News  Mideast News
Report: Israel won't warn US before Iran strike
Associated Press
Published: 28.02.12, 08:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. #30 Michael
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (02.28.12)
Do you think Iranian ICBMs are in the very own interests of the USA?
32. SpyPutz 11- do you still claim that
Stephen in New York   (02.28.12)
Israel has no "comparative advantage" in weapons development? All your posts are rooted in ignorance. Israel will always have friends in the world.
33. No big deal
Aldo ,   Brooklyn   (02.28.12)
The US will know as soon as the Aircraft leave the hangars if not sooner
34. #19 Roxy
David ,   USA/Israel   (02.28.12)
If you haven't done that already, you are very foolish.
35. Keep it Secret
Brod ,   USA   (02.28.12)
Israel's defense against existential threat should be kept secret. External forces are only interested in sabotaging Israel in defending herself against those hellbent on destroying Israel. They want Israel to be a sitting duck to Ayatollahist nuke. Israel can tell them to go to Hell.
36. To number 19, get ready
Israel ,   Texas USA   (02.28.12)
You want Israel to tell you to be prepared! what do you think all this is? You and all the citizens of Israel, should prepare, with extra rations, and prepare their bomb shelters. Then just go as normal, if they wheren't needed, good, if they are needed you are prepared.
37. Usa is not a friend for peace. Usa is
Moshe ,   Usa   (02.28.12)
a state that was founded for the benefit of its citizens to have economic control of its destiny. Usa citizens patronize themselves by saying it was founded for liberty & freedom; but it was really founded to escape the tyranical taxes of the crown of England & to broaden their sales of their products to France who helped defeat their mutual enemy, Briton. Free nations must defend their economic liberty. Therefore, Pres obummah is not Israel's friend.
38. US trying to avoid potental Muslim anger?
Joe ,   Canada   (02.28.12)
It is not likely that the US would be kept uninformed by Israel. Even if this was so US intelligence would likely detect the preparations required for a strike on Iran. The more likely objective of these declarations might be to avoid getting US standing in the eyes of the muslim world from deteriorating further by giving the appearance of non cooperation. This was one explanation for the Libyan EU strikes which the US refused to directly participate in. Israeli declarations may also have internal political objectives to reassure the public & maintain government unity.
39. #32 Oh yeah? Please list...
TaylorT ,   Earth   (02.28.12)
...all of Israel's friends. Have these friends given Israel tens of billions of dollars and helped Israel avoid world condemnation in the United Nations Security Council? This is a rhetorical qustion, of course. Israel has only one friend that (as Obama said) 'puts up with it.' If Israel keeps acting like a spoiled brat (by, say, attacking Iran without giving the US notice) then Israel will lose this friend. This wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing (for Iran and others who hate Israel, that is.) Some of you really want to spend another two thousand years without a state, don't you? Just keep acting the way you're acting and it's a done deal.
40. ISRAEL, IRAN...
SJOERD RUURD ,   planet eRTH   (02.28.12)
ISRAEL IS ONLY ALLOWED TO STRIKE IRAN, FOR SELF-DEFENCE, WHEN IT HAS BEEN/WAS ATTACKED BY IRAN FIRST. THE SAME GOES LESS OR MORE FOR EVERY OTHER COUNTRY/PEOPLE IN THE SAME SITUATION/CIRCUMSTANCE, ACCORDING TO STILL PRESENT LAW, LEGISLATION AMONG MANKIND EVERYWHERE...
41. #31 Albrecht, USA is Israel's best friend, the only friend.
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.28.12)
There is nothing in Iran except for its common people that are "the very own interests of the USA." Did I mention oil? The common person in Israel is also of an interest to the USA, since the two countries are the best of friends. Did I exclude the uncommon right wingers on this tb?
42. Realpolitik and Israel
Pucky ,   DC USA   (02.28.12)
The real issue is not how effective economic sanctions work (and that's debatable), but timing. Iran is playing for time to have the delivery abilities before further sanctions affect them in a non reversible way. Yes, Obama's gang (don't forget, they are the Clinton Administration + a few Chicago loyalits) don't dare risk the elections. A Bush, Sr. or Reagan would long ago have bombed the Iranian facilities and then some. Go Israel! You are the only serious player left in the Nar East.
43. Plausible Deniability
Mark of Lewiston ,   Lewiston, USA   (02.28.12)
The US has ways to find out and alert our people without a formal notification from Israel. The US has early warning airborne radar all over the region to alert our troops and ships of incoming threats to us and to others. The US also has troops on the ground in Israel maintaining and operation US radar for ABM systems. The operators are all Americans, reporting up the chain to Americans. If Israel wants the radar take, Israel has to ask for the radar to be "on." This is all political and has nothing to do with security for either country. The only affect on US elections will be to boost Obama's chances with the CINC bump that happens with all wars since 1812. The only question is will Iran believe the sleight of hand?
44. The post at No. 6 is not mine
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.29.12)
I'm not so much concerned about whether the U.S. rates a head's up as I am with the strong likelihood, given the current administration, that the U.S. would tip off Iran. Not a risk worth taking.
45. To: No. 22
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.29.12)
Thank you for noticing. It wasn't even a credible fake.
46. ISREAL alone?
Jewls ,   America   (02.29.12)
Israel is NOT alone!!! She still has THE LORD OF HOSTS ... THE MOST HIGH GOD .. YAHWEH !!! AMERICA IS NOT REPRESENTED BY OBUMMER ! Many of us are stuck with him but don't Support his apathy towards Israel. Israel pray NOW.. Psalm 91 
47. To: No. 25
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.29.12)
I think you missed the point. Of course the United States will be able to detect an Israeli strike -- the issue is whether Israel informs the United States in advance of such a strike.
48. 39- Yes, Israel is very irritating
Stephen in New York   (02.29.12)
with its insistence that Tehran will not nuke Tel Aviv.
49. SarahB, if you are not threatening to Leftists...
mary of bethany ,   singapore   (02.29.12)
if you are not threatening and annoying the Leftists like thorn in their flesh, they won't "fake" you constantly, coz not worthy of their attention. and WE ALL KNOW YOU, the genuine Sarah B. every "faking" will perfect your "skill" even better.
50. To: Mary of Bethany at No. 49
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.29.12)
Why, thank you! I'm not all that easy to imitate. Which explains why invariably, the fakes write such short, stupid and grammatically incorrect posts. They cannot sustain the head fake, and they certainly do not sustain the perfect command of the English language. One does wonder, however, why they seem to consider it a calling. Perhaps they can make themselves useful -- cleaning toilets, or bagging groceries, or as a bicycle messenger. I can only surmise that all of the foregoing severely taxes their abilities. What a shame that there are people who prefer to collect disability and sit in front of their computers with their thumbs up their ..... well, you can figure out the rest. Pitiful, isn't it, these trolls that have absolutely no life outside of a computer and the Internet ....
51. To: No. 40
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.29.12)
Sigh. I guess you are blissfully unaware that threatening to wipe a country from the map constitutes an act of war. You have been spending far too much time in Amsterdam's marijuana cafes. You REALLY are an object of pity. And scorn.
52. ISREAL NOT TELLING THE US ABOUT THEIR PLANS!
Maggie B Wise ,   Ocala, USA   (02.29.12)
IF THEY TELL THE PRESIDENT WE HAVE --HE WOULD TELL ALL OF THE FRIENDS? HE THINKS HE HAS! SURPRISE IS THE ONLY ANSWER!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article