News  World News
Grass: Israeli entry ban reminds me of Stasi
Reuters
Published: 11.04.12, 22:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. Guenter reminds me of a piece of pig pong
Yanni   (04.12.12)
Excuses to pigs everywhere.
32. GG
Ari Gold ,   LA USA   (04.12.12)
Grass is a provocateur. He is loving all the attention that he is getting from this useless poem. People love to blame Jews for every problem in the world.
33. #16: Anyone who is Meshige is you.
Israeli 2   (04.12.12)
34. mr. grass
(04.12.12)
the stench of nazism and antisemitism is emenating from not only your past, but from the pen which you used to write your idiotic poem. it is that stench that israel doesn't want to smell upon your arrival on our shores. purely the stench. this is why you are stench non grata in israel.
35. News: Ex-SS Storm Trooper Claims Persecution By The Jews!
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (04.12.12)
36. GG is an idiot
Ron ,   OC, US   (04.12.12)
Like he wants to come to Israel...The man is a disgrace, PERIOD! I would no longer give him the forum that he wants. He like Carter is to be ignored. They can both howl at the moon.
37. And David Grossman?
Michel ,   Jerusalem   (04.12.12)
He published almost the same in an European paper and nobody in Israel cares or dare criticize Grossman. Why ?
38. I thought Israel was democratic ...
AQ ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.12.12)
... where it can tolerate criticism allowing speech and opinion freedom. So what now ... Israel is gonna ban everyone it doesn't like how he or she thinks. Just like banning Norman Finkelstein who is in fact Jewish!
39. The STASI wouldn't let anyone OUT you SUPERFICIAL NITWIT!!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (04.12.12)
40. A nazi roach
Mahlon Drumgoole ,   Newark NJ USA   (04.12.12)
You can't win a war of words with a psychopatic nazi like Grass. Just let him talk and expose himself as the deranged SS nazi he still is. Remember, Hitler's last message was to blame the German people and , of course, the Jews for Germany's near destruction by the allied nations. Like the true psychopath, Hitler refused to acknowledge any blame for the war. Eichmann gleefully said that he would go to his grave laughing--also the mark of a souless creature who did not have the capacity to feel guilt over killing so many people. Grass undoubtedly took part in Germany's war crimes as a volunteer in the SS. His BS about urginhg Germany to deal with their past waqs nothing more than an attempt to be idolized by the fools in his literary world.
41. The Nazi
Stefan Soback ,   Israel   (04.12.12)
Gunter Grass has a Nazi past and, how surprising, it has caught up with him. I'd just like to remind mr. Grass of the basics of anti-Semitism. Through 2000 years the Jews have been accused of things that they never did. Germany and its Nazis (like you) undertook the Holocaust, an extermination of a nation. YOU really did it. We have never nuked anybody and we never will. We will never attack the Iranian people. At best, maybe (but just maybe) its nuclear facilities. What a world of difference. So, mr. Grass, keep the lid on it. You and your nation has a long way to go until you are at any position to criticize us.
42. Put him out of his misery...
Harrybaby ,   Canada   (04.12.12)
Its time to put this pathetic ex-nazi out of his misery. Now that he has seen Israel born out of the ashes of his holocaust, its time for the mossad to deal with him the same way they dealt with Eichman. Or maybe he should be kept around to watch as his beloved Reich is conquered by islam!
43. G. Grass = Waffen SS . He should shut up his bigmouth ASAP !
(04.12.12)
44. Once an SS war criminal - forever an SS war criminal
who cares   (04.12.12)
That Germany is not officially condemning the SS war criminal Grass shows once more : Germany still didnt get it - Germany will NEVER get it !
45. I guess s.s. in his case must mean stupid
jason white ,   afula, israel   (04.12.12)
shit. I guess he regrets not helping to finish the Final Solution. Don't worry grass, there are others who would be happy to finish us off. You had your chance, now STFU!
46. Said the Nazi -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (04.12.12)
All that the Komunist Socialist in Former East - Germany, did against the National - Socialist was not wrong. But Israel is not Komunist - Socialistic, but can do something Right albait that.. Arn.Sweden.
47. Enough attention given to this old fart
Deb ,   US   (04.12.12)
He's just a garden variety Israel basher and a pretty boring one at that.
48. Grass, twice during the past several decades, has entered...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (04.12.12)
...Israel, and each time he violated his visa application when he stated that he was not affiliated with the Nazi party of German, according to Qol Israel (the Voice of Israel radio). Twice he lied, despite the fact that he volunteered to serve in the Waffen SS. Thus, he should know, Jews have the right not to allow former Nazis into their national home, especially after they lied twice about their past...!!
49. The moral equivilent defense
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (04.12.12)
You will only see this from the secular Left, who use the devious (hint: snake-like) argument to confuse a moral issue, by blurring the lines between right and wrong, good and the "E" word. To know the future listen to the most degenerate heroes of the Left, and that is where the world will be in 10 years. It's called the 'theory of evolution'.
50. Far from condoning Grass
Sagi   (04.12.12)
I wish to point out to all those using terms like SS and Nazi and war criminal that they are not only stupid but they are far beyond that. If the man is 84 today then he was born in 1928. This being the case he could not have been more than 14/15 or so at the height of the Nazi regime and in the middle of wwii. Hardly a candidate for terms like war criminal or Nazi as have been used here. A person of that age is called a minor and is not responsible for his actions, in contrast to the man of today who is indeed responsible for what he states and does. His condemnation of Israel is truly outrageous but Yishai's response was ridiculous and unwarranted and serves no purpose whatsoever except to add fuel to the flames. It is concrete proof that he and his likes should not be at the helm of government.
51. Even a donkey does not stumble twice over the same stone…
Jack Klaber ,   Israel   (04.12.12)
GG, your reactions and views are now crystal clear and cannot anymore be interpreted otherwise than anti-Semitic!
52. thats a good one coming fro a former SS man
zionist forever   (04.12.12)
He was condemned and made a persona non grata in Israel after his last little comment and so not this former SS man wants something new to say in some kind of childish tit for tat game. You were mean to me so I will be mean to you and say more not nice things before I go running to my daddy.
53. Turnspeech
Raphael ,   netanya   (04.12.12)
Neither Stasi nor Gestapo ever prevented anybody entering Germany. On the contrary, people were welcome as slave laborers or gas chamber guests. However, it was a real problem to escape without being shot or eaten by SS or Vopo dogs.
54. #50
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (04.12.12)
You are right, Grass was a boy during the Nazi regime. At 17 when Germany's defeat was clear, he volunteerd for the U-boats, the most ideologically faithful unit in Germany: he and his family must have been fervent Nazis. Instead, he was inducted to the Waffen SS, not Wehrmacht, not civil defense. Again, it shows his ideological fervor, feelings of racial superiority and Jew hatred. So you can justify Grass as much as you want: his opinions are shared by millions: Fatah, Hamas and Iran, Neo-nazis and radical Leftists, extreme Catholics and Klansmen, skinheads and Arab firsters. Like others, Grass is laying the groundwork for a future genocide of the Jews, while falsely accusing Israel of genocide. The difference is that he wore the uniform of the Waffen SS. The POS should shut up.
55. ''It reminds me''
tiki ,   belgium   (04.12.12)
Israel // Stasie. Now, this is the latest compliment. Let's see with what the 'friends of Israel (critic is not Jew-hate) will come up next , because slowly they start to run out of ''blessings''. It looks like Eli Yishai has 'hit a nerve with the old senile SS'er with the Nobel prize.
56. He can kiss my tuchas
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.12.12)
what an ass, he knew full well that his anti semitic, anti israel 'poet' would stir up controversy, he got it and, now, continues with his nonsense and flimsy, nasty, excuses to continue his rant rather than to accept responsibility for remaining a nazi.
57. Anyone got a wooden stake?
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.12.12)
I got the hammer....
58. showing, again, how morally obtuse the old fool is.
rick ,   walnut creek   (04.12.12)
this old fool could make a statement comparing Israel to a police state because, for this old fool, IT'S ALL ABOUT HIM. if one is nice to him, honors his foolish conjectures, celebrates his grotesque slanders and distortions, he's OK. if one criticizes gunther's stupidity and his bias, and reacts defensively to the outrageous assaults, then the critic is like the stasi. a swine with a pipe in its mouth is still a swine.
59. the hitler youth has spoken
JL   (04.12.12)
60. Unrepentant SS men forbiden to enter
Zeev ,   Rehovot,   (04.12.12)
Israeli low forbids unrepentant former SS men entering. Using Goebbels like libel, SS men Grass proved, that he remain unrepentant. That is Israeli message to Grass and to the world. As for Stasi, Grass always was DDR sympathizer. He easy cross the lines between National Socialism and, Soviet Socialism just dew to their common hatred to democracy and capitalism and their propaganda using “doublespeak” . It is possible that he know about Stasi more then we think.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article