Opinion  Giulio Meotti
A Jew-free Europe
Giulio Meotti
Published: 22.03.12, 11:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
61. We are Israel, not America or Europe
Tzvi ,   USA   (03.23.12)
Scratch a gentile and you will find an anti Semite. Remember that from your bubee? No now the disguise is falling away. National Public Radio, the Republican Party, and of course all of Europe now openly can spit on us. So what else is new? Jews, we are Israel. I for one will miss Rothschilds' wines, but like everything else, we will find a way to make it better in our own land.
62. #57 nice
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.23.12)
It's unusual to hear a comment such as yours. Thank you for showing that there is another side to the coin. I am not yet sure, however, which side of the coin is larger. Peace.
63. #30: The Germanness (if you could call it that) of
Henry from New York ,   USA   (03.23.12)
German-Americans has been so diluted that it's really more a symbolic thing. Culturally they are American with a few exceptions.
64. 2020, 2050, 2080? Ridiculous!
Henry from New York ,   USA   (03.23.12)
2020. Sure it's eight years from now and maybe, just maybe you can make some estimates on population leaving out unforseen circumstances. 2050 and 2080? That's a joke. There are some many different things that could happen that that those numbers are useless. Why put up such figures when they are meaningless?
65. Every Jew a .22
BH ,   Iowa   (03.23.12)
66. European Reaction
Sigmund   (03.24.12)
The Failure to partitition Palestine in 1937 mainly due to Islam opposition violent and barbaric prevented the second revival of Islam as a creative force now Islam is mmires in death hate and murder interislamic .The future for Islam is dire as counter revenge with horrific weapons wells .
67. European anti-Semitism
Syd Chaden ,   Palermo Calif USA   (03.24.12)
I disagree with the premise that European anti-Semitism is the result of an unpleasant reminder of Auschwitz, or of the moral failure of Europe. When the Germans invaded, France could hardly wait to turn over French Jews to the Germans for the trip to Aushwitz. No country interfered with the Holocaust, not even the USA. Franklin D. Roosevelt declined to bomb the death camps or the railroad tracks leading to it. Anti-Semitism is not new to the world. It just has not gone away.
68. 67,...
split ,   US   (03.24.12)
"France could hardly wait to turn over French Jews to the Germans" ,... Why, because they were good neighbors ??? ,...
69. How predictible ,...
split ,   US   (03.24.12)
Another pathetic attempt to blame others fo their own shortcomings.
70. Guilt projection.That's how leftism treat S,Amer jews/Israel
Justin Case ,   Brasil   (03.25.12)
71. # 2 prohibit muslim immigration
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (03.25.12)
and repatriate,it is too late,the islamic jihadist from Toulon,was born in France,and his ilk are protected by the constitution,who knows how many thosands of islamic jihadists are roaming the streets of Europe and north America,Australia,the constitution of the Democracies is the greatest enemy of western civilization.
72. #68, #69 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.25.12)
No; France could hardly wait to turn over French Jews to the Germans...because they were Jews. You close your eyes not only to facts, but also to the obvious. Another pathetic attempt to blame others for your own shortcomings.
73. Unfortunate Slipping
Jakob Heidbrink ,   Skövde, Sweden   (03.25.12)
While I largely agree with the message of the post, I not the same unfortunate sliding between Israel and the Jewish people as can be found among anti-Semites: Germans' opinions about Israel's policies in Palestine are prima facie no indication of anti-Semitism. Israel is a State; Jews are a people. We would all be much better off if everybody could remember that distinction. One can be very critical of Israel without being an anti-Semite, and one can be a Jew without having to subscribe to Israel's policies.
74. #73 jakob
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.25.12)
Good post. The problem, as you point out, is that very many anti-Israel statements include hatred of Jews; a fact ignored by many. And Jews who do not agree with all of Israel's policies 100% are labeled as traitors.
75. 72 - Logic my dear Watson, logic ,...
split ,   US   (03.25.12)
The Jews settled down and got kicked out from 109 countries and places around the world since 200 AD, that says something about the Jews not the nations that kicked them out ,... An impartial self-assessment is not a virtue or a part of Jewish character, is it ? A Jew can do no wrong, right ?
76. # 68 "France could hardly wait to turn over French jews to
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (03.25.12)
the Germans,why ?.because many Frenchmen were sadistic like you,and they were more than happy to help the Germans to carry out the German demonic plan,as a sadistic Antisemite did you offer your service to islamic jihad ?.or,you are a muslim,and you are already a member of islamic jihad.
77. 76 - Conveniently omitted my 75 response ,...
split ,   US   (03.26.12)
and keep pushing the beat-up an eternal victim crap ,...
78. american anti-semitism
ross ,   israel   (03.26.12)
i think that per capita there are more kahanists in israel than there are anti-semites of any comparable level of hatred in america.
79. #75, #77 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.26.12)
Wrong (as your usual). Kicking out Jews says much about the nations that kicked them out. They were thought of as Christ-killers. But I forget: you make it a point of ignoring facts. An impartial self-assessment is not part of your character at all. A Jew can do wrong. But to you, a Jew can do no right. The Jew has been the victim for millenia. But the real crap comes from you. You should get a PhD for it (‘Piled high and Deep’).
80. 79 ,...
split ,   US   (03.27.12)
Google "Bernard Lazare: Fordham", open the first entry and read first 13 lines of chapter one - Trying to help you, pinhead ,...
81. #80 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.28.12)
Read the forward: “Many of Lazare's explanations can be, and should, be challenged.” His "thesis" is akin to saying a woman causes her own rape by the way she dresses. He also 'ignores' [there's that word again; the one you know so well] that the nations were bound by a religion that blames the Jews. I repeat: you should get a PhD. Although I'm no longer sure if P stands for Piled or Pinhead. You are a sick puppy.
82. 81 - An incurable case,...
split ,   US   (03.28.12)
So, 7 Billion of goyim should bend over to make 16 million so called 'chosen' ones happy, right ? ,...
83. By whom ? A pinheads like you ?
split ,   US   (03.28.12)
“Many of Lazare's explanations can be, and should, be challenged.” Good Night ,...
84. Split, you are......
Lena ,   Toronto, Canada   (04.02.12)
Split, you are beyond reasoning, your mind is poisoned and you see no light, what will you tell to God after your death? Go to the nearest church and repent before it's too late. My words most likely will mean nothing too you, but remember that all of us are going to be judged at the end of our lives, regardless of our religions or believes.
85. There is, the difference is
(05.08.12)
that Jews in Europe do not go round attacking people. Our minority does. And anyway, surely in a democracy each person is free to live their life as they see fit, as long as they respect the law.
86. Europe
Chris ,   Europe   (01.31.13)
If you all think like that then how about we take all the money back you owe us to keep Israel afloat and cut all funds to it? We won't even need a crusade...
87. Immigrants and Religiously foreigners
Dinov ,   Oxford UK   (08.10.14)
When Jews leave Europe to the Europeans, then yes, we will have peace and prosperity again.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article