Jewish Scene
Nude images hung in religious J'lem neighborhood
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 10.02.12, 14:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
31. 29 Sorry,but i don t know why.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.11.12)
Anyway,you know perfectly that if i did hurt you,it was not intentionally. Very sorry if i did so.
32. 29 Charles you are a great pro in ...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.11.12)
Jewish history,and you are degrading yourself with the kind of comments you write here. I am quiet sure you could find a fine way to contribute to Israel.
33. #25 - it doesn't matter if it's a reaction to a provokation.
Henry from New York ,   USA   (02.11.12)
It will still provoke a reaction (hence provok-ation). As #24 says, you guys, and when I say you guys, I mean everyone taking part in this nonsense, regardless of religious affiliation, need to get your acts together and stop behaving like children. It is embarassing to see grown Israelis acting like this. The secular, religious, and kharedi Israelis all need to learn to live with each other. None of the groups are going to vanish in a puff of smoke and each adds a great deal to the country. You guys need to receive a positive education about each other and try to cooperate for the good of Medinat Israel. I am all for having a shtetl set up in Poland though and deporting the sikirim to it though (or at least strongly encouraging them to leave). They're responsible for most this anyway and are forcing their ways on everyone, religious and secular. They're just generally awful.
34. #17 They stare at your painting all night
rebecca ,   Modiin   (02.11.12)
I wonder what they do when they go home after all that "inspiration". If you want people to stare at naked women, good for you. I find it insulting, degrading and a few other things that would make this post be excluded.
35. No doubt, when the Haradim retaliate,
rebecca ,   Modiin   (02.11.12)
It will be all the Hardims fault because seculars, like Arabs, are such nice people who would never mean any harm by their actions.
36. 30JK The extreme freedom...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.12.12)
of morals in the secular society is part of the problem. Extreme disease asks for extreme remedy.
37. Haaretzian Gerostrates win! Torah and Boticcelli burn.
Miron ,   USA   (02.12.12)
38. #3 Michael - I am glas you enjoyed it
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
The question is, why didn't you display it in Mea Sharim for all to enjoy? Don't you think that you displaying it so that only you could enjoy was rather selfish on your part?
39. #4 Yaakov - Fantastic Idea
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.12.12)
Why not start with pictures of the females in your family, for all to see and enjoy Mother, Wife, Daughter, Sister, any relative of female gender Grab you camera, start snapping away, you can print them on your Brother, Epson, or whatever printer you have available
40. Couldn't you come by the real thing ?
Ish Kabibble ,   Delancey   (02.12.12)
I bet you know where all the porno shops are at where you live Don't forget the lotion for you hands, you'll avoid blisters when you use enough
41. #6 its not medieval but 18th century
golan ,   modiin   (02.12.12)
their clothes are 18th century garb, their education is pagan, their knowledge of Jewish history is nil, their ideology is full of lies and they have a right to their stupidity just like Sa'ar in Big Brother does to his stupid ideas.
42. THIS IS SPARTA!
david ,   israel   (02.12.12)
43. Posters
Enoch ,   Toronto   (02.12.12)
When God created Eve, was she fully clothed? Is it offensive to look at God’s creation?
44. Ora , Why ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.12.12)
Simply because i prefer another way to discuss . A] When you give a great compliment to a disgusting liar and hatefull racist , your compliments to me have lesser value . B] You were "beloudigd" because i did'nt answer your : What is BB . I was sure that you knew it , you're NOT dumb , and made a joke with this question . Now you know the "why" of muy silence then . C] did you read my "qui aime bien , chatie bien" ? Was adressed to you , in my discussion with this "vogeltje" . D] don't give me a name , My father ZL gave me a Jewish one , don't need more . Have a fine day my dear .
45. Golan 41 , i know , but it's the whole
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.12.12)
that is medieval .
46. Incitement. Thats not cool
secular guy ,   Israel   (02.12.12)
47. #25 reaction to provocation
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (02.12.12)
In the US, you have black people moving into white neighborhoods. This is a provocation, so they burn these beautiful crosses on their lawns in reaction. In Holland, you have gays kissing in public, provoking their Muslim neighbors. So the Muslims make the gays lives unbearable until they move away. This is a hate crime, nothing less, and if Arabs were victims and not Haredim you would see mass arrests and police violence.
48. 44 Charles,i need to feel that...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.12.12)
you trust me.to continue to discuss with you. You offended me by saying that i am a lier.You should have known better,since i always admitted my mistakes,and did not hide what was not in my advantage. When i make compliments,i mean it. Concerning the TBer you mention,our opinion about her differ. It breaks my heart to witness that the marvellous Neshama from such a fantastic guy like you,is Has Vehalila,on it s way to getting lost,if not connected to G-D.I wish you find an openminded genuine orthodox Rabbi ,from whom you can learn,what the Tora is all about.Get the facts straight, then you will know what you are talking about,and your decisions will have value. Of course,you run the risk at 120, to find yourself in Gan Eden for ever,and ever.....
49. Small potatoes
Observant Jew   (02.12.12)
This kind of action is a pathetic joke. I have a better idea: Tomorrow no more welfare payments for people able to work, and everyone under 25 reports immediately for military or national service (men and women).
50. 49 By trying we can easily find...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.12.12)
ways to correct wrongdoings. Other men s i mean
51. Well, that should make their payyos stand up!
Yitzhak ,   Israel   (02.12.12)
52. Right challenge, wrong way
JewishHeart ,   Israel   (02.13.12)
It is right to challenge the Haredim in Kiryat Yovel. In this once secular neighborhood, just like once Morrocan traditional Bet Shemesh, The Haredim start buying houses, renting them out, and then moving in before anyone notices they are a mass element. Give them five years and they have completely become a majority in a once secular neighborhood. Then they start bullying, and those seculars that are left move out and leave a few secular radicals to defend what was once a secular city/neighborhood. The traditional/secular heritage and founding of the city/neighborhood is lost forever to thugs who took it over. We need to protest, but posting naked pictures of women is not the way to protest....Women are to be respected not as meat, but as human beings. I wouldn't want my mother or sister's pics being posted everywhere. Maybe a documentary about all the once secular cities that were taken over by the haradim to warn people about future takeovers. They are already trying it now in Ashdod and in Arad (Hassidi Gur). Give seven years and once secular Ashdod and Arad will be Haredi....fight, but protest respectfully, dont lower yourself to their level.
53. Challenge them the right way.
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.13.12)
As a minimum: 1. Take away all the special special financial privileges, such as large families welfare and stipends to students who do not prepare for gainful employment. 2. Make working and service to the state an essential requirement of every citizen, military service included. 3. Every citizen will be required to pledge allegiance to the state of Israel, a state in which State and religious institutions will be separate. 4. Write and ratify a constitution stating that men and women are equal, and abolish the rabbinical court.
54. Ora
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.13.12)
The "trustworthy" was about the information given in this wikipedia article , not about the book i think . And , if only ONE said it's trustworthy , don't rely on it . But i'm sorry , had to say : you made an error , maybe because you wanted to react rapidly . How can you , who's not hatefull , not telling knowingly disgusting lies , say that such a person is great ? I remember four of her big lies , some even very disgusting . And without saying sorry , i was wrong . Please don't talk about my "neshama" , i'm not getting lost at all . You are , and i hope you will encounter some day a fine secular person who will show you what it means : LIVING . I'm NOT a candidate . Don't think that a "gan eden" exist , it's only something invented by people who want others to behave correctly . There is NO proof of it existence , nobody returned from there . Try to make YOUR Gan Eden HERE , while you live , ad 120 of course . You know : better one bird in the hand than ten in the air . What the Tora is about ? very easy : Ve'ahavta et re'echa kamocha . Nothing more .
55. 54 Charles
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.13.12)
I do not agree with you about the person you mentioned.I think she is very smart,has a golden hart and defends Israel skilfully [I am not aware that she lies.] Yes,Charles,you are absolutely right,the Tora is all about: Veahavta et re eha kamoha. That is not that natural,and Tora training is a huge help. For instance,the tora learned me to seek good in people. I think that you have a golden heart,Charles,that is your nature. But you can t enjoy people that are not perfect. This shortcoming,you could easily overcome by studying Tora.I could write a book ,how Tora improves our love to neighbours. I have not always been Haredi,and i know the Secular way of life. When i say that Haredi are living fully their life,i know what i am talking about. I had thanks G-D wonderful years with an outstanding husband.We were two halves of the same soul.At 120 i hope to join him.Another husband, as you suggest,could only disturb. I wish you from all my heart,only good,Charles. Have a fine week.
56. #55 ORA, A very nice personal note.
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.13.12)
You are a soul lost in the desert because you know not Nature and what we know from science, but you are honest. Those who follow your comments know to appreciate your honesty. You are a good person because you believe in humanity. This you retained from your chiloni days. However, you are a confused person because of what you don't know. To compensate for your lack of knowledge you reach out to the Torah. This is easy to do, but a major mistake on your part. You are a good mother and grandmother. You have sacrificed your brain for those who are not worth it.
57. 56 Michael,most orthodox people..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.13.12)
are for Tora and for Science. In the modern society,there is a lack of humanity,and that s why i think we should all reach out to the Tora.
58. Ora , your "study" made you blind . TRY # 3
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.14.12)
You don't see how some can be hatefull towards people with whom they disagree . See the TB's after Barak's 70 th anniversary . "i don't wish him good" "go with your hero to the other side of our northren border" by your "great" one . Lies ? i support the pedophile priests , or , "one priest has maybe saved , against payment , a Jew during WWII . That's all by this same person . When you defend something don't do it with lies , insults , distortions and racism . Jews have suffered because of people using such words . Smart ? maybe , but certainly not a MENSCH .
59. Ora , 57 Don't exagerate please TRY # 2
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.14.12)
You wrote : Most orthodox are for tora [ yes ] and for science [ ????? ] Maybe you , Thanks to your education . But those who are going ONLY to religious Jewish schools don't see very much science . For them the earth was created only some thousand years ago , not million of years , They don't show the human body , Where is the science then ? If they don't reeive it atr school , they can't be "for it" as you wrote ,
60. 58 Charles, I am very vigilant...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.14.12)
to keeping my own many flaws in control,and have no motivation to keeping busy with else s. Charles,believe me ,your time is to precious to waste on observing evil,on which you have no control.With your great skills you have better to do. Keep well.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article