Opinion
Modern-day Jewish hero
Giulio Meotti
Published: 25.01.12, 11:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. He was CIA
David   (01.25.12)
Dangerous line of work.
32. a brave person
anton ,   Ist turkey   (01.25.12)
Indeed, killing an innocent person only fits to cowards
33. well written tear jerker but I agree w/#1
Amos ,   Israel   (01.25.12)
My brave Israeli heart would rather go down fighting my enemy to the end instead of proclaiming that I am a Jew! I am bound to my Land and I will defend her to the death!
34. what is this goyishe dribble....
(01.25.12)
I can feel for myself thank you very much and don't need a non-Jew looking to sell his book to tell how to feel!
35. don't you just love it when the world loves us for....
(01.25.12)
so easily becoming dead impotent Jews?
36. He is a hero.
nibor ,   israel   (01.25.12)
Heroes are heroes for many reasons. He affirmed his Judaism in the midst of the worst conditions and fear, and by doing so, showed solidarity for all of us who are still alive and still making sacrifices for eretz Yisroel. We don't always know why we should remain Jewish, and probably neither did he, but he knew it was important. That is a hero.
37. #!4
Texan   (01.25.12)
@14 Joshua !!!! I can not Belive you !!! Daniel Pearl it is our Heroe !! He is Jewish and a Human being !!! You need to read his book !!! Remember jashua what his last word was !!!! G-D Bless his soul ! We the Jewish people and Am Israel ALLWAYS REMEMBER DANIEL PEARL!!! to you from a ZIONIST Am Yisrael Chai !!!!
38. according to normative Jewish behavior...
Carolina ,   in my mind   (01.25.12)
he affirmed his Judaism which for me is as good as saying the Shema...however he's not a hero "just" another modern-day Jewish martyr. Perhaps if Mr. Meotti were Jewish he would be able to understand the difference.
39. 24 Oh Really
Kwanku Dai ,   New York USA   (01.25.12)
A hero would have shown no reaction to them. Show hatred or any reaction ?? Thats just what they want.
40. To Ehud #9
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (01.26.12)
When a person has no real idea about how to debate someone's personal stance, they always turn to "CHARACTER ASSASINATION".
41. Reply to #12 Maurice
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (01.26.12)
Just because a man decides to walk in harms way, does not make him a "HERO". Speaking of wants, I want to see you make ALIYAH, and come live with us, we who face daily the chance of being abducted by our enemies. Is it possible that he did not fully take into consideration the dangers involved, and the hardship imposed on his family ? Just to write one more article to be read and discarded about our enemies, or perhaps in pursuit of a literary prize for his writings.
42. MEOTTI'S VICTIM WORSHIP
Frank-el ,   Seattle USA   (01.26.12)
The mercenary "journalist" Meotti is up to his old tricks again of Jewish victim worship. With all due respect to the Pearl family, Daniel was at best extremely naive and at worst recklessly foolish. His death was predictable given the circumstances. How could a father and husband voluntarily place himself in such an insanely high risk position? Was it blind ambition to get his name on the WSJ byline that drove him to deliberately put his head in the lion's mouth? He was "western" - major factor risk; he was American - major risk factor; he was Jewish - yet another major risk factor. It's like racing a Formula 1 car blind. Why seek a known terrorist in hostile territory that was sought by the police..an activity that could be even illegal? Although his killers didnt act like humans, he's no hero in my book. Perhaps Mr. Meotti could do a better job of remebering this horrible murder with better balance and perspective deserving of a journalist and not a cheap propagandist.
43. He died as a Jew, but did he live as one?
Dan ,   USA   (01.26.12)
If it serves no other purpose, Daniel Pearl's brutal murder should serve as a lesson to Jews who think that by proclaiming themselves to be "at home in the world" or "citizens of the world" that they are somehow immune from Jew-hatred. Did Daniel Pearl have any active connection to his Judaism before he read those last words at knifepoint? How could any self-aware Jew travel to a place like Pakistan in search of a newspaper story on Al-Qaeda and expect not to be sniffed out as a Jew? He was a tragic victim of a horrific crime, and he died for being Jewish, but I would hesitate to call him a hero.
44. a victim or a hero
(01.26.12)
any one was killed by an enemy becouse of his race or his religion only is a victim but any one was killed by the enemy becouse he was a hero is a hero
45. No Danny Pearl would have been a hero
jason white ,   afula, israel   (01.26.12)
if he showed up at an I.D.F. induction center at the age of 18. Those that served honorably are heroes and heroines.When you are born in Israel, you are expected to do your duty. Too often we make a big deal out of draft dodgers and their success overseas.
46. most stupid talkbacks yet on Ynet
John McNab   (01.26.12)
For those of you with reading comprehension problems here is the gist of what this article about: ''But the barbarous murder of this American Jew, who was married to a beautiful, young French wife and expecting his first child, Adam, didn’t awaken global public opinion to the most significant truth of our times: Today, every Jew in the world is on the frontlines of war.'' ......... the article is not about whether Pearl is a hero or not. If Meotti dropped the word ''hero'' from the text it would change the subject of the article in the least. Ynet sure does attract some morons.
47. Thank you for the info!
redbourn ,   arad israel   (01.26.12)
48. Danny Pearl
michael Pielet ,   israel   (01.26.12)
What a waste of a life. Danny should have reaffirmed his committment to the jewish people by marrying a jewish girl and having a jewish child. Why is that so hard. Be a simple Jew, live a Jewish life. Have committment to the Jewish people. Danny appears to have been a very bright adventuresome young man who because of his lack of Jewish identity put himself in a position in Pakistan dealing with Islamic terrorists were overjoyed to murder the Jew Pearl. Heroes are those people who put their lives on the line for the Jewish people. They serve in the army, they live in Judea and Samaria, they live in israel. They and only they are Jewish heroes.
49. 48- about commitment.
ronit ,   haifa   (01.26.12)
Commitment to judaism is commitment for peace. Living at Judea and Samaria isnt heroic . We should prefer enlightened people, living where ever they can contribute to humanity, like Daniel.
50. I would like to add
Joe ,   Newtown, USA   (01.26.12)
Eli Cohen , Hannah Senesh to these and many other men and women who gave their lives on the alter to defend and proclaim AM ISREAL CHAI , We will never forget them and honor their memory .
51. #41 Seve Goodman
Maurice ,   Montreal   (01.27.12)
You're all about judging people. You know nothing about my life ( I spend 6 months every year in Israel, and I am very familiar with the dangers you are talking about) and you know obviousy very little about Pearl's life. But you are ready to jump to fast conclusions and judgements. That is all I will respond to your talkback.
52. Maurice
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (01.27.12)
Wow, I believe you are a bit "TOUCHY" about your life.....WOW just 6 months a year....I guess we should call you a "HERO"....a part time "HERO"...when are you going to become a "FULL TIME HERO"
53. Sorry for you,small person
(02.07.12)
How much more xenophobia can exist in one person?
54. The narrowmindness of Chaim
(02.07.12)
What does his wife have to do with how Daniel defined himself? Leave the box behind and start thinking like a human being. And regarding the child, don't you think that at one point he will choose to define himself without your "help"? It is called growing up into a persona for himself, which is the full right of everyone. Who are you to deny this from a grieving family, or the dignity of the fallen . In fact, Daniel had more integrity and Jewishness that you will ever have.
55. You are Wrong 48.... So Wrong...we Jews are about Humanity,
Dina ,   USA   (03.20.13)
Compassion for Us AND all of G-d's Children... Wake up and reach out to ALLl not just your own, ten you to will be living a life of a Hero or Heroine. Tomorrow you should buy a gentile a coffee,,, such silliness
Previous talkbacks
Back to article