News
'Israel should annex 60% of Area C'
Moran Azulay
Published: 23.02.12, 13:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
1. it makes sense where have he been all
Moses Mafora ,   JHB, SOUTH AFRICA   (02.23.12)
this time? he must go tell the stupid UN that.
2. That's Ariel in the picture
dovy ,   uk   (02.23.12)
3. Israel must grow in size...
Jules   (02.23.12)
as much as possible, simply because she is the only civilized country in the Middle East.
4. {Plan
michaelpielet ,   israel   (02.23.12)
This plan makes sense, however NEVER GRANT CITIZENSHIP TO ANY ARABS RESIDING IN JUDEA AND SAMARIA. These arabs can be citizens of jordan.
5. I am all in favor ...how about you Guys ?
AlbertoGA ,   St. George, USA   (02.23.12)
The UN and the World will not agree ! And what did they do in WW2 Massacres in Europe of us, Hum ! And now that Israel face idiot Monsters from Iran where is the protection of the WORLD for Israel. Blah, blahs . . .that is all.
6. This is the only logical direction if we want to survive.
tom ,   tel aviv   (02.23.12)
All that's needed now, is for the Lunatic Israeli Left to aquire additional IQ points in order to be able to comprehend this (not so complicated) issue!
7. What a stupid dangerous idea
avi   (02.23.12)
if there is no clear solution to an issue it does not mean implementing one out of desperation...egypt to annex Gaza and bring the muslim brotherhood even closer with a whole country behind them..wow..what stupid idea
8. Hebron is the birthplace of Jews and Judaism.
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (02.23.12)
Muslim Arabs should go to Jordan - the 2-state compromise, or else Jordan must be held accountable and the Balfour Mandate restored. Jordan has been in violation of the only condition of its creation, responsible for the deaths of 1000's.
9. West Bank Solved
Dan ,   Florida   (02.23.12)
If we take the bold and logical step and annex the entire West Bank the problem is solved. The Palestinians can all move to their Seaside Resort of Gaza where they may live under the enlightened rule of Hamas. ANNEX ALL OF THE WEST BANK NOW
10. This is the best we can do for now
Yossef   (02.23.12)
11. What about Area B? I say Annex
Joe Sombrero ,   USA   (02.23.12)
What about Area B? I say Annex Area C near the 67 armistice line is not enough to defend Israel with real borders you need to annex areas of Area B if not all.
12. Yes yes and yes already!
Hippocrates ,   earth   (02.23.12)
13. BREATH OF FRESH AIR
JEWDI knight ,   AMERICA THE BEAUTIUL   (02.23.12)
FINALLY A PLAN THAT DOESN'T RESULT IN ONE GIANT GESTURE TO THE INVENTED ONES...at least ISRAEL doesn't get the dirty end of the stick...as far as Egypt taking back the gazans...terrific ideas...it's their people and their responsibility to begin with. also NO SUCH THING AS "RIGHT" of return...can't return to someplace you've never been to begin with... this puts a whole new complexion of the middle east , and a new perspective on the arab squatters who will rocket and poison the lands they can't steal.
14. bennett's plan
alexi   (02.23.12)
they will get used to it asbennett says is spot on. In fact, arabs respect israel more when it is aggressive and press its claims whereas they mocked barak and olmert's concessions and demanded more.and guys like dennis ross and obama should not take positions and stay the hell out of negotiations to be neutral referees. Ross talks rubbish from his UCLA training like kurtzer,s ame story, 2 phds disconnected from reality. while there are virtuallyno anitiquities from canaan times, and since most of the relics are israel which bothers arabs as they have little archaeologic claims to the area, what do readers say about arab argument that they descended from canaanites and that israelis stole cannaan land. What arguements do you have to rebut this argument that arabs current day in the west bank do not come from cannanites?
15. who is worse, the muslim brotherhood or hamass???
jewishness ,   NYC, USA   (02.23.12)
YES, they both suck. But the brotherhood almost recognizes Israel and HAMass doesn't, and won't. The brotherhood/egyptian army works in the background with Israel, there's some cooperation...with hamass, there's nothing but ignoranuses and hell.
16. Bad Idea! Let's not do it!
Israeli2 ,   Israel   (02.23.12)
17. SECURE BIG ISRAEL, Sinai back, nonviolent transfer, BALANCE.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (02.23.12)
18. No such thing as "West Bank". Only Judea & Samaria!
Mike   (02.23.12)
19. just like the pre-ware Nazis-Russia deal
observer ,   Egypt   (02.23.12)
20. Israel should annex all of Judea & Samaria.
Chaim ,   Israel   (02.23.12)
The bottom line is the bigger Israel is; the safer Israel is. Had Israel kept the Sinai, for example, Iran and other enemies could not think of us as a "one bomb state". From now on, Israel's policy should be that whatever we win in a defensive war is ours forever. No more concessions. No more retreats ever.
21. HE'S WRONG! IT'S GOTTA BE 100% OF C!
stude ham   (02.23.12)
to heck with this arcane idea of how much of israel's lands we're allowed to have. no longer will we accept foreign invaders to steal our lands. BUILD ISRAEL BUILD!
22. NB most of these TBers r Messianic Christians....
(02.23.12)
falling all over themselves to get to their war of Gog and Magog which according to them we are meant to fight for them. Real Israelis DO NOT want this as a solution FORGET ABOUT IT!
23. Area c
johnny ,   norway   (02.23.12)
i used to live in area c before i moved to Norway. if i had Israel id i would stayed in Israel.. i wish Israel take over area c.. i would come back and live in Israel..
24. #14 Alexi
Devorah   (02.23.12)
Canaan is not mentioned in the Qur'an. There is one mention of the name, "Arab," in the Tanakh. It was a town called "Arab" in Joshua 15:52 which was in the vicinity of Hebron. If they were decended from the Canaanites, they would not reference the name, "Arab." Perhaps they were Arabs who moved to Canaan at one point in time, but that does not make them the descendants of the Canaanites. Look, they would say they were descendants of the planet, Neptune, if it meant getting a free ride. The bottom line is that they don't know who they are or where they came from.
25. Lets steal as much as we can get away with....
Edithann ,   USA   (02.23.12)
TATA
26. What would ever compel Egypt take over Gaza?
leo ,   usa   (02.23.12)
27. Make Edypt take Gaza in exchange for continued US aid
Charles   (02.23.12)
If Egypt doesn't want to take Gaza they can do without the money (and they NEED the money).
28. 60%?
Jew ,   Canada   (02.23.12)
Talk of fools! 60%? G-D gives his Jewish people Israel 100% in a 6 day war, and 45 years later the fools talk about 60%. This is what infuriates G-D; the Jewish people received the Torah with the land! Who else received the Torah can claim the land!
29. Edithann @ 25, correction. No steal, but return.
leo ,   usa   (02.23.12)
30. stop the occupation !
Noor famous activist ,   Gaza   (02.23.12)
Next talkbacks
Back to article