed war crimes during their withdrawal from Armenia in WWI, but so did the French in their war against Algerian independence. Maybe when Erdogan and Sarkozy were not responsible, then they should grow up and take retrospective responsibility. But that's no excuse for the French to pick on Turkey for crimes of genocide when there are plenty more present day candidates that fit the crime.
35. #11 blindman
(12.24.11)
The address you posted is chock full of facts showing that the "Pal" stories about being forced out of their homes, etc, are false. Example You just shot yourself in the foot. Congratulations.
36. #6 vlad, #14 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (12.24.11)
The Algerians and Vietnamese were fighting the French, remember? The Kurds were not fighting the Turks but they still killed them even though they were defenseless.
37. It's funny...
esnuffnstl ,   USA   (12.24.11)
...because it's not about us-oh, and because it involves France in a diplomatic hissy fit. Cheap entertainment, if nothing else.
38. Erdogan the failure
Arctodus Simus ,   Kodiak- Alaska   (12.24.11)
When that "moderate" islamist take power in Turkey, Erdogan wanted a big change in Turkey traditional policy. He turned a could shoulder to the US during the second Iraq war, change its stance toward Israel, invested a lot in warming tie swith Syria, Iran and Gadaffi in Lybia, as he wanted to shift from west to east, and give amore islamist turn to his policy. But after a few yaers is policy is atotal failure. Turkey isolated itself loosing its change to integrate Europe, weakining its support in the US, putting Israel in the arms of cyprus and greec, thus isolating itself of the western mediterranean countries. Gadaffi fell in Lybia. Syria is in turmoil and caused a refugee problem to Turkey. Key Iranian officials threatened to launch missiles at Turkey. One can said Erdogan only succeded to isolate its country by its policies.
39. well
pini   (12.24.11)
Sarkosy is pathetic but so is ergdowan
40. These "great" political leaders look like big children!
Jouko ,   Finland   (12.24.11)
It is amazing how these proudful political leaders behave - not even simple truths they cannot admit! In trying to save their faces - they lose their credibility. Politics seem to be a great game for 70-year old children.
41. Napoleon "hero" killed a generation of Frenchmen in his wars
Jouko ,   Finland   (12.24.11)
And he is still considered a great HERO of France - how senseless the French people seem in their judgement!
42. Leaders today : little boys who yell insults at each other
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (12.24.11)
43. there are big differences
observer ,   Egypt   (12.24.11)
1. Armenian men joined the Russian and French forces to fight against the Ottoman Empire, whereas Algerian men joined the French army as soldiers to liberate France from the Nazi enemy. 2. Armenian gangs slaughtered many Muslim Ottoman citizens (More than 520.000 Turkish and Kurdish civilian to be exact), whereas Algerian men sacrificed their lives for the French. 3. Armenians attacked the Ottoman Empire, whereas Algerians fought to aid France's fight for liberation from Nazi rule. 4. Some Muslims did kill some Armenians, but not because they were Armenians, but to take revenge for their relatives slaughtered by Armenians cooperating with the Russian and French forces. Furthermore, the famine that had hit them affected all.
44. Blowback.
Spengler ,   USA   (12.24.11)
Erdogan perhaps might be accurate. But it looks to me, that the Algerians are taking a healthy revenge. You see plenty of Algerian youth standing around smoking and spitting on the streets of Paris harrassing pedestrians in their native tongue while having their hands out for L" assisance from the french Govt. I cant feel too bad for them as I live near LA, which has an immigration problem of its own...
45. # 13 what bottle are you drinking from
ben   (12.24.11)
The Armenians are a peacfull non violent people. Other than Musa dash [ 40 days of] and that was a defensive stand, You won't find them suicide bombing or fighting back like the American Indiand or the Palastinians. They certainly do not have caches of weapons or militias. The only thing they are fighting for is the recognion of the Armenian Genocide. A genocide that the State of Israel denies and works verry hard to remove it from history books. Please google [ Israel Turkey and the politics of Genocide. It is the official policy of the State of Israel that what happened to the Armenians was not Genocide Affirmed by the President of Israel Peres. Is that what you are doing RIVAKH
46. 33
anton ,   ist turkey   (12.24.11)
israel is not a friend of turkey anymore and will be treated as such thats normal as for being ungrateful it doesnt matter that much at this point turkey wont help jews again i belive ;)
47. #36 CORRECTION 'Kurds' should have read 'Armenians'
solomon ,   bklyn   (12.24.11)
48. #34 max
solomon ,   bklyn   (12.24.11)
The French are not picking on the Turks, which I define as serious accusations regarding a not too important occurrence. They are righting a wrong in recognizing a major slaughter of Armenians by Turkey. Many would say that if France picks a present day candidate, it would still be Turkey due to their attacks on the Kurds. (Yes, the Kurds have attacked Turkey, as the Algerians attacked the French. The Armenians had not attacked Turkey.)
49. #16
jared ,   Oromocto Canada   (12.24.11)
michael, just remember this...people who live in glass houses love to throw stones , erdoghan, sarkozy, heck im canadian and im willing to be we have some dirt in our closet too, admit your mistakes apologize for them and move on were in the 20th century guys let the past go and apologize, forgive but never forget
50. ERDOGAN RUNNING OUT OF
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (12.24.11)
Running out of countries to bash and have a go at.
51. No 43. And Egypt expelled 80,000 Egyptian Jews
EgyptianJewishRefuge ,   Ex. Cairo, Egypt   (12.24.11)
No 43. And Egypt expelled 80,000 Egyptian Jews.
52. Turkey murdered 1.5 million Armenians
Sami ,   New York, USA   (12.24.11)
Turkey murdered 1.5 million Armenians. The first Holocaust of the 21st century.
53. I think both...
Jewish Patriot ,   Galut   (12.24.11)
I think both the French and Turks committed genocides. And not only against the Armenians or Algerians, but they both conquered the half world and cultures, nations were disappearing cause of this. France nor Turkey have no right to condemn Israel and the Jewish people, and when they say that Israelis do genocide to "Palestinians" that is the biggest hypocrite behavior and lack of knowledge. We only want our little and ancient land so they better shut up when it comes to the Middle East issue.
54. What about the atrocities Turkey committed in Cyprus?
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (12.24.11)
We all hear of the horrors of the Armenian Genocide by Turkey which started on April 24, 1915 but we seem to forget the horrors committed by Turkey in Cyprus from 1974 to the mid 1980's! Turkey was condemned for Human Rights Violations, Genocide, Ethnic Cleansing and violations of basically every Human Rights Convention since 1948! Maybe someone should give Edogan a computer so that he can too also Google ans see the dreadful crimes committed by the Turks in the 20th Century which is still going with Turkeys human rights violations against the Kurds to this day!
55. #52: You mean the 20th Century, I think.
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (12.24.11)
56. to vlad and solomon
shahrazed ,   annaba,algérie   (12.24.11)
read algerian history then speak ,the revolution of the independence began in 1954 and erdagan talk about genocide of 8 may 1945 wich left 45 people dead mostly unarmed teenagers in three days
57. Don't hide history
Ronnie ,   Israel   (12.24.11)
Where Moslems have killed "infidels" ie. Jews and Christians or Moslem it is quite acceptable to them. Where others have killed Moslems that they consider a problem.
58. #56,
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (12.24.11)
one dead is too many but 45 dead people you don't call genocide.
59. #33 my friend anton
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (12.24.11)
We do not need friendship, we need to be alone. It is better for us being indiferent. Your goverment is fighting like don Quixote, and will end up like him. Let see the list. Greece, Bulgaria, Armenia, Israel, Cyprus, Kurds, Syria, Iran, and now France since Erdy is in power. We do not need any friendship from a country that will explode in its economy at any time from now. The list is too long, my friend ( good cuban coffee, smell delicious) and it is time to realize that France law may have domino effect and in a shor time Turkey will br isolated like you mr moustache told about Israel. There are differences between turks and Israel. Turkey needs attention, Israel needs security. Enjoy turkish coffee
60. The Erdogan school of learning how
(12.24.11)
to win friends and influence people! The biggest loosers usually make the most noise when they feel they are loosing it completely.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article