News
Suspicion: Israelis harvested organs from the needy
Eli Senyor
Published: 22.05.12, 14:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. Harvesting organs ....
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.22.12)
.... is routine in India and other places in the Far East for the benefit of American recipients who are willing to pay upwards of $1 million per organ. Sadly, it has become commonplace in the West. I am sad to see that Israelis are involved, but they are certainly not the worst of the culprits -- a fact which will surely fall by the wayside. Of that I have no doubt. Israel will be villified in the international press, while the worst culprits are the United States, Canada, the U.K., France and Japan. I'm not too sure about the bit about being "thrown into the street," but that would be the fault of the local hospital, wouldn't it? And the countries who permit them to operate, knowing full well what is being done and, doubtless, whose administrators collect a hefty fee for looking away.
2. Oh no..another fabrication against those "innocent" jews
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (05.22.12)
I wonder what they have to say to this one....lias as usual??! Riiiiiight.
3. #2
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (05.22.12)
What is your problem? Just as not all Wieners called Peter are sociopath racists, not all Israelis are law-abiding citizens. Like everywhere, there are criminals. What the article did not mention is that so far the only person ever caught murdering people to harvest their organs was the muslim Hashim Thaci.
4. Peter, not sure I like the generalisation
David Wolper ,   London, England   (05.22.12)
Jews have good and bad as well as Austrian's, English and Germans. If the Israeli police have made an arrest why would this be a lie? I think that is all we would have to say on this.
5. Peter cannot read or has serious problems?
Maurice Solovitz ,   London, UK   (05.22.12)
the article states that arrests have been made IN ISRAEL. The issue is that it is a serious problem throughout the Western World and worse - anywhere that there are wealthy people willing to pay for someone elses organs. I am certain that Peter is outraged at the harvesting that takes place in Austria but perhaps because you are so good at denying any responsibility for any crimes done in your name - you aren't particularly worried?
6. #2
Sane ,   Manchester   (05.22.12)
Ah yes a traditional Austrian. You see no one is going to defend these people. If they had made clear the risks etc. they still would have been breaking the law but people would be sympathetic. As it was they didn't, and no-one is going to defend them. And they were arrested by Israeli, Jewish police.
7. Sarah B, can't believe it's true...hahahaha
(05.22.12)
8. #2
Nice Bloke ,   Rochdale, UK   (05.22.12)
What's your problem? The suspects have been arrested and if there is a case to answer they will face the full weight of the law.
9. 1 - Caught with your hand in the cookie jar? ,...
split ,   US   (05.22.12)
BTW, who were the brokers and traffickers arrested and found guilty in US organ "recycling" and money laundering business? Levy Izhak Rosenbaum rings the bell ? Just in case you want to learn more google "Levy Izhak Rosenbaum Pleads Guilty" ,...
10. #2 Peter, You're a Moron!
Alex ,   Texas, USA   (05.22.12)
by your logic all the people in Vienna are morons as well. Hmmm...
11. Peter in Vienna
Leon ,   Grand Rapids USA   (05.22.12)
They were arrested by Jews, you idiot.
12. To Peter,,,,
aline silverman ,   Israel   (05.22.12)
NO lies...WE in Israel arrested them....
13. #9 Split
(05.22.12)
By any chance do you also know the name of the Italian-American former dentist who was using body parts from corpses in a deal with certain funeral homes? Well, unfortunately, none of these bones and organs were ever tested and people who unknowingly received these parts in hospitals who thought they were dealing with a reputable medical professional ended up with things like AIDS and hepatitis and dying as a result. But since this criminal wasn't a Jew, I guess it's no big deal.
14. "Israelis" only? I bet that EVERYBODY does that
(05.22.12)
but only us are honest enough to report about us. And anti-Semites make sure that only Jews are singled out for this. So no, I'm not impressed or outraged, except for maybe the anti-Semitism so prevalent in the "free" and racist press, which is run by the extreme-left and Islamic elements. They all seem to "cleanse" their crimes by singling out Jews. Outrageous and sickening.
15. Is that the same of killing people?
mandala ,   zimbabwe, rusape   (05.22.12)
16. 4, 5, 6, 8, 11 - Missing an important facts ,...
split ,   US   (05.22.12)
They're on Interpol's wanted list since 2008, they ran from justice and found safe haven in Israel ,...
17. 13 - Rule # 1 in hasbara tactics ,...
split ,   US   (05.22.12)
Caught with your hand in the cookie jar, try to divert the attention by pointing finger at someone else ,...
18. Whichever....
David ,   London, England   (05.22.12)
the only name in which these crimes are being committed is in those that have been arrested or yet to be arrested. The way Peter says it sounds a lot like a a variation of the blood libel.
19. 3 - only person ever caught murdering people to harvest
split ,   US   (05.22.12)
Try to distinct the term "cought" from "implicated" ,... Some figures from Thaçi's inner circle were accused of harvesting human organs from captives that supposed have been murdered for their kidneys, which were sold on the black market. Thaci was implicated but nothing was proven. An Israeli Jew Moshe Harel was accused as the the broker and another Israeli, Zaki Shapira, identified as co-conspirator. The Turkish doctor Yusuf Sonmez involved in this case and wanted by Interpol have a kind of a German (Yiddish?) sounding name for a Turk ;) ,...
20. From the needy for the needy
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (05.22.12)
21. peter & split ! brothers in hate,
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (05.22.12)
how much would you charge to sell your mother's kidney ?.people who hate are capable of everything,and always short on money.
22. Jews goyim slav arab black white - it's just disgusting
rebecca ,   Modiin   (05.22.12)
and I'm glad they have been caught and hope that if found guilty they are given harsh sentences.
23. World needs ALL OUT (covert?) WAR against crime&corruption!!
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (05.22.12)
24. Organs on Ebay
sk ,   USA   (05.22.12)
A few years ago, some people "auctioned" their kidneys on Ebay and I recall one auction went over $1 million. Ebay soon put a stop to it.
25. #1 Sarah B
Jared ,   CANADA   (05.22.12)
you know I always enjoy reading your posts, your usually spot on...but to include Canada where our healthcare is FREE paid for by the government just because were a "western" country is just ludicrous...back your statement up I think more of my country than that...
26. IT HAPPENED IN NJ/B"KLN WITH RABBI RECENTLY
ZIMBI ,   NJUSA   (05.22.12)
27. Moont
Dani ,   Israel   (05.22.12)
To number 15 (Mandala) you mont learn to write in e english before you share your thoughts and as for murder please send our regards to your murdering monkey leader Mr Mugaabie who you obviously sopport or else you would be amongst your starving brethren without internet
28. Attorneys are not asked for organs, not even destitute ones.
Michael ,   California, USA   (05.22.12)
29. as # 1 says in other nations this happens
Galut ia ,   Selah   (05.22.12)
and It is not a good thing ... voluntary Organ donation is not a bad thing in and of it self ...but taking advantage of low income populations that can ill afford it is wrong. whether it is doctors from India ,the united states or Israel ...this practice needs to stop...it is good that Israel Police's National Fraud Unit is involve in sorting this out.
30. # 1 - Nice try
Nina ,   NYC   (05.22.12)
"That U.S.-Latin American connection is dwarfed by a network of organ-trafficking organizations whose reach extends from former Soviet Republics such as Azerbaijan, Belarus and Moldova to Brazil, the Philippines, South Africa and beyond, a Bloomberg Markets investigation shows. Many of the black-market kidneys harvested by these gangs are destined for people who live in Israel." http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-01/organ-gangs-force-poor-to-sell-kidneys-for-desperate-israelis.html
Next talkbacks
Back to article