News
Gay Palestinian man petitions for asylum
Aviad Glickman
Published: 24.05.12, 23:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
1. Similar issue in the EU
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (05.24.12)
There have been cases of gay Muslims applying for asylum on the basis that gays suffer abuse in Muslim countries. We could find ouselves with a mass migration of Muslim gays to the EU! On the other hand this gay guy had lived in Israel and has a long-term Israeli partner.
2. Tough one here
Amichai ,   Huntsville, US   (05.25.12)
I don't know, maybe it's not that tough. If he's lived in Israel in peace for the last 10 years with the same partner, hasn't been in any trouble, applied through the legal channels & wants to contribute to Israel as a citizen, then I say let him. There are many worse people to worry about than a gay Muslim man who's life is indeed in danger if he's returned to the Palestinian Territories.
3. Send him to Gaza not Nablus
Palestinian   (05.25.12)
4. Didn't Israel boast about saving gay Palestinians?
Mark ,   VAncouver   (05.25.12)
Funny, Michael Oren was boasting to US audiences two weeks ago on how Israel saves gay Palestinians, yet when it's time to put your money where your mouth is, Oren is nowhere to comment. Is Isrrael using gay Palestinians for hasbara purposes?
5. Let him stay!
Susie ,   Scotland   (05.25.12)
Israel please let this man stay it is obvious he will be slaughtered if he is sent back to the West Bank! Although all the pro Palestinian supporters in the UK would tell you that no harm will come to him, cause the Palestinians are such tolerant peace loving people!
6. Use him in PR
Pedro ,   Brazil   (05.25.12)
Use him in PR to show to the world the truth about PA.
7. Sorry dude, but if you cant stand up and say
A ,   Belgium   (05.25.12)
in a loud and clear voice, with 5000 people standing beside you,..." I am seeking asylum in free and democratic Israel because the neanderthal palestinian authority will not grant me to live the life I want"...than take your chances in Nablus. There are enough parasites trying to take advantage of the freedom they have in Israel, the JEWISH state.
8. Anyone remember Sodom & Gomorrah?
Pasquinel ,   Canada   (05.25.12)
9. Gay Asylum Seeker
NYC Girl   (05.25.12)
Here's an idea. Grant this man asylum...and send the Naturei Karta to Nablus.
10. Is homosexuality allowed in the Jews religion???
Westbanker ,   WestBank   (05.25.12)
11. gay asylum in Israel
dmmd ,   bronx   (05.25.12)
If he wants to remain in Israel he should be required to be circumcised. Do you think he would stay?
12. #4 The High Court will likely grant his petition
Vlad   (05.25.12)
13. petition obumma, see if he gives you a visa for US.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (05.25.12)
14. Neaderthal authorities?
Rolly Heffez ,   Tampa, US   (05.25.12)
Dear #7, the Palestinian authorities aren't the only Neanderthals here, Eli Yishai is certainly giving them a run for their money and he is a racist hypocrite to boot.
15. The Religion Of Peace
(05.25.12)
Huh, seems the arabs are full of HUDDA!
16. We Jews lack of compassion, it's so sad
Yossef   (05.25.12)
we lack land too, but that's another problem.
17. #7
MR ,   Israel   (05.25.12)
Nobody could have said it better.
18. Let him stay...but make him tell all the leftist as$holes
A Jew ,   Galus, TX   (05.25.12)
19. To #16: we lack backbone too - you're proof of that
A Jew ,   Galus, TX   (05.25.12)
20. #10 Is Shabbat desecration allowed
Ilan   (05.25.12)
Homosexuality is not condoned by Jewish law but there is no obligation to punish people for it either. We do however have an obligation to treat people in kindness. Gay people deserve not to be discriminated against or to be treated in disrespect. Be kind it is good for you
21. EU
Dovid ,   Modiin   (05.25.12)
Maybe one of the EU countries would provide him a new home. This is not our problem.
22. Grant asylum ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.25.12)
... with no strings attached. The man is entitled to his privacy. His life has been hellish enough. Let him and his partner of many years live peacefully and quietly in Israel, while his family rots in Schehem. No need for loud or publicized press conferences. Sometimes, just knowing you have done the right thing is satisfaction enough. Grant him citizenship, too, if he wishes. I guarantee you that he will make a far better citizen of Israel than any member of Shalom Achshav.
23. His life is in danger, he should remain here
Rivkah F. ,   jerusalem   (05.25.12)
This man obviously is not a security risk. His life is in danger. He harms no one. If he is deported to Nablus, he will be killed at worst or his life will become unbearable. He should stay here.
24. Well... who took down Mr. Mubarak who let you guys live?
Miron ,   USA   (05.25.12)
If you can't stand own people who look upon you without deadly hate, how can we keep you? You will make our homeland into the same what you do to your own.
25. (1) Sherlock Holmes
tiki ,   belgium   (05.25.12)
Denied in Europe because of 'fear of mass migration of Muslim gays to EU but Israel should accept because the guy has lived there for a long time! Wake up call.....: asylum seeking Muslim gays also live in Europe for many years. But as usual...what's 'allowed for Europe is 'forbidden for Israel because it's in-human.
26. 21 It IS Israel's problem
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (05.25.12)
Since his Israeli partner is involved. They can't deport him ! And Israeli law provides supports for same sex relationships
27. You Jews can keep him...
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A.   (05.25.12)
You and his likes deserve each other...lol
28. #22 Sarah B
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A.   (05.25.12)
I can't believe my eyes... You Sarah B being compassionate towards a Palestinian? Could it be that it is something to do with your sexual preference? Are you seizing the opportunity to come out of the closet?
29. Despite muslim homophobia
Raphael ,   Netanya   (05.25.12)
All over the wold, gays&lesbians are sporting a staunch anti Israel, pro arab posture. Mybe they prioritize their taste upon their safety.
30. Send him to
Rami abu ghalyion ,   Ramallah   (05.25.12)
To Gaza No need kinda of those ppl in W.B
Next talkbacks
Back to article