News
Man stabbed to death for complaining about noise
Ilana Curiel
Published: 05.05.12, 20:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. Take a breath 4 instead of all the finger pointing
Lauren   (05.06.12)
A man is dead, dont use this as an opportunity to start preaching about politics or religion. What happened was stupid and terrible whomever did it. Lets keep the orphaned family in mind and hope they find peace
32. to 29- you have got to be kidding
Barney ,   USA   (05.06.12)
our troubled youth are in certain areas? wrong, prejudiced and naieve. they are everywhere. Most are caught? wrong, very few are caught. severly punished? wrong again. most get nothing, maybe slap on wrist. have to stay home for a few weeks. edithann, you have one quality that can be observed and that is consistency. consistently wrong about everything you address. consistently prejudiced against Jews and Israel. I am grateful for this. We don't need people of your caliber "supporting" us. Your ignorance is just where it belongs-with the opposition. toodaloo
33. BARUCH DAYAN HA'EMET
Yoch ,   Y'layim, IL   (05.06.12)
34. Catch them and hang them by their BAITZIM!
Rio ,   New York   (05.06.12)
35. #6
mark ,   ca   (05.06.12)
yaaaakov,you have no clue about American cops.There is a bad apples but majority are way better in every aspect than their Israeli colleagues.Stop criticizing US cops and worry about your own backyard.
36. #26
mark ,   ca   (05.06.12)
have a sip of kool-aid.
37. sorry #26, post was addresed to#29
mark ,   ca   (05.06.12)
#29, have 10 bottles of kool-aid.
38. #11. Not just in Beer Sheva
5th generation ,   Israel   (05.06.12)
All over the country - criminals are supported much better than any honest citizen. We are just a source of cash.
39. #10 Stay in America
HumHum   (05.06.12)
where morons like you belong. It's Be'er Sheva. The likelihood of those teenagers being Arab is very low. Ignorant dumbass Americans.
40. High Culture!!!!!!!
Asa   (05.06.12)
Sorry to disapoint you, but its simply the 'high culture' Israel benefited from ......russia (it's sadly the truth, spin it as you wish, you cannot hide it. Confront it and the community will tackle it. Ignore it at your peril,)
41. Police here do nothing....
Yvonne ,   Netanya, Israel   (05.06.12)
This could have been me, my son stopped me complaining about terrible noise under our house, we are on the first floor and constantly have people under the house arguing sometimes till 4:00am. You ring the police but there is no action, I believe people have given up calling as they know no help is available unless it turns out to be tragic as in this case.
42. Unruly and lawless youths!
Shoshieb ,   Migdal, Israel   (05.06.12)
There is not enough discipline in the home/school/recreation areas. They are not punished - they should spend a minimum of 10 years in jail. At school - they should be severly punished or expelled until the police/psychiatrist allows them back in school. The parents should be held responsible for letting their children out with knives etc. and for drinking and not discipling them There should be punishment for underage drinking (the drinking-age should be raised to 21). We have in our moshav underage drivers zooming around and making noise in the middle of the night on the 4x4 dirt bikes... and they don't mind stopping in front of my house and chatting (talking extremely loudly) and revving their engines.. there should be laws, like in yesteryear, and should be followed. What are we coming to? These children are our future leaders???
43. Sign Of The Times
J Smith ,   UK   (05.06.12)
This regularly happens in the UK.Same scenario group of drunken/drugged teens stab someone complaining.Its a result of poor parenting and western culture .
44. Revolting, outrageous!
Israeli 2   (05.06.12)
A coutry of LIARS, the whole Police is a disgusting notorious bunch of liars, crooks, criminals and slobs!!!
45. State schools should give priority..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.06.12)
to teaching civil behaviour ABOVE all other lessons.The bad elements ,which are influencing the good elements, should be rejected from normal schools and sent to special disciplinary schools. Only when conscience will precede science Israel will be,as the world expect her to be, a light among the nations
46. Lots of noise pollution in Holland.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (05.06.12)
47. A punishment fit the crime
Yael ,   Meitar   (05.06.12)
I hope these kids are sentenced to 20 years minimum (no parole), hard labor and that every penny they ever earn is paid to the widow and orphans of the deceased. The police are completely impotent !!!!!
48. In connection with post #46 something went wrong!!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (05.06.12)
49. Again with post #48. It was "inadvertently" sent, not yet ..
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (05.07.12)
ready. I also technically don't understand why it was sent prematurely. What I wanted to express was first of all that it is a TERRIBLE TRAGEDY for the young family! And that in connection with noise pollution of all sorts and levels the authorities should be far more on the ball. That's why in cases like this I find the traditional brachah "Dayan HaEmet" slightly "misplaced". The stress should be far more on this worldly LAW and ORDER. Once again, the authorities have to take noise pollution far more seriously!! In other words they are co-responsible here. It is beyond any comprehension why people would react so violently. I believe a "case" like this warrants the death penalty. How G-d awful SAD!! Once more, authorities DO your job!! It isn't just a bit of noise. I suffer from a severe kind of tinnitus and can't filter any sounds either. Too much noise for too long CAN be a total ONSLAUGHT against one's nerves. I can very well understand why the victim impulsively and deep down trustingly went outside to ask those "people" to pipe it down. Their reaction (even if drugged) is beyond the pale of humanity. No, "Dayan HaEmet" feels wrong. People are responsible, the perpetrators of this heinous act and the authorities. There are no words to say to the widow and her little daughter. Later on realise that what the victim did was right, normal and good for a mentsh who trusts in his fellow human beings core of goodness. ALAV HASHALOM.
50. Religious
Sallee ,   Haifa   (05.17.12)
Well, what a surprise - the murderer was religious - like most of the people you see getting arrested these days!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article