Opinion
The day Europe died
Yigal Walt
Published: 21.03.12, 10:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
99 Talkbacks for this article
61. this is an answer to #8
Alex   (03.21.12)
Have no idea how it ended down here
62. Europe's moral decline
Thomas ,   Germany   (03.21.12)
materializes in people like Ashton, Sigmar Gabriel and a long list of other european elite members.
63. The Europeans sent the Jews back to Israel
Sami ,   New York, USA   (03.21.12)
It was the Europeans (and Arabs) who sent the Jews back to Israel.
64. 2,000 years of Antisemitism
Laila ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.21.12)
2,000 years of Antisemitism. What do you expect?
65. Civilian collateral damage OK
Niru ,   Bristol, UK   (03.21.12)
This was the argument Mahinda Rajapaksa of Sri Lanka used when bombing civilians during the fight against the Tamil Tigers. Though from Sri Lanka, I have cut all my ties with the country as I consider it a rogue dictatorship now.
66. massacre
jill ,   chicago, il   (03.21.12)
Mohammed- thank you for saying that the work of the man in Tolouse was the work of a crazy man. Killings in Gaza are the result of Hamas continually and without provocation launching rockets into another country. Which came first? The situation is complex, but I cannot say it is a "massacre" without first acknowledging the role of the government there as well. Please- if Hamas would put down their arms and renounce violence, would violence against Gazans end? You know the answer.
67. To: No. 58
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.21.12)
Were it not for the actions of the Europeans since the Christianization of Europe, the Jewish population today would be 330 million. We number around 13 million. And throughout the millennia of persecution by the Europeans, we never stopped making enormous contributions to society and civilization. When YOUR forebears were painting their faces blue, howling at the moon and sacrificing human beings to very questionable deities, MY forebears were writing the Bible. Who on earth thinks that Jews are particularly interested in having Europeans, with their barbaric and bloodthirsty history, as "friends?" Newsflash: For the most part, we can take you or leave you. Most of us disdain you. Just stay out of our business and we will stay out of yours.
68. To: No. 65
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.21.12)
Your analogy is completely inapposite. It is also considerably hypocritical. One does wonder why you haven't you cut all your ties with the U.K., in view of the huge number of civilian casualties as a result of indiscriminate NATO bombing in Afghanistan, Iraq and Waziristan? Over a million, actually. And, of course, there were all those dead civilians when NATO carpet bombed Kosovo. But then where would you live?
69. Re:edithann and her tata,lol
Malone ,   Hfx   (03.21.12)
She never has anything to say,her sole purpose is to provoke...I almost feel sorry for her,but not quite...I just consider the source and ignore.
70. # 42
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.21.12)
Ashton the moron in her speech said, ''when I visited Palestine" Does'nt this dimwitted excuse of a woman know there is no country on the map of the world called Palestine? Brainless cow needs to learn a thing or two.
71. # 26
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.21.12)
There is a very simple solution to the problem. Stop bombarding southern Israel with your rockets. Put your weapons down, give up ALL forms of violence & you & your children will live in peace.
72. Fantastic piece and so true!
Gábor Fränkl ,   Budapest, Hungary   (03.21.12)
Europe in a nutshell.
73. The Gates of Vienna fell this time thanks to dumb leaders
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (03.22.12)
like Ashton assisted by even more stupid & naive progressives bent on destroying the current social structure
74. nice article although europe died long time ago
ester   (03.22.12)
2000 years of antisemitism and wars showed it
75. To: Maone at No. 69
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.22.12)
Edithann. Ta Ta. VERY reminiscent of Laugh-In's Lily Tomlin, who had two signature characters: Ernestine the telephone operator and EdithAnn, the obstreperous, stupid child, whose signature closing was "TaTa." I wonder if they are one and the same person. Idiotann's politics identically parallel those of Lily Tomlin. Hmm. Curious.
76. i have been saying this for years. the eu is immoral, lost,
ralph   (03.22.12)
confused. it has no moral compass. its christian core - rotten, but still mouthing some lessons - is dead and dying. christian ministers do not know what they should minister or teach,some also convert to islam and say it makes them better anglican ministers - no joke, true event - its prince mutters with nothing meaningful to say, except that islam and eco-green are worthy matters. its elite is corrupt and equally lost. and its youth have no direction. it is the dead past for the new emerging vibrant judaism. it is the east not the west where we must look and orient ourselves. even africa appears to be coming of age. all will surpase the eu and uk within our life time. that is if any people who can read are still left there.
77. Hamas signs death warrant of Palestinian children
Catherine ,   Newport beach, ca   (03.22.12)
Hamas threads itself among the palestinian civilian population, using the Palestinian children as human shields. Again, who is responsible for any civilian casualties in Gaza?! The IDF is scrupulously and surgically delicate about trying to avoid the non-militant population in Gaza. Hell, ISRAEL even foots the bill and provides tertiary medical services to the palestInians, which is more than their own leaders do.
78. to israil
hurra ,   iraqu   (03.22.12)
you can not get it both ways .. israil is part of the west in middle east and israil is part of midle east in the west
79. To Brain # 58
ChanahS ,   Israel   (03.22.12)
A total no-brainer if you ask me. Can't even spell your name?
80. European antisemitism
Ray Huppert ,   Sydney Australia   (03.22.12)
Israel do not fear! You will succeed in the long run. Your case is just. Remember the Bible : God made a covenant with the Jewish people. Never doubt this.
81. #24 take your racism and stupidity to Al Jazeera
(03.22.12)
You are pathetic: your post is full of slogans and lies but not one single fact and of course, it is a total distorsion of reality. Last time I looked, Gaza was under full palestinian control - Israel is not there anymore. Last time I looked,it was Palestinians from Gaza shooting into Israel 10,000 rockets of all sizes, into Israeli towns! Last time I looked, terrorists from Gaza plan and execute terror attacks against Israelis inside Israel! Last time I looked it was palestinians I Gaza and the West Bank were inciting for the destruction of Israel. Are you trying to deny our natural right to defend ourselves? Howl ong would coward thugs like yourself be able to live in such conditions? Are you trying to justify your innate anti-Semitism and support for murder of Jews with these lies? Of course you do! Now take your racist rant outa here and do let facts hit you on your way out!
82. #78 yes we can!
(03.22.12)
I agree that I'd prefer to have my country anywhere else I the world than here, surrounded by genocidal and primitive people, but this can't happen. Israel is our ancestors land and we are destined to live here, and defend ourselves. But don't worry my friend: Jews have prevailed and outlived all those who tried to murder and "wipe her off the map". So yes, we'll be still here, living and flourishing, defending our values, way of life and culture, while our enemies sacrifice their future generations on the altar of racism, intolerance, genocide and incitement. Our enemies shed their own blood, while we build, create and grow stronger. So yes, Israel is here to stay, as the ONLY and ancestral land of the Jews, whether you like it or not!
83. Cathrine Ashton
David Sucari ,   Modi'in, Israel   (03.22.12)
her recent remark comparing the murder of children in Toulouse to the killing of Gaza children is despicable. She posseses "tons of ashes" deriving either from naivity or intentionally found an opportunity to besmirch Israel. Shame on you Cathrine!
84. #34 I think you've jumped to conclusions
observer   (03.22.12)
This article appeared before her agency engaged in a belated spin effort. Had she or her agency really meant it, they could have dispelled the rumours much earlier. Those rumours were put about by sources who heard her tirade and had an interest in spreading that sort of sentiment - ie Palestinians and their allies. Her silence indicates that she was not opposed to that message. She knew full well that once it got into the media, her Arab friends would be satisfied. All she had to do was keep quiet until it spread. When the backlash came, she then issued a mealy-mouth correction that the arab press would anyway ignore. The winner? She. However, I think many have missed the point. By seeking to include this massacre with other tragedies, she sought to minimise it. This would only come from someone who was reluctant to even mention it at all. The misreporting of her comments definitely did correctly portray her sick and twisted attitude.
85. Did you sleep well, Israel?
Andreas ,   Berlin   (03.22.12)
Hey, Israel, I can't believe you finally woke up! Nice surprise ...on the other hand: Who's got the right to complain after acting like Sleeping Beauty for 20 years?
86. #53 Bunny: No, it died when they stood .......
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (03.22.12)
and watched 6,000,000 Jews and many other get slaughtered by the Nazis. Let's not forget that many Europeans assisted the Nazis carry out their Final Solution of the Jewish Problem and the Roosevelt Administration just closed it eyes!
87. History repeats
Cristu Esz ,   Paris, France   (03.22.12)
”Arab mobs, organised and fanaticised by political intriguers working on the religious fury of the ignorant, attacked scattered Jewish settlements and murdered and plundered wherever no resistance was offered. In Hebron, the inmates of a rabbinical college, innocent youths who had never handled weapons in their lives, were butchered in cold blood; in Safed the same fate befell aged rabbis and their wives and children. Recently some Arabs raided a Jewish orphan settlement where the pathetic remnants of the great Russian pogroms had found a haven of refuge. Is it not then amazing that an orgy of such primitive brutality upon a peaceful population has been utilised by a certain section of the British press for a campaign of propaganda directed, not against the authors and instigators of these brutalities, but against their victims?” Albert Einstein, letter to Manchester Guardian October 12, 1929
88. Ashton shows her true colors
Alfredo ,   Raanana   (03.22.12)
It is now official
89. Europa unbearable
Karl Kowalski ,   Germany   (03.22.12)
I am abashed and angry about european politicians. They are all sick about political correctness! It is unbearable!!
90. Read what she said
Tomer ,   Hod Hasharon, Israel   (03.22.12)
Sorry I don't fancy joining in the gleeful Ashton/Europe-bashing here. Have any of you actually read what she said? She noted a number of places around the world where childrens lives have been affected by fighting, among them SDEROT and Gaza. She did not draw any equivalence between any of the examples she gave. How this equates to anti-semitism quite escapes me. Seems to me that we should focus on real antisemitism wherever it exists, and stop foaming at the mouth whenever any outsider has the temerity not to be 150% "on our side".
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article