News
UN wants end to West Bank demolitions
AFP
Published: 27.01.12, 21:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
84 Talkbacks for this article
1. "Extensive human suffering"
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.27.12)
Well, illegal construction -- done without official building permits and professionally-done sewer, gas and electrical connections -- can cause a great deal more human suffering if the building collapses, killing its occupants, or there is a gas leak, a faulty electrical connection or a badly constructed sewer line fouls fresh water. Then, a lot more people will suffer. There is a reason why construction permits must be issued, and Arabs are not exempt from the requirement. They only THINK they are. That said -- on the subject of "extensive human suffering," why doesn't the United Nations focus on North Korea? Iran? Syria? To name but a few. With each passing day, the United Nations becomes more of a laughingstock.
2. sir,
(01.27.12)
what is your humanitarian view on what is happening in syria now? don't you think this issue of 7.000 dead in syria by a butcher leader is a bit more pressing that a palestinian who built him home illegally and needs to have it dismantled????
3. Human suffering? Like the stack of dead bodies in Syria.
Cynic ,   USA   (01.27.12)
4. Disband the UN . Now.
Jules   (01.27.12)
5. I FORGOT
....DACON9   (01.27.12)
WHOSE LAND IS ISRAEL? ISN'T ISRAEL A SOVERIGN NATION? WHY did Israel ever begin to negotiate with any of the worlds intruders to get into this position of answering.
6. human suffering
daniela ,   panama, panama   (01.27.12)
The UN talking on human suffering... is going to sleep in fortified rooms in Sderot considered human suffering? I think that the UN forgot what is human suffering a long time ago, but, since it has to give the appearance of doing something they look for anything. If it was really important the human suffering, they will find it in Syria, in Paquistan ,in Iraq, in Nigeria, Somalia, etc. etc. etc...But I believe that when the word Israel appears in any report it makes the UN look serious. Please ..give us a break....
7. When the UN rids hell'sbullys of rockets
then the world ,   will listen   (01.27.12)
8. Human suffering
Arie ,   Minneapolis, USA   (01.27.12)
Sending a criminal to prison is also imposing suffering. Deporting illegals causes suffering. The question should be is that suffering fair? If you break the law, you will have suffering caused to you. Why aren't they bringing this up?
9. Only Jewish suffering counts to some Jews
Mark ,   Detroit USA   (01.27.12)
Being Jewish means you show concern for other people's suffering. If you can't do that, you are a failed Jew.
10. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.27.12)
Israel is a nation of laws. Building any structure is ILLEGAL without the requisite construction permits and approvals. Your comment is absurd on its face.
11. STOP DEMOLITIONS
UNCLE JOE ,   CONN USA   (01.27.12)
ONLY WHEN THEY BEHAVE LIKE HUMANS AND UNLIKE VICIOUS BABOONS SET AND HELL BENT ON DESTROYING THE OTHER. END.
12. lets make a deal. stop building on my land and i'll stop des
ralph   (01.27.12)
destroying your building.
13. UN
Sam Tayar ,   montreal   (01.27.12)
I once built, without a building permit, a small structure behind my residence. I was forced to demolish it. I also know someone in Soviet Russia (or was it Communist China) who built without a permit. He is still in jail. I guess he was lucky........firing squad would have been much worse. Moral: If you want to build without a permit go to Israel. You have a 50-50 chance of getting away with it, pay a $100 fine or getting reimbursed for your efforts.
14. to Sarah #10
Ed ,   USA   (01.27.12)
Your comments would have credibitily if the laws both in Israel and in the occupied territories allowed Palestinians to obtain permits and accepted the proof of ownership that was used before 1967.
15. Ban Bans Illegal Homes, While Syria Burns
Noah Lev ,   LosAngelesUSA   (01.27.12)
The Arabs will say almost anything to blast Israel in the eyes of the world forums. Assuming they are right, and Israel wont give them permits, hows about Israel proving once and for all its procedures, and take away their specious arguments. I am sure, Israel gave them ample warning beforehand..of the pending demolitons..but, as with the perfidy involving the 10 month "freeze" on building, dismissed by Abbas, the Arabs choose their fight carefully, knowing Israel is tired. I read somewhere that the govt offered the Pales tens of thousands of housing, along with apartments for Jews. No word on that, typically.In Syria, hundreds of thousands of people are being killed, wounded or inconvenienced by a dictator, yet Ban bans Israeli legitimate actions.
16. So what if young children are suffering?
ZionistBecky ,   Israel   (01.27.12)
G-d did not give them the land. Sucks to be them and it rocks to be part of the Chosen People.
17. 1-Sarah B
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (01.28.12)
And look where the UN is situated-in good old USA.And Who gives more money than other countries to UN? It's high time that the American people fixed that horrible problem.The UN is a useless mob of idiots and an enemy of Israel and the US both.
18. 16
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (01.28.12)
ZionistBecky,your post is not good.Think before you post.
19. Arab suffering equals human suffering?
Lenya ,   Australia   (01.28.12)
What about all the Jewish homes demolished and razed and Jewish families left homeless by IDF and police? Why isn't the UN saying anything about that or aren't Jewish suffering considered human suffering by the UN?
20. Occupied territories?
Lenya ,   Australia   (01.28.12)
Occupied by whom? We all know that Palestinian Arabs really are the settlers in the Land of Israel. Palestinian Jews are the true historic owners of so called "Palestine" which is really called Israel of the Hebrews. (formally Canaan)
21. THE SO-CALLED LAND/STATE OF ''ISRAEL'', THE PALESTINIAN PEOP
A WONDER-SJ. R. ,   MULTIVERSE   (01.28.12)
PEOPLE AND SO ON... ''ISRAEL'' WAS/IS ALSO THE NAME OF JACOB FROM THE CHRISTIAN BIBLE. IT IS MORE THAN TIME THAT ALSO ''ISRAEL'' RECOGNIZES A STATE FOR THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE. THAT ''ISRAEL'' MINDS IT''S OWN INTERNAL ''ISRAELIAN'' BUSINESS, FROM NOW ON. VIVA THE ENTIRE UNITED NATRIONS ORGANIZATION, THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE AND EVERY PEOPLE A.S.O...
22. have to keep that "poor palestinian" thing going or soon the
rachel ,   usa   (01.28.12)
there won't be any more money for these 60 years of refugee status....(give us a break !!!!)
23. To sarah B
Jimi ,   palestine/Ramallah   (01.28.12)
Its amazing how you turn the isue up side down. UN knew that homes were built upon engineering standards, BUT ISRAEL IS MIS BEHAVING IN AREA C which is 62% of west bank, and rejecting to issue building PERMITS. Don't make yourself selly more...
24. #16 Amen! (Hashem is great)
(01.28.12)
25. Put an end to antisemitic UN ! Dissolve it !
who cares   (01.28.12)
Arab leaders are massacring their people and threatening to wipe out other nations and this insane, ridiculous institution is just talking nonsense while wasting a lot of money from taxpayers......Stop the UN now ! Dissove the UN ! UN is UNnecessary and antisemitic !
26. Bad Vibes
Zivron   (01.28.12)
27. #14 Spot On...
Nour ,   One State   (01.28.12)
Sarah will surely not address your post. On the other hand she lives in New York (One of those Israel Firsters) hiding in a basement , and hasn't woken up yet. The rest us of actually live in the Middle East and our lives will never be her chess pieces despite her constant warmongering.
28. They Deserve Nothing, Get It
Noah Lev ,   losangelesUSA   (01.28.12)
To Ed: okay, so lets be fair and go back to the 49 and 67 Wars. After 48, no Jew was allowed by Jordan, which used grave stones for latrine flooring, etc. Everything Jewish was destroyed. 2 states were offerred, one Jewish, the other Arab (Muslim) Arab attacks effectively made null and void the partition...creating disputed lines, which still exist. Lets assume the Arabs won in 48,678 or 73, would any Jews be allowed in? (Abbas says YNET to Israelis living in the new Palestine). So much for racism. The Arabs gambled in 48/67 and lost. The property prior to 67 was often falsified by the Arabs. When there are final borders, all this will be settled. assuming Abbas and his cadre of liars and thugs ever appreciate Israel's gestures. Frankly, he deserves nothing.
29. # 10 It's funny
John ,   Hamilton, ON   (01.28.12)
and typical that Jews are apparently not subject to the laws of Israel.
30. Israel's bevaviour is indefensible....
Robert ,   Australia   (01.28.12)
....and it lives under the delusion that a higher authority approves it. Disgusting!
Next talkbacks
Back to article