Jewish Scene
Haredim oppose Yardena Arazi performance at J'lem ceremony
Tzipi Malchov
Published: 13.05.12, 14:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. There is no greater contribution...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.13.12)
than to help the needy.At that,the Haredi people are without competition. Also they are very humble and don t ask for recognition.
2. U mean the Haredim & their black flags r coming 2....
MF ,   Israel   (05.13.12)
Jerusalem Day? or are they going to attend just to be Polish-Jewish and Lithuanian-Jewish anti-zionist sticks in the mud? I say ban them! and let Yardena sing! After all having her sing is a better use of my Arnona (municipal tax money) than to give my Arnona away to the very generous Haredim so that they can claim that they are charitable! which brings me to TBer #1 Pah-leez! "they are very humble and don't ask for recognition" oh really? I can show you at least a dozen advertisement books from fancy Haredi Charitable organizations...all of them have names and are color coded for amounts given ... really Ora get real!
3. Ora
Michael ,   Haifa   (05.13.12)
I am one of the millions of workers who support the needy Haredim through my taxes. They are needy because they do not work and "need" my money. They do not recognize me, for I am in sufficiently jewish for them, and like the goyim in the shtetl, I am only recognized as such for being a sucker for them.
4. JUSTICE FOR ALL=IT I$ ALL ABOUT MONEY EQUAL DI$TRIBUTION
me   (05.13.12)
NO RIGHTI$T AND NO LEFTI$T,NO OFFICIAL AND NO OPPO$ITION.NO ONE CAN EARN HUNDRED$ TIME$ MORE MONEY THAN ANYONE AND THAT I$ THE WORLD WE ARE LIVING IN!!!!!!
5. #1 haredim is hebrew for "beggars" - haredim are the needy
Israeili Jew ,   Israel   (05.13.12)
or con artists
6. It's not haredim who oppose it
(05.13.12)
It's OUR Torah, the Torah for Religious and Secular Jews. The same Torah that gave us the right to the land of Israel and told us to keep Shabbat and eat only kosher food, opposes women singing in front of men. Daily poking fun at G-d and His laws must be giving you tremendous pleasure.
7. 2 MF Aren t you a bit confused?
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.13.12)
What you describe is marketing,and is not related to the quality of being humble and asking for recognition.
8. @ #6
M. Davison ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (05.13.12)
Show me where halakha or Torah forbid hearing a woman singing. You can't because there is no place in either. What you're talking about is Custom (minhag), which is merely the result of a particular rabbi's interpretation of various psukim. On the contrary, there are concrete examples in the Torah of women singing before men as equals. It's only today's misogynistic rabbis who find a need to make themselves relevant with superfluous decrees and even decrees that contradict what is written in the Tanakh. The ones who should worry about God's reaction are those supposedly "learned" rabbis whoise only pleasure in life is to make the lives of their followers miserable. I wonder what God will have in store for them? Ritual followed blindly is no substitute for intelligent belief.
9. 3Michael,I am a Haredi...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.13.12)
thanks G-D i do not need your tax money,and i know lots of Haredim who work.And there are many Secular people who live on your tax money. I appreciate you ,and for me ,secular Jews are 100% Jews if their mother is Jewish.And you are surely not a sucker.And my Haredi acquaintances think like me. The trouble is,you know the Haredi by what you read in the papers,which are full of lies. Thank you for your comment,direct conversation is the best way to know each other. If you have any questions ,it will be a real pleasure for me to answer them. You sound like a decent guy. Shavua Tov,Michael.
10. @6 well no...
secular Jew ,   Jerusalem   (05.13.12)
the Torah has no such prohibition and you know it because if it did you would have given up Book, Chapter and Verse. and naturally you really don't want to mention Miriam (Moshe Rabenu's sister) dancing and singing which does appear in the Torah! The prohibition you are so seriously mis-remembering is Talmudic and it jumps off the sentence "Kol Isha Erva" and then explains that men are not allowed to hear women sing and NOT that women are not allowed to sing. What did you think that we secular are stupid? Forget you are the one who is!
11. @1 given that 4 of 7* TBs disagree w/you...
Jerusalemite ,   Israel   (05.13.12)
perhaps it is you who ought to be humble and admit that there is a strong possibility that you are wrong! *I am actually being generous because 2 of the 7 are yours.
12. @2 Neturei Karta are not Hardim
rebecca ,   Modiin   (05.13.12)
13. Did the haredi council members suggest any one else?
rebecca ,   Modiin   (05.13.12)
If they dont have anything better to suggest then they are the ones saying Haredim dont have anything to offer.
14. Ora , where you , and i lived ,
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.13.12)
charidim worked , and studied tora . At least most , if not all , of them . This contrary to what is happening here . You wrote : there are many seculars who live on your tax money . Can you give details ? what kind of people ? retired ones ? ill ones ? But contrary to charidim , they are NOT paid to study unnecessary subjects .
15. Time to take back the country from the primitives
Steven ,   Teaneck   (05.13.12)
16. 14 Charles,face it ...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.13.12)
The haredi have learned the rules of the democratic political game,and now they play better than any one else. Nothing i can do.Sorry.
17.  To ORA at 9
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (05.14.12)
Do you recognize Reform Jews as Jews?
18. Ora's other shoe drops
mea   (05.14.12)
Ora, first you declare you and 'many other' Haredis work. Then you thumb your nose at us with your declaration to Charles. And that is apparently how you look at things--that the Haredis "play the gAME" better than anybody else, and so that is that...? Israelis are massive suckers, just massive, massive suckers to allow one sector to leach off the rest. Try selling this to US Jews considering aliyah.
19. The tax paying public...
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.14.12)
are the people that should be allowed to make such decisions - and we are FOR Yardena Arazi performing. When the **vast majority** of the haridim are working and paying taxes like the rest of us, Jerusalem will be a better city with more money for the truly needy.
20. Ora , nazis came to power by democratic rules too
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.14.12)
21. Let both sides win!
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (05.14.12)
Here in London it was the custom for generations that at weddings the Rabbonim departed after the Grace after meals and before the mixed dancing. Today there is a lot less mixed dancing. Why can't the main part of the presentations take place, followed by a pause for those who want to leave before the female soloist begins. We need a compromise to satisfy both sides.
22. 17 John Even a Jew with a Jewish...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.14.12)
mother who convert to Islam is a Jew. Regarding the Reform Jews,the statistics say that the following generations have mixed marriages with non Jewish girls,hence their children are not anymore Jewish.
23. 18 mea,in life everything is not...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.14.12)
or black or white. There are good and bad elements in all societies.Pointing the finger at one society is WRONG. We can continue with the hatred,or we can try to settle our differences by negociating,with the tools democratie gives us. I believe the Tora study is a must for Israel.If the Israel state will not be able anymore to help the Tora students,i am convinced they will find enough sponsors who know that helping Tora students is a Beraha. The best proof is that Israel is one of the only states,if not the only,who did not get broke during the world economical crisis. Look at the Satmars,who don t take money of the State.They receive plenty of money of rich sponsors. The young couples live all in decent modern apartments. Believe me mea,you will gain nothing by stopping to help the Haredim.You will not pay less taxes,and the money will go to who knows were. Need i say more? Have a fine week,mea.
24. 20 Charles, excellent argument.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.14.12)
I need some more time to find a valuable answer.
25. Haredim are without competition as schnorrers.
S.F. Stoner ,   Carmiel, Israel   (05.14.12)
They are driving working people out of Jerusalem, and if they are so humble, why are they begging for recognition.
26. Why this leftist extremist woman ??
LeftistToSingInJeru ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.14.12)
Arazi when she had her morning tv show was alwasys making anti religous and anti setller remarks why this woman was choses suddenly ? It shows that those in the leftist media spotlight always seem to get the "spoils" when it comes to publicity and especially MONEY !!
27. #2 MF I'm still LMAO great responce!!!
Mike ,   Raanana Israel   (05.14.12)
28. # 6, Kol Hatan vekol Kalah
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (05.14.12)
How many haredim do you know,who were carried away from the good path,because they have listend to women singing ?.anything,if its not logical,should be rejected.
29. 25 Cheer up ! Men with poor hearts
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.14.12)
are worse off,given they can not be helped.
30. 21 Sh.Holmes Wise words.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.14.12)
Next talkbacks
Back to article