News
IDF gears up for Global March to Jerusalem
Ynet reporters
Published: 25.03.12, 16:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
31. Which home?
Adar ,   London,UK   (03.25.12)
Israel is the only state you call home, there is no other home!!
32. Nour
Adar ,   London,UK   (03.25.12)
Which home are you returning to? Israel belongs to Jews. Go back to where you belong Arabia, Syria, Jordon or whatever... Just get out of Israel Do NOT step in Israel keep you're dirty feets out!! Shalom Israel
33. THE ARAB MARCH
mebosa ritchie ,   glasgow scotland   (03.25.12)
SPRAY THEM WITH PIGSHIT
34. #4 You have the right to remain in Canada
Cynthia ,   USA   (03.25.12)
After all, your grandparents worked hard to get there. They ran away to Lebanon from Israel because of Syrian militias in '48. From Lebanon they went to Canada. They could have fought for the land like the Jews but they ran away. You live in a fantasy world of false entitlement. Thank you Nour for a perfect illustration of Palestinian lies. Btw, how much are these marchers getting paid? Last year it was about $50.00 per person.
35. #4 Keep Taking Your Meds Nour!
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (03.25.12)
The only "Right of Return" you will ever see is your right to return to the cesspool from which you and your cronies came.
36. Next Year in Jerusalem
Joseph   (03.25.12)
If not this year. We'll keep trying.
37. pigs will do, but
alan ,   texas   (03.25.12)
barking dogs may do as well. You can also have a women's contingent shoot them. Some dead arabs will get the media screaming and Israel's answer, should be: don't even think about trying this ever again!
38. Minimum harm? How cute!
Maxim ,   ISRAEL FOREVER   (03.25.12)
39. Nonlethal Devices
Bill ,   New York, USA   (03.25.12)
Whatever happened to that microwave device that causes searing heat on the surface of the skin but no real damage? It would be way cool to test that out on the willing test subjects attempting to storm the border. Wait one turn for claims of being ready to die for Allah and Al Aqsa to be replaced by complaints about discomfort.
40. Sarah dear! I love it!
Maxim ,   ISRAELOAMERICAN   (03.25.12)
WOW GIRL! Word word, right in between the eyes Sarah. Bull's-eye! keep up the good work beautiful Lady.
41. These Dolts of the Burning Sand,...
Gideon Reader   (03.25.12)
...have been duly advised and warned with plenty o notice and lead time. Consider violation of Israel's borders a "RED LINE NO GO ZONE". Trespassers will be shot early and often! That seems pretty ssimple to me. The usual suspects of the Yellow Stripe (US,UK.FR,GR,EU,UN), do not care for that? Too effen bad.
42. 23 - So what? what's your point? ,...
split ,   US   (03.26.12)
Are you stupid or what - Read it again what he wrote, read my response and try to find an anology in those two cases, pinhead ,...
43. To #4
Marianne ,   USA   (03.26.12)
Home? Israel is not their home, never was... I don't know what history books you are reading.. but, your wrong..
44. THEY ARE NOT PROTESTERS. THEY ARE CRIMINAL HOOLIGANS
rivka ,   los angeles   (03.26.12)
Planning pre meditated violence and violation of our borders.
45. To: Maxim at No. 40
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.12)
Thank you very much for your kind words.
46. To: Bill at No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.12)
There isn't a single nation in the world that would refrain from use of deadly force in the face of such a provocation. Why should Israel? If they REALLY are willing to die for their "beliefs," let's help them along.
47. To # 4...dear Noor..
Rafi ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.26.12)
I blame you not for wanting to return to where your parents once "camped" on their way out of the neighboring brotherly countries where life was even worse.. I understand you and would be no different...this because we know that what you left is now thousands of times better. Your brothers who stayed know it too...but, this is not an easy task...as you have done nothing to deserve it....you just want to take advantage of OUR work in OUR land...Go through the proper red tape, if you have what to offer, you might be considered...but remember it must be some talent or capacity we are short off and need, just like anywhere else with any other country...now do you feel you stand a chance?...go for it Noor...don't hesitate!
48. 43 - Home? Israel is not their home, never was...
split ,   US   (03.26.12)
1878 Ottoman census listed 403,795Palestinians, and 15,011 Jews, whose land did you think those Palestinians lived on? When you read that the 1922 British census listed 569,177 Palestinians and 83,790 Jews in Palestine, and that Jews owned 3% of the land, and the 1947 census which showed Jews owned 7% of the land, who did you think owned the other 97% and 93% respectively? They were Palestinians, and the land was called Palestinian territory.
49. #7
Nour ,   One-State   (03.26.12)
Wrong. As per UNDHR (issued by the United Nations) Article 13(2) of the UDHR phrases the right of return broadly and simply, as follows: “Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country.” Article 12(4) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) phrases the right of return fairly similarly: “No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country.” Israel has signed and ratified the ICCPR and has not made any reservations to Article 12(4), containing the right of return.
50. #8
Nour ,   One-State   (03.26.12)
Solomon, can you please enlighten me as to how many of your Prime Ministers actually hail from this region? As far as I am concerned, all of them (or their parents, and that’s as far as it goes) were born in such places as Poland, Germany, etc. We on the other hand can trace our forefathers (dozens if not hundreds of generations to the Land of Palestine). As for the right of return it is universally endorsed by the UNHR signatories including “Israel”.
51. #48 but they never governed themselves from antiquity.
(03.26.12)
52. # 51 so? Many nations today have not...
Nour ,   One-State   (03.26.12)
Why single out the Palestinian people? It's no secret that our land has been a threshold of regional amibitions and expansions. Does that make us any less entitled to right of self determination? I think not.
53. # 48 Noor
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (03.26.12)
the reason so many Jews came back to Israel was the result of the Israeli's return to israel after a 2,000 'scattering;' that Rome first imposed on israel. Before and after any 'pals' Israel was and is the "Homeland for The Jewish People.' SInce the pals can't make peace anyplace on earth, they are not only a non people, they are an invention. The pals will never have a state. Israel is taken by her rightful owners. The majority of people world wide fully support Israel for they know it was established over 3,000 years ago. Biblical history proves this point as well as the prophecies coming to pass. A pity you aren't allowed to read the bible ( the worlds best seller ) or, you'd seed how this G-d given Promise is kept, in a word, Israel. I pity your vast ignorance.
54. Nour
AL QUDS ALYAHUDI   (03.26.12)
What is Judea stands for ya Ahbal? Does it stand for Judah or Islam? and what Judah stand for, Jews or Islam. Jews lived in Israel THOUSANDS OF YEARS EVEN BEFORE MOHAMMED WAS BORN. Do not forget your prophet Mohammed have killed thousands of Jews in Saudi Arabia, who have refused to convert to Islam. Many of Muslims in Saudi Arabia are Jews. One day they will come back to Judaism.
55. #48 NOOR
Iranian Jew ,   Los Angeles   (03.26.12)
We can go further in the history. how about 2,000 years ago? how many generations of Jews do you want us to trace to Israel? And since when you decide which type of leader we should choose for our land? We choose whoever we see fit. Your Arafat was an Egyptian born. So why would you choose him as a leader? He was not Palestinian? I mean Balestinian since you don't pronounce the letter "P". Palestina is a Greek word. why would you choose it to call yourself? Your language is Arabic. Why not choose and Arabic one? Let me guess! Someone else made it up for you. And that someone was not smart enough to think about this. Please stop the BS. We don't buy it.
56. Nour Jerusalem 1948 - 1967
Emma ,   London   (03.26.12)
Please refresh your memory of what the Muslims did to Jerusalem in 1948. They expelled all the Jews and made it Judenrein. There is a book by the British photographer John Phillips documenting this explusion. This was after the UN had declared Jerusalem an international city. Google John Phillips Jerusalem and you will see the images. They then systematically desroyed the old Jewish Quarter and the synagogues within it, ripped up the grave stones on the Mount of Olives and used them as paving stones. And you dare to complain now that Jerusalem is an international city for all religions. You abrogated your right to rule Jerusalem when you desecrated and expelled all Jewish life from Jerusalem you cannot be trusted to respect other religions. You don't like the facts, tough.
57. #10 split
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.26.12)
Israelis are not claiming they are refugees nor are they laying claim to Poland. You really are that stupid, aren't you?
58. #27 tarbouche - I like it
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.26.12)
I actually like your idea. If Masjad Omar and Masjad Al Aqsa are transferred out of Israel, maybe the arabs will stop their fake "history" of Jerusalam and leave it alone, while having full access to the Masjads (while denying access to anyone who is not a Muslim). The farther away from the Temple Mount and Jerusalem, the better.
59. No 4
Emma ,   London   (03.26.12)
Nour The only reason Muslims suddenly care about Jerusalem is because they have become to realise how important it is to the Jews. They don't really want it they just don't want the Jews to have it. As I said, in my earlier post, you did anything but respect Jewish rights to the city even building a wall and denying them access to their holy places. So I repeat once again, you cannot claim the moral high ground and because you behaved so disgracefully and disrespectfully when Jerusalem was in your hands you can now go and take a running jump and kick at yourselves. You deserve nothing.
60. Human shields
Ralph Haglund ,   Sweden   (03.26.12)
That is what this flock of lemmings are, and that is ILLEGAL, it is not illegal to shoot them down. But IDF has skunk spray, white-and-blue paint guns, whatever those people want. They can even choose to get tatoos impossible to remove, with a nice Star of David.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article