News  World News
EU's Ashton: Children killed in Toulouse and Gaza
AFP
Published: 19.03.12, 22:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
118 Talkbacks for this article
31. Rockets?
Adam Glantz ,   Herndon, VA, USA   (03.20.12)
Wow, I didn't know those poor kids at Ozar Hatorah were firing rockets at civilians in Toulouse!
32. Ashton' s comparison
Mike caton ,   usa   (03.20.12)
Being a Jew of partial Italian origin, I can only tell Ashton what i think of her in Italian: VAFFANCULO.
33. Ashton
JoeinLA ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.20.12)
Ashton is beyond disgusting. She should be fired immediately.
34. An utter disgrace
Harvey ,   London   (03.20.12)
What has this got to do with Israel Palestine . Presumably she mentions it because the victims are Jewish . Next time a British child is murdered by some psychopath , I will remind the wretched woman of the Coalition actions in Afghanistan and the resulting deaths of afghani children including those massacred last week . If the EU commission had a spine she would be clearing her desk right now and on the next plane home .
35. ASHTON LISTEN: Children in Gaza are NOT deliberate targets
Scott   (03.20.12)
Having read her comments - she's definitely making an incorrect comparison. That is deliberate.
36. Hat Trick or turning tricks. Not with...
GideonReader   (03.20.12)
...that Panim. lady Asston is certainly up for a Hockey event. A Hat Trick. Three in a row. The equating of defense in a war situation against an agressive hostile entity with the blatant murder of an innocents; children and a cleric at a religious school in Toulouse (Fr). Propagandizing at Israel's expense while proporting to be impartial while making the case for agressors again. And lastly showing the world an ugly side to the raw politics involved. And when the word ugly is used. In Lady Asston's case it is serious. The saying goes: Beauty is skin deep. In her case Ugly goes clear to the bone.
37. Murder in France
samuel tayar ,   montreal   (03.20.12)
Pardon my ignorance but did a Rabbi also die?
38. What the F---?
Rassoul ,   Montreal, Quebec   (03.20.12)
Unbelievable! What an idiot! She is such a suckup and brown noser. Ashton scared of those faces in front of her and gives in like a beaten bullied victim in front of an audience of onlookers. She knows she is wrong and will never be looked on as a sensible analyst. What a -uck up.
39. Horrified at the comparison!
Stephie ,   England   (03.20.12)
I am horrified at the comparison Ashton has made. The children in Norway were not shot because of their faith. Children in Gaza die because their authorities allow rockets to be fired from next to hospitals and schools and the Israeli's, not surprisingly, have to retaliate to try to put them out of action. These children in France died because they were Jewish in an apparently neo Nazi attack. It is very sad that this can happen in Europe in 2012, even sadder, and actually rather worrying, that a top European Diplomat is so obviously anti Semitic. She should have spoken to Jewish youths and given her whole hearted commiseration and support to them.
40. She looks like special needs, and says retarded stuff too.
Israeli ,   Haifa   (03.20.12)
41. SICK, SICK, SICK to the core!!! Is she stupid or evil?!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (03.20.12)
42. Children killed
Rachel   (03.20.12)
She has a point about comparing the murders of the Jewish children in France with the murder of Syrian children,but not the Gaza children. The children who died in Gaza were not murdered by the Israeli army. They were tragic,unfortunate victims of a war,which was forced on Israel by terrorists who run the society and who use these children's homes and even their bodies as human shields while firing missles into Israel,which they hope will kill Israeli children.
43. She Should Resign
Michael ,   NY uSA   (03.20.12)
If Ashton cannot see the differences between children gunned down in cold blood at children accidentally killed in cross fire of war, she should resign. There is no moral equivalence between a terrorist attack that guns down children on their way to school and casualties of was as collateral damage. Perhaps she was trying to appease her Palestinian guests
44. Cosmetics on her face cannot hide her ugly heart
John ,   NZ   (03.20.12)
45. It's only natural......
Robert ,   Australia   (03.20.12)
.....that an entity will attempt to justify their actions as acts of self preservation etc.... However, when viewed by someone who can make an objective comparison without the emotional component you will see a more sane point of view. You people who condemn Ashton for her condemnation of the Toulouse atrocity should also be condemned.
46. P.C. Absurdity. Israel does not target children.Sadly
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (03.20.12)
Hamastan do not care for their children. How much lower can they get than sending children to pick up a rocket launcher knowing full well RETURN fire is imminent,putting a bomb belt on a child,firing from amongst civillians including children,a child miles from home in fading light approaching a military outpost wearing a back pack etc etc?
47. True to form,this woman never ever misses a chanc
Berchmans ,   Scotland   (03.20.12)
48. EU Ashton is making history
Raymond Brokosvhi ,   Indonesia Jakarta   (03.20.12)
Not only is she ugly on the outside. She is also ugly on the inside. I bet there is a hidden feeling inside her just wanted to scream "lets kill all jews. . . errr i mean zionist". Bankrupt EU is bankrupt economically, spiritually, morally. It is simply FINISHED. No longer revelant.
49. Children Killed in Toulouse and Gaza
George Fink ,   Melbourne Australia   (03.20.12)
Lady Ashton shows herself to be as stupid as she is prejudiced. In equating the deaths in Toulouse with the those in Gaza, Ashton ignores the fact that the Jews of Toulouse are not at war with the rest France!!! To the best of my knowledge they have not fired a single missile at their neighbours. In contrast, Hamas, the PRC, Islamic Jihad et al have long been at (a declared eternal) war with Israel at which it these Palestinian forces and Muslim colleagues (Hezbollah) have fired many thousands of missiles, including more than 400 just last week, at Israeli schools and other civilian targets. These Palestinian missiles have wreaked havoc on many thousands of Israeli kids.
50. She'll be forced to resign
John ,   Sydney, Australia   (03.20.12)
If the necessary pressure's applied from the Israeli Government and Jewish groups, then she'll have to resign
51. THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT
David ,   New York, NY   (03.20.12)
Let's give her the benefit of the doubt: For Catherine Ashton to equate the murders in Toulouse with events in Gaza qualifies her without doubt as one bigoted, stupid bitch!
52. what ashton apparently said
philipe   (03.20.12)
gazan babies are killed directly or indirectly by hamas or jihad use of civilian cover which is a war crime. The jews killed in france were cold blooded murder victims. Ashton equated the two. Her remarks are so aggregious, so beyond anything even of incitment that a firing squad would not be sufficient punishment for ashton, another lawyer in the mold of pillay. i suggest to ashton that she take a heavy dose of sleeping pills during her bathing. Her disappearance would do the world a favour.Her comments are on a par with ahamadinejad, a blood insane murderer with the blood of americans on his neck.
53. Not all us white people are this stupid
shaun green ,   pasadena usa   (03.20.12)
Please don't assume this woman speaks for all of her kind. We have good and bad people, smart and stupid just like everyone else.
54. to number 1
raed ,   chile   (03.20.12)
killing is killing, isreal commited crimes against palestinians for being palestinians.. and in france jews were killed for being jews.. we need to be more forgiving.. a killer is a killer no matter of what reliegion or background he is.
55. Unlucky comparison
Shamir ,   São Paulo - Brasil   (03.20.12)
There´s no mean such comparison. She has a biased mind against the jews and Israel.
56. Re: Typical Irish
Al ,   Melbourne, Australia   (03.20.12)
Why are there a disproportionate number of Irish in these so called human rights organisations, specifically those that target Israel? The British occupation was the only thing that kept these ingrate peasants in their place, they are terror-mongering scumbags when left to their own devices. Dublin is the only capital city in Europe which retains a statue of an out and out nazi.
57. Beneath contempt.........
NS ,   Long Island, NY, USA   (03.20.12)
Before I go on I must urge my fellow TB's not to stoop to insults that degrade women. I understand the anger. I am angry too but keep in mind that we all have mothers, wives, sisters and girlfriends who we would never use those words to describe them. Having said this let me go on and say that Ashton is an extremist hack politician whose ideals are beneath contempt. The Israeli Government should declare her persona non grata and ban her from the country. When she arrives in New York on EU business Mayor Michael Bloomberg should refuse to meet with her.
58. Zero parallel between Toulouse and Gaza
Maurice ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.20.12)
How can she equal the deliberate cold blooded slaughter of children in France with the unfortunate collateral deaths of children in Gaza. Children in Gaza would not die if the cowardly terrorists did not use them as human shields. Israeli soldiers do not target children. She should resign immediately.
59. So according to this idiot
Steve from Raleigh   (03.20.12)
We need to start hurling missiles into French towns because that's nothing if not justified and noble. Ms Ashton you are functionally retarded and you need minders.
60. Ashton: a typical British Antisemite: blood libel
Sami ,   New York, USA   (03.20.12)
Ashton is a typical British antisemite. This comment is a Blood Libel. She should resign.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article