'Agreements with Israel must be revised'
Elior Levy
Published: 03.03.12, 12:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. Division of disputed Territories
John ,   Judea   (03.03.12)
Time to stop this charade one and for all, we all know that there will never be a pal state so lets just begin the negotiation with both Jordan and Egypt over a fair division of the disputed territories
2. How is it that PA would have 97,5% of their demands ....
Jouko ,   Finland   (03.03.12)
during the Clinton led peace talks but then Yasser Arafat turned off the agreement. How is it possible that Israel is not interested in peace even if PA every time turns away the compromise solution. UN proposed the division of Palestina in 1948 - who was it that declined?
3. All Arab demands based on 'DEATH TO ISRAEL"
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (03.03.12)
There have been 23 new Islamic states created in Arabia which never existed before, and 23 new capitals. Still they demand Israel's capital be cut asunder. Is this a religion of peace or death?
4. "REVISION" = Restoration of the Balfour. [End]
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (03.03.12)
5. More of the same!
J1 ,   Earth   (03.03.12)
6. To: John at No. 1
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.03.12)
Why divide anything? The territories are not "disputed," they are non-sovereign territories acquired by Israel in the course of fighting a defensive war. Gazans are Egyptian citizens; West Bank Arabs are Jordanian citizens. Why shouldn't Israel annex it all and simply repatriate the Arabs to their respective countries?
7. peace
pozarski ,   warsaw, poland   (03.03.12)
it seems palestinians want to discuss peace with some other Israeli governemnt, perhaps of their own making. let them sweat.
8. A compulsion to adhere to the.....
Gideon Reader   (03.03.12)
....rules of the game known as "Silly Buggers". Pompous fools making believe that they are actually in charge of something and have some modicum of sway in the circling of the commode of what ever tiny chance the collection of thieves, murderers, general footpads and blackguards, known as, (ahem) Plaestinians.
9. To the PA
Standing Tall ,   USA/Canada   (03.03.12)
As soon as you agree to STOP the incitement against Israel and Jews, which you agreed to do 12 years ago and have failed to implement, you can sit at the peace table then. Forget your right of return, it won't happen. Do you really believe that Israel wants to commit suicide? Also, no mention of the one million Jewish refugees. Where is their right of return? I guess I don't understand the arrogance of the Arabs. Do they think they can do what they want and not be held accountable for anything?
10. Never be peace until israel obeys international law
christianpalestinian ,   Big Sur, California   (03.03.12)
israel must withdraw from the entire west bank, gaza strip, and east jerusalem as stipulated by the entire world community.
11. Wow, the Pals now demand more? Goog luck in Jordan
Eyal ,   USA Israel   (03.03.12)
12. Losing a war you started
Todd ,   Baltimore   (03.03.12)
Dear PLO, Take a vacation. No need for these boring meetings! Your relevance is in steep decline, but don't worry, my taxes and my European buddies will still pay your salaries! Take it easy. Take your families to the beach. Buy yourself some nice clothes, work on your tennis serve. You deserve a holiday! lots of love USA
13. Deport Abbas back to Tunisia
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (03.03.12)
Abbas has made it crystal clear he has no interest in peace with Israel. It was a mistake letting the PLO into Israel. Abbas & his fellow Fatah thugs should be sent back to Tunisia (even the leader of the PLO - Arafat was born in Egypt). Israel should be negotiating with local Arabs.
14. So after 20 years now its Netanyahu's fault? LOL
Joe Fraser   (03.03.12)
15. the defeated make...DEMANDS ?? !!
moshe ,   Tivon, Israel   (03.03.12)
Be realistic! Suppose that the pal, or their presumed allies had the upper hand. Just suppose that the pals and their "allies" actually out fought Israel on the battlefield. In this fictitious scenario Can even a left wing Israeli sympathizer see any reasonable compromise the pals would offer the Jews? If not then why the hell should the weak, defeated , so called "palestinians", claim to be in any position to make DEMANDS. Those days are over. pals: Take what is offered . You have NO other choices. moshe
16. Sarah, thanks for the laugh!
Nour ,   One-State   (03.03.12)
Repatriate, huh? Repatriate THIS.
17. peace talks pre-condition grandstanding
danny ,   canada   (03.03.12)
since the PA is in the mood to pile on conditions ahead of agreeing to peace talks renewal maybe Israel should match them with some of their own recognize Israel as a Jewish state end claim to right of return inside Israel agree to protect rights of Israelis that remain in Judea demilitarization guarantee no foreign basing assure protection of religious sites no reason the Israeli's also can't enjoy the fun of grandstanding with obstructionist "pre-conditions"
18. The only topic should be terms of "Palestinian" departure.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.03.12)
There is absolutely nothing of value for Israel to talk to "Palestinian" poseurs about. This land is ours. It has been ours for more than 3,500 years. Countless international law experts have incontrovertibly proven this land is ours. The only thing Israel should talk to "Palestinians" about is the terms of their departure from our land.
19. To: No. 16
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.03.12)
You are MOST welcome! I'll be the one passing out sweets as your sorry ass leaves Medinat Israel. If you behave nicely, I won't jeer too loudly. You will NEVER have your own state, and you certainly will never be part of mine. The best part: you have only your violent selves to blame. Chew on that, chica, and see if you can work your way (however slowly) up the evolutionary chain. Right now, even Neanderthal man is still too high up for you to view.
20. To: No. 10
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.03.12)
Here's a news flash: the "international community" doesn't dictate marching orders to Israel, particularly when they act in violation of international convention and law on a routine basis. Israel has always conformed to international law. You need some catch-up time, by the way. Israel has withdrawn from Gaza. But if those missiles continue to fly, that could change. In a heartbeat. In fact, it probably will.
21. How would PA/PLO know what Bibi can do - they nevever tried
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (03.03.12)
Since 1 month before Bibi formed his government Abbas has avoided peace talks at all costs. He asked for a building freeze, and got it for 10 months. But then waited until the 9th month to come to the table. The Quartet set a 3 month deadline, Abbas waited until the end of the 2nd month to sit with Israel and then claimed that Israel was delaying things. Abbas has never once agreed to the 2 states for 2 people (Bibi did publicly in his Bar Ilan speech) but still calls for it as a precondition. Abbas has never sat down with Bibi to seriously discuss a peace deal, only preconditions or extensions. How does he know what can be done to end the conflict and grant the PA the state they have turned down 6 times in 62 years?
22. Negotiated peace, with whom?
Khan ,   U.K.   (03.03.12)
When we get this fake Jew and the invented people(Pals) of this land we will have some PEACE.
23. Sarah B USA / Israel
Sagi   (03.03.12)
You are quite rude at times, even to me( I am generally on your side ), but nevertheless enjoyable.
24. Abbas & his new conditions
tiki ,   belgium   (03.03.12)
Old, new or no conditions, who cares. Nobody takes this doubletalking snake serious anymore, except for a few Europeans who still believe that the ""Arab Spring"" set the Arabs free. If the Arab Palestinians want to do themselves a favour, they should send this idiot home and for ONCE in their miserable life, vote for someone who cares more about his people than himself & his Victory.
25. You go Sarah B.
daze ,   US   (03.03.12)
You entertainingly smack the arrogant arabs (ie-nour none state #16) and the usual petri dish of odious Jew haters that infest these talkbacks. Your "in your face style" of force feeding them the facts is Israeli hasbara at it's finest, and it doesn't cost the Jewish state a dime
26. #19 and you need to get off mexico's land!
27. Any deal is suppose to provide peace, would this?
hell no ,   Israel keep it all   (03.03.12)
28. Abbas: This dirty animal makes me sick to look at him!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (03.03.12)
God'll bring judgement on him; the fires of hell will be hot! God bless, Israel; praying for the peace of Jerusalem!
29. We are convinced: Palestinians do not want 2 states
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (03.03.12)
All the signs and signals are there that prove the Palestinians do not want a two state solution, and have no intention of ever signing a peace treaty with Israel. The most ugly, disgusting evidence was the elected Palestinian leader, Mahmoud Abbas, declaring last week that the holiest shrine in Juadism - the Holy Temple of Jerusalem - is a figment of our imagination. Disgusting racist rhetoric from the man who proves again and again he is not a partner for peace.
30. Definitely the religion of death
Chimo ,   Las Vegas. USA   (03.03.12)
What Israel should say is, unless the Arabs are willing to trade peace for peace, instead of land for peace, then there will be no peace ever, and then Israel should annex all of Judea and Samaria and that will be that A
Next talkbacks
Back to article