News
Court rejects Migron deal; orders evacuation by August 1
Aviad Glickman
Published: 25.03.12, 17:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Justice has been served, good job ... more!
AQ ,   Jerusalem   (03.25.12)
2. No one is above the law? Really?
ZionistBill ,   Israel   (03.25.12)
There are countless examples in the past of nations which did the right thing instead of following the advice of unelected judges. Hilter didn't worry about judges. US President Andrew Jackson ignored the US Supreme Court and kicked native Americans off of land that white settlers needed. Why can't Israel do the same? Is anyone else tired of this hypocrisy? If other nations have done such things, then Israel should also be able to. The reason so many get upset when Israel does what others have done is because of antisemitism.
3. Of course we have to prove to the world we're saints!
ab ,   TheRock   (03.25.12)
even if it means shooting ourselves in the foot! When the jordanians NOT palestinians will begin honoring 'the law (and stop murdering our people), we'll talk law. May Hashem protect us from our own madness.
4. The law acting above the law!!
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (03.25.12)
I am 100% in favor of law enforcement, anywhere in the world. However, the law has to be applied with due respect to the law. In too many instances, our HIgh Court appears to demonstrate a seeming disregard for a balanced approach to legal matters, free of political considerations. Statements aimed at one segment of our population, in this case about settlers, not being above the law, seems to be a contradiction in terms of the available circumstances. This is not about a few misguided 'hilltop youth' being warned against illegal actions. This is more about a defence presenting strong evidence that in the majority of law abiding countries would be hard to deny. This current High Court hierarchy seem more concerned with maintaining a politically oriented attack against settlers, and grossly misusing the law in the process. Israel needs a strong judiciary system, but an honest one that gains the trust of our citizens.
5. Israels faux display of democracy....
Edithann ,   USA   (03.25.12)
Too little too late... The world already knows what Israel is all about. Anything beyond the'48 borders is internationally (UN) illegal... TATA
6. Fair is fair
Avraham ,   Israel   (03.25.12)
I was against the compromise in the first place. Do not reward illegal construction...it sets a very bad precedent for next time. Fair ruling by the Supreme Court.
7. DOWN WITH the LEFTIST PRO-ARAB HIGH COURT of INJUSTICE
Benjamin ,   Ramat HaSharon   (03.25.12)
Shame on Israel for allowing anti-Zionist anti-Israel anti-Jewish self-appointed judges to rule the state.
8. Will Bibi be the one to get Sharon's punishment next?
(03.25.12)
9. Something Wrong
Joe Sombrero ,   USA   (03.25.12)
This is my opinion there is something wrong with political system country that allows foreign goverment funded organizations to run policy in a democratic country. The question is whois protecting them? These people were in essence foreign agents in my opinion working to change a democratically elected government and a democratically elected policy. Take a look at this video from Fox news notice the receipt in the video for Peace Now. Since JPost does not allow links you have to do a search in Google for the words docs on the block foxnews. I am afraid now there may be a Civil War because of this breech of trust with the settlers.
10. settlements?
JEFF ,   MIAMI/JERUSALEM   (03.25.12)
It is the atheist supreme court who is breaking The 10 Commandments of Our Father the land belongs to the seed of Abraham and the evil judges are blasphemers and idolators. I would like to see the demonic deed and who wrote it. Israel will never have peace as long as she seeks to appease our enemies and refuses to honor YHVH..
11. No one is above the law.
leonmen ,   meitar israel   (03.25.12)
So we should follow the example of Hitler!!!???
12. No one is above the law except the courts
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (03.25.12)
The courts seem to think they run the country and had out orders instead of deciding judicial contentions. They should be put back in their place. The are judges, not law makers or enforcers.
13. What do you expect.
michaelpielet ,   israel   (03.25.12)
Arabs have rights. Jews have no rights. The article is misleading the land was not arab land.
14. Can someone tell me WHO
(03.25.12)
appointed the judges for the High Court in Israel? What right do these self-appointed judges have to run state affairs and make decisions for citizens in Israel? Isn't it time for a group of people - loyal to the state and to the Jews - to appoint themselves as judges?
15. What's mune is yours, what's yours is yours to keep
Jerry ,   Boston   (03.25.12)
To Edithann, USA. You are an hypocrite, a fool and an imbecile.. Back to 48'?. Can you please tell me when will the native idians get back THEIR land stolen by white thugs, spearheaded by Andrew Jackson, or your beloved NY stolen by same white trash in exchange for worthless trinkets? -- Fair value hey!
16. law above the law
yosef yankelev, Phd ,   Coral Springs, USA   (03.25.12)
David, Yishar Koach, I would take it one (important) step further - every truly patriotic Jew, in Israel and the world should declare: Curtail the "democratic" liberties, so abused by sworn enemies and: F#&K the Unelected Bagatz - the tool of the leftist cancer on the body of Israel.
17. #2 Zionist Bill's role model of Hitler
Michael ,   Haifa   (03.25.12)
In advocating a government policy of ignoring the decisions of the Supreme Court, Zionist Bill cites the example of Hitler in support of his argument. I suspect that Zionist Bill is a bit sick in the head.
18. the exiles
cristian ,   argentina   (03.25.12)
blessed and cursed men are much like animals,the animals throught the year are moved from one place to another in search of climate,food and survival and men are equal but even more animals for allegedly men can reason as opposed to animals that live only by instinct,men are moved by natural causes but also often causes generated by the men themselves as violence,war,inequality,injustice and persecution,in world wars europeans exiled america in masses,generating inequality and crime in latin america masses migrated to the u.s. and in contemporary times the masses of the arabs countries also migrate to europe for the injustices that generate violence,when the man behave like a man,these problems will exist no more immigration but it is so difficult to men that reason
19. Are Israel's High Court Judges SECRET Converts to Islam?
Linda Rivera ,   New York, USA   (03.25.12)
20. Taqiyya - LIES and Deception to HATED infidels are an
Linda Rivera ,   New York, USA   (03.25.12)
important part of Islam. PA Muslims know that all they have to do is LIE and say the land belongs to them and Israel's rabidly anti-Jew, anti-Israel High Court will PRETEND that Muslim lies are the truth and demand the destruction of Jewish towns and communities. Muslims also say that Jerusalem and ALL Israel belongs to them. Will the High Court next demand that Jews leave Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and all Israel and surrender the world's sole, tiny Jewish state to totalitarian, colonizing Islam? Justice and HUMAN RIGHTS now for Non-Muslims!
21. rule of law
David ,   USA   (03.25.12)
Any law, nation, or entity that kicks Jews off Jewish land in favor of occupying Arabs is anti-Eloheim, anti-Torah, antisemitic, and an enemy of the Jewish people. Whether it be the court, judges, PM, USA, or anyone else. Arab liars do not gain title to Eretz Israel by their lies. GO HOME INTERLOPERS! Go back to Arabia or Egypt or Persia. The borders of Eretz Israel is from the River of Egypt to beyond Damascus and from the Great Sea to the Euphrates.
22. #2 ZionistBill
(03.25.12)
"Hitler didn't worry about judges. [...] Why can't Israel do the same?" Maybe because Hitler is not an appropriate role model for the Jewish state. "The reason so many get upset when Israel does what others have done is because of antisemitism." Yeah, now people are Anti-Semitic because they oppose Hitlerism. The Israeli right is getting dumber and dumber.
23. Time for civil war and the destruction of the LEFT!
PERIOD   (03.25.12)
24. Paid agents, traitors of the EU, Britain, France etc.
Gábor Fränkl   (03.25.12)
The Erev Rav has spoken...
25. High Court: Neither Jewish nor Democratic
Akiva   (03.25.12)
Jewish = Torah Democratic = Elected by the people. High Court are neither.
26. THIS VERDICT IS A SHAME !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (03.25.12)
27. Ha! Ha! Ha! TATA @#5!
Israeli 2   (03.25.12)
You are exposing your true anti-semitic colors. More colorful than your flag. I am laughing at you because you try to anger us but fail miserably.
28. Anti-Hashem not-Supreme court rules it is above the law.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (03.25.12)
29. Israel's High Court is intolerable.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.25.12)
Once again, Israel's High Court has proven that it is a force of evil. It's decisions run counter to Israel's vital interests. It demonstrates no loyalty to Israel whatsoever. The time is long overdue to bring the court under the control of the Knesset and Israeli people. Also it must be reformed. It is ridiculous to allow radical leftists to dominate Israel's court system. The current High Court situation is intolerable.
30. I wonder if Mr Begin "would understand"
John Robey ,   Austin, Texas   (03.26.12)
if Palestians occupied Jewish private property because they "were on a mission." It would be OK right?
Next talkbacks
Back to article