News
Report: Iran strike to delay nuke work by 6 months
Ynet
Published: 28.03.12, 23:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
1. recall the US 2007 erroneous report
mohson   (03.28.12)
The US is full of crap on the effect of a strike. It would set iran back 2-4 years and give some time for regime uprising since kameini's ayatollah's are a death cult who have pushed persians to the end of their rope. Many revolutionary guard are ready to overthrow kamenei who has his getaway plane on standby 24/7 ready to fly him to Moscow, saudi arabia or damascus.
2. but longer if attack all seats of power, government, religio
ralph   (03.28.12)
government centres, seats of power, religious schools, kill the head, arms and legs and leave it defenceless to attack by its people and it will be gone for ever. very short sighted report.
3. One strike finished Saddam Husseins
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (03.28.12)
nuke dreams ONCE AND FOR ALL !!!!!!! Sounds not too bad ?! JUST GO FOR IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
4. Exceedingly unsurprised by that final assessment
Cameron ,   USA   (03.29.12)
As are you. Only the sheer weight of US muscle and ability stands to pull Israel's fat out of the fire on this one. We all knew it would come down to this, no?
5. This is called a PSYOP the U.S. is famous for it.
Jake ,   USA   (03.28.12)
Don't believe one word. Israel has the most potent air force in the world. It can and will destroy Iran's nuclear program. It can and will destroy Iran's regime if the result of strike is all-out war with the Mullahs.
6. More Hussein crap
Frank ,   Canada   (03.29.12)
Hussein is in total disarray. He is farting ridiculous propaganda to avoid a strike.
7. Then an attack after the first 6 months ....
carlos ,   San Diego U.S.A.   (03.29.12)
would be easier since Iran's defenses will be damaged. Hit them until they break down.
8. Article a Deflection: Israel could wipe Iran clean
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (03.29.12)
of its nuclear sites. Not to mention having three or four subs with ballistic missiles right off the coast after having sunk iranian subs: a little computer virus set Iran back a year; a barrage of arrow2 missiles would devastate Iran, its confidence and deliver a sure message that Israel will NOT tolerate a tyrannical regime in their neighborhood, threatening to use nuclear weapons against it. Further; the arab world is in total turmoil; the mullahs and imams are becoming very unpopular: even the muslim brotherhood is becoming more and more moderate, especially in light of Ghadaffis downfall and humiliation. Assad is next, Iran will follow and Turkey will completely back off its ottoman quest and humble itself unless it too wants a whooping. The west has been planning to obliterate Irans regime for decades: the practice runs in Iraq and Afghanistan have proven indespensible in gauging iran's demise and destruction.
9. Ynet supports US propaganda against a strike
(03.29.12)
10. Facts - US is clueless about Israel or Iran capabilities.
Observer ,   New York,, USA   (03.29.12)
While they know some about the HARDWARE capabilities, they don't know about the HUMAN capabilities. Two nations of two different thinking - Survival and Destruction Israel MUST survive. As the say goes - necessity is the mother of all invention .. and I will add not all by military hardware.
11. 6 months... or 60 years?
Robert ,   USA   (03.29.12)
It is not possible to predict how long any strike by Israel would set back Iran's nuclear weapon ambitions. The strike itself may only set back the potential for Iran to develop nuclear weapons by many months to a few years, but a strike and followup attacks, along with continued punitive sanctions might cause Iran's leadership to give up nuclear ambitions entirely, or even bring about regime change when it is demonstrated that the Iran government cannot protect its own people.. A military analysis like this only addresses physical damages, not other changes that might occur as a result.
12. amahdinejad
Beary White ,   Norway   (03.29.12)
The main crazy thing with Ahmadinejad ; he does not care if he kills some millions of arabs in neighboring contries, when he fails in wiping Israel off the map...for him an arab life means nothing.
13. Hope springeth eternal, #3 & 5
Cameron ,   USA   (03.29.12)
But Israel's ass is truly on this Persian hook.
14. Reality? Who wants man's reality? We have G-d's reality...
ZionistBill ,   Israel   (03.29.12)
...and that reality has served us well for 4000 years. I'm with the others on this board: Israel can do anything. Did we not recently conquor Lebanon? Did we not recently kill a lot of Palestinian civilians? We can show any of our neighbors how tough we are, and surely we can show the Iranians. We took out Iraq's nukes, how much harder would it be to take out Iran's? Do the Americans know about our mission to take out Iraq's nukes? Probably not, as they also didn't predict WWI. So how knowledgeable could they be? LOL!
15. So bring it on.
Kaml Kamsour ,   Iran   (03.29.12)
So bring it on. You think we are afraid of you ? We are waiting for you Israelis since the past 5 years to attack us, so that we can teach you a lesson once & for all. Kindly stop blowing hot-air and start the war immediately.
16. This report assumes that an attack
Stephen in New York   (03.29.12)
will be a repeat of historical attacks with some updates and enhancements, but essentially a variation of what has gone before. It will not be anything like the past. We know this. ("We'" is me and the cat, Poogie Woogie). What if some interested party shuts down the Iranian power grid for a couple of years? Meow adds Poogie Woogie.
17. iran
gene ,   ny.usa   (03.29.12)
Blah Blah Blah . Strike now or face elimination
18. Israel wouldn't dare start a war with Iran..
Chris.B ,   Australia   (03.29.12)
for fear of its own safety. Iran would be compelled to obtain nuclear weapons for a start and this would start a nuclear arms race in the Middle East.
19. The U.S. is an ostrich ....
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.12)
... with its head in the sand. Israel will not be looking to delay Iran's nuclear ambitions; Israel will be looking to put an end to it, permanently. Think of Iran as a giant glowing cinder.
20. # 3:Osirak was easy
Aren Haich ,   Copenhagen Denmark   (03.29.12)
When comparing Israel's attack on Iraq's Osirak in 1981 with the potential bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities, one should remember that Saddam’s Iraq at the time of Israel’s bombing was fighting the most intensive and crucial stage of its long war with Iran. Israeli leaders knew that all of Saddam’s military might was pointing east towards Iran, and that the likelihood of an Iraqi retaliation against Israel was minimal and manageable: Saddam did not have long range missiles, and the threat from Iraqi jets could easily be contained by the IDF. Even then; Ariel Sharon recalls the Begin cabinet decision approving the attack “as the most difficult in Israel’s history”.
21. I wish Israel could destroy Irans nuclear program but sadly
Adam ,   USA   (03.29.12)
I don't think they can through an air assault. None of the responses seem to consider the withering response that Iran will launch if attacked. This would likely prohibit any "follow-up" attacks, The destruction of Osirak and the Syrian nuclear facility were brilliant military operations but far simpler then what it would take to seriously effect Irans capability. The USA can do it using the B-2 to drop the 30000 lb MOP. Iran would not know what hit them. But after fighting two protracted wars and with a teetering economy the USA will not attack. All that can be done is to continue along the current path ... covert operations / sanctions /regime change
22. More biased rubbish from the Obama regime.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.29.12)
The Obama regime would prefer any result over Israel destroying Iran's nukes and saving herself. This report is more biased rubbish from the Obama regime intended to discourage Israel. Destroy Iran's nukes NOW!
23. Iran Nukes
JOHN SULIOT ,   Swannanoa   (03.29.12)
So wait six months and do it again (and again).
24. DO NOTHING AND DIE
LARRY ,   US ARMY RETIRED   (03.29.12)
THAT IS WHAT THE WORLD REALLY WISHES ISRAEL THAT IS REALITY. NEVER AGAIN REQUIRES PHYSICAL ACTION NOT TALK .
25. More Disinformation from Obama
Ross ,   Henderson, USA   (03.29.12)
This President and his supporters will do anything to undermine the Israeli Government. This is just more disinformation designed to instill hesitation and fear.
26. Laughing!
vit ,   usa   (03.29.12)
Pretty soon pro-Iran hacks will be writing "reports" that a strike will only set back Iran's program by two weeks.
27. The great thing about aircraft
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.29.12)
Is that unlike missiles and rockets, they fly home get more fuel and bombs and can do it all over again as many times as required.
28. 'Effect of Iran strike unclear' - No sh..kidding.
leo ,   usa   (03.29.12)
29. Cameron @ 4, there is certainly a possibility
leo ,   usa   (03.29.12)
and I do not think you are stating anything people here do not know already, but the choice is always between bad and worst and burden of this choice is still on Israel.
30. ZionistBill @14, I am not sure, but I feel your irony
leo ,   usa   (03.29.12)
is misplaced.
Next talkbacks
Back to article