News  Mideast News
Iran: We have proof US behind assassination
Ynet
Published: 14.01.12, 14:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. Dont Cry Tears For Him
Noah Lev ,   LosAngelesUSA   (01.14.12)
"To the best of my knowledge", wha? Is that a denial? The US reporters on this have had a field day, with Israeli dismissals as vague, therefore possibly an admittance. Hillary's response was more appropriate, if not an outright lie. I mean get real. Would Israel, the US or most other nations admit what is an act of war? Let sleeping dogs lie. That scientist knew the dangers inherent in his work, just as police and firemen. Lots of people have motives..the Kurds, Iranian dissadents, Iraqis, Saudis..you name it. Blaming the Jews is routine in these matters. His death, like that of Saddam, Mammar and soon Mubarak..is good for the region and good for peace however. Dont cry any tears for him. Applaud the culprit.
2. Its Again 1933 With Ahmad Instead
Noah Lev ,   Los Angeles USA   (01.14.12)
Iran has threatened retaliation and provoked its peopleto seek revenge against Israelis and Americans. They areitching for a conflict Thats obvious. When the US/Israel/Britain will coordinate an attack however is problematic? Threatening to kill citizens of any country is an act of war. Iran's rebuke of 4 UNSC resolutions re: uranium are major violations, all which should have been responded to by our carrier fleets, combined with British and Israeli warplanes and cruise misiles. Or do we want to wait (like Korea) until they have actual bombs..or the ability to make them overnight? Its like 1933 all over again, but this time with Ahmad vs Adolp and the Rev Guards vs the SS Same thugs and murders. , hell bent on violence and death.
3. killing...
montymoose ,   los angeles usa   (01.14.12)
Most USA citizens deplore targeted murder of any kind. In some cases, those who are resposible for the deaths of thousands, Machievellian means are a necessity. A sciencetist does not fall into the above catagory. Never the less, in my opinion, IRAN, has absolutely no standing to complain about violence. They have sponsored murder of more "innocents" , used their own children as bomb carrying martyers, and appear to put an uncaring god of blood and vengence as their idol of worship. Iranian government has no place to complain about their populace being targeted, their own actions bring these action back on to their own. They need to remember that all the blustering will not scare the USA. If necessary, IRAN as a country could be oblitered by the USA, but we do not blame all Iranians, just the governmental leaders. Threating retaliation is like them saying their prophet will avenge them. My take, .. The GOD of the BIBLE, is the only true God, ..all others are a n imitation, powerless, worthless actually a shame. Of course, all are entitled to follow whom they chose.
4. Proof..or prejuducial pretense?
John ,   Boise, ID USA   (01.14.12)
Even so called "proof" can be made to look, or even "appear" to point towards anything their superstitious and fanatical minds may conjure up. .As a result of their own personal prejudice, in the eyes of the beholder, the "proof" may even point towards their own "inside" dealings. After all, haven't the Iranian people have had enough of their dictators and this is the "next step" in the process?
5. yes its true
rashid ,   palistinian   (01.14.12)
i just come back from teheran what giving them all documents proof that amrica is what done the deed me tell you dem tings are true believe me never tell you lie
6. Pulease !
Jon ,   Youngsrown, USA   (01.14.12)
It apears to me the USA is being pulled inro a war by Israel again. You want anti semitisim to stop ? Leave us the hell alone ! You are only creating more enemies
7. Iranian "hit"
graczek ,   Maryland, USA   (01.14.12)
This was a gross crime of aggression and a clear violation of international law. It would not surprise me, however, to read of operatives from Iran doing an action on US territory to teach imperialists a lesson. Apparently they learned nothing in 1953 and 1979. Such an action would indeed be deplorable, but perhaps justified under the circumstances. Turn's about fair play!
8. #7 graczek re: #3 montymoose
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.14.12)
If you really believe that "turn about's fair play", you would enjoy reading post #3 montymoose. Just part of post #3 (in case you don't wish look):
9. #6 jon
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.14.12)
We (the US) have enough of our own reasons for wanting to stop Iran from building a nuclear bomb. If they succeed, a very many other countries will also begin the process. Israel is worried; so is the US. And yes, antisemitism is linked to Iran getting the bomb, but in a different way; they want to annihilate Israel. Antisemitism will not stop if Israel stops looking after its own interests. Antisemitism will stop when people like you stop blaming Israel for others' faults and evil intentions and support the right of Israel (a Jewish country the size of New Jersey) to exist.
10. If you need anyone to blame...I'll take the blame.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.14.12)
Good riddance to the Iranian nut and his religious fanatics that he aids .....with weapons of mass destruction. Religious fanatics don't need a weapon to indoctrinate people to their cult.
11. Iran "proof" of US hit on Nuke Scientist
Ernie ,   Millersville, USA   (01.14.12)
Two motorcyclists placing magnetic bombs on the car? The CIA and the Brits don't have that kind of style and class. This was the Mossad, without a doubt. Iran already blamed Israel, so they may as well blame the US and UK, too.
12. darn C.I.A. leaving documents for the Iranuts to see!
Jerome ,   Basalt, Colorado   (01.14.12)
such a great and justified hit on another isalmist iranut job and they leave all the papers for the them to find! I like totoally hate whEn that happens!
13. Rumor has it...
Uncle Samuel   (01.14.12)
... that the hit was an Iranian job. There are native Iranians working against the cruel Islamist regime that is now in place and crushing their people. Iran pre-dates Mohammed's concocted cruel, totalitarian, unjust, misogynistic, racist, violent, aggressive, war-mongering, politico/religious system by many centuries. Islam's welcome tends to wear thin after a while... like about 5 minutes max.
14. speculate is all anyone cann do
mark ,   usa   (01.14.12)
It is easy for Tehran to make charges, such charges would not be unfounded. However it just as easy to make the claim that scientist was killed because he was in contact with western intelligence, was discovered and kill by the revolutionary guard for such activities. Can not have one of their own caught red handed betraying the state. That would call into play the whole idea of the foundation of the islamic republic. however by killing him, his death brings him back into the fold for use by the state.
15. Iran's accusation would be credible if they had evidence
John ,   NZ   (01.15.12)
16. false flag
tevye ,   Colorado Springs, US   (01.15.12)
Of course the documents were probably Israeli forgeries.
17. Yes, let the war begins......
Peter ,   kl   (01.15.12)
Ya, the scientists know the risk and this applies on both sides. Well just don't get frustrated when the Iranian says... the red line is crossed and all die on both sides and we can call it "legit". Remember, until now which side is the patient one. And remember too... Iran is ready and had lost 1 million men in the Iran/Iraq war when they were weak. Today ... they are more powerful than all in ME including Israel (minus the nukes). So like you say ...make this legal? sick .
18. What are Israel's real motives?
Robert ,   Australia   (01.15.12)
Stop lying about what Ahmedinejad said about Israel, stop lying about their capabilities and listen to the CIA and the IAEA and stop letting Israel and AIPAC dictate US foreign policy ?
19. #18 robert
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.16.12)
1. In a public address on IRINN TV on June 2, 2008, Ahmadinejad stated: “The Zionist regime has lost its raison d'être. Today, the Palestinians identify with your name Khomeini, your memory, and in your path. They are walking in your illuminated path and the Zionist regime has reached a total dead end. Thanks to God, your wish will soon be realized, and this germ of corruption will be wiped off.” Google this if you are not too lazy. Or if you want more you can find it yourself; there is plenty. 2. Israeli capabilities are secret. 3. Prove your statement that Israel and AIPAC dictate US policy. Israel is the size of New Jersey, Jews are in the minority in population and Congress. 4. Yes, someone should stop lying. Look in a mirror.
20. #19 - Item 1
Robert ,   Australia   (01.16.12)
That's a revelation. If that's all the basis of wanting to attack Iran, Israel also would have a problem with many other countries. By posting that you have admitted that Iran's alleged wish to "wipe Israel" off the map is a complete fallacy.
21. #20 robert
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.16.12)
Read my post again. He clearly threatens to annihilate Israel, a threat made more real by Iran’s strive for nuclear weapons. You have also not answered my item 3. By not doing so you admit there is no basis in fact for your statement. By posting you have admitted that any pretense you may have of paying attention to facts is a complete fallacy.
Back to article