Jewish Scene  Rabbi Levi Brackman
Why won’t God reveal himself again?
Rabbi Levi Brackman
Published: 27.05.12, 08:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. the REAL"sinai" is in saudi arabia
proudmuslim   (05.27.12)
"Then God opened her [Hagar] eyes and she saw a well of water. So she went and filled the skin with water and gave the boy a drink. God was with the boy as he grew up. He lived in the desert and became an archer. While he was living in the Desert of Paran, his mother got a wife for him from Egypt. At that time Abimelech and Phicol the commander of his forces said to Abraham, "God is with you in everything you do. (Genesis 21:19-22)" "He said: 'The LORD came from Sinai and dawned over them from Seir; he shone forth from Mount Paran. He came with myriads of holy ones from the south, from his mountain slopes.' (From the NIV Bible, Deuteronomy 33:2) jews need to learn basics, from muslims.
32. To #16!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (05.27.12)
As you live and rely on the Law of Moses: you will die by that Law! Have you broken any of the Ten Commandments? God says if one is broken...all are broken; one falls short of the glory of God and His righteousness. The blood of animals can't save you; thus, the need for the ultimate sacrifice for the remission of sin...the atoning blood of Jesus Christ (without it, one goes to HELL)! Your distorted view of the scriptures doesn't change the Truth of the New Covenant. Jesus' life fulfilled the Law, the Prophets and the Psalms (read Psalm 22: the Crucifixion)! God bless, Israel; a. Remant will come to the saving knowledge of Jesus Christ--their true Messiah, whom they rejected once.
33. Because god doesnt exist, its as easy as that..
David ,   EU   (05.27.12)
34. Irrational Rabbi...
JFT (Jew for Truth) ,   3rd. rock from Sun   (05.27.12)
...who can't even distinguish between"Jehova" Deity of the Is- raelites, a religious concept, and "God" a philosophical concept. (The Logos, or Nous, of the greek philosophers)
35. "Christians" Zionists? Impossible!!!
JFT (Jew for Truth) ,   3rd.rock from Sun)   (05.27.12)
If Jesus Preached Peace, Truth, Jus-p tice, how can a real Christian be Zionist? Stupivangelists : Yes, that,s what you are for sure, and gravely brain washed, too.,as Jewish Zionists also are.
36. Prophecy 101
Adam Neira ,   Paris, France   (05.27.12)
"The fact that this type of collective Divine revelation has only occurred once in history." Yes, but individual prophecy has occurred and was prophesied to return. The Tanach contains many instances of real prophecy from Isaiah, Ezekial, Jeremiah et al. The best description of what constitutes real prophecy is offered by Maimonides in pages 219 to 250 of "Guide for the Perplexed". BTW, the requirement of a prophet needing to exist before the Moshiach/King is crowned is satisfied if the Moshiach/King is a prophet himself. Is such a person alive and breathing right now on Planet Earth today ? Interesting times nu ?
37. It is needed EYES TO SEE to understand God's revelation!
Jouko ,   Finland   (05.27.12)
Here in Africa God reveals Himself almost everyday but eyes to see are needed to understand His revelation. Besides why do you want Him to reveal Himself again - He has already revelead Himself, you just now have to obey to what He has said.
38. Follow the light you have, then you will be given more light
Jouko ,   Finland   (05.27.12)
39. He will reveal Himself to you
Andy ,   Ghana   (05.27.12)
It's only a fool who says there is no God. He will reveal himself to you and you witness for Him. Mark my words
40. He was serious when he said we will inherit his creatio
Miron ,   USA   (05.27.12)
one mitzvot he sat for himself.
41. To the Dumb Atheists...
JFT (Jew for Truth) ,   3rd. rock from Sun   (05.27.12)
Know that all the great geniuses believed in God: Pythagoras, Plato, Galileo, Newton Max Planck Einstein, Spinoza, Kant, Descartes, Jung, Columbus, etc. All of them, except Freud, who obviously thought of himself as God. And Darwin? Well, he was a genius...of madnes!!! This Brit was surely hallucinated by the equatoerial Sun of the Galapagos... and couldn't "evolve" after wards...
42. To (JFT) Jew for Truth
Z.Z. Coltrane ,   USA   (05.28.12)
You are no less dumb...than the Atheists'! Unless you both repent and turn to the saving knowledge of Grace (found only in Jesus Christ), you both will end-up in HELL (Christ preached more about Hell than He did Heaven; because, He didn't want anyone to go there)! I love God's chosen people--Israel; I wish they all could be saved, but they won't because of their stiff-necked, hard-headed pride. It's sad. They have no idea what's coming; the Time-of-Jacob's-Trouble. Repent-repent-repent!!! God bless, Israel and His Jerusalem (Jesus will sit on the thrown of King David)!
43. G-d is real and beyond all our imagination can picture
Gila ,   Beit Shemesh, Israel   (05.28.12)
Actually I was personally privileged that G-d revealed something of his infinite presence to me some years ago in an amazing visionary experience at the Kotel. I was deeply traumatized by it, even though it was truly wonderful beyond words (and by the way I was stone cold sober at the time) and have never really got over it. As a result I am always aware of being in His presence: sometimes that is not easy. No, I am not crazy. Actually not only am I of sound mind but I am an academic with a doctorate and a strong logical way of thinking. Yes, I did already believe in G-d and I was truly seeking His will for my life and had been through a lot of suffering before that. And I had reached a point where I truly needed to know 100% what He wanted from me and no longer had the emotional strength to continue with what was for me a huge spiritual dilemma. But no way could I ever have begun to imagine the sheer immensity, way beyond words, of what happened to me that particular night. My mind was simply unable to take in such huge immensity. Which actually was the point that G-d was making to me. Actually, if you bother to read the Torah, how can you NOT believe in G-d? For instance, one of the laws He gave the Jewish people was that of shmittah, letting the land lie fallow for one year out of seven. G-d promises that He will provide enough food for the Jews the previous year to last them through the year of shmittah and the year after, before the new crops are ready. Can you seriously imagine a human being creating such a ridiculous commandment?! Not in a million years! And if humans had really invented the mass revelation at Sinai, do you really think that the Jewish people would have been fooled?!: they were there and passed on their memories to their descendants. Had it not happened the way it was recorded in the Torah, there would have been far too many witnesses and their descendants to have pointed that out. You can not believe in G-d all you like, but that doesn't mean He doesn't exist. As I'm sure we'll all find out once our present physical lives are over....
44. God reveals himself all the time
Stephan ,   Munich, Germany   (05.27.12)
and the whole history can be seen as a revelation. The Jewish Prophets, especially Jesaja, have predicted the whole history until today. Jews have been selected by God for showing how he shapes history and future. Jahwe is master of history, not man and the books of the Prophets are the clear proof. Who else could predict history? Humans will realize that and all will come to faith in God. Everything has come true so far and in the end, the Lord will return to the Zion. Right now, we are close to the great historic change of human's destiny. It has already started. All signs are visible now in the world (increase of criminality, criminal leaders, amassing natural catastrophies, dictators were falling, diseases, science is telling fairytales and humans believe it while the truth is being denied.....) Then, Israel will be new founded and the Temple will be rebuild. The Ark of the Covenant will be found again (it is in the Zion) and there will be peace all around the world. It will rain justice and all conflicts will resolve. The sin will disappear from the world, humans will make their paths straight again since everybody will come to faith. We all will witness that coming, the great change is near.
45. @14: I hope so
Walter ,   Germany   (05.28.12)
All the rock stars and hot babes must be there. I always wanted to see Jim Morrison live and in color. BTW do you think I'm also able to see Marilyn Monroe? She looked like an angel but was hot as hell.
46. @18
Walter ,   Germany   (05.28.12)
I recommend you the books of Stephen Hawking. He has proofed that there is no god necessary. Of course he was not able to proof that there is no god. But he also has no proof that there are no pink unicorns...
47. @41
Walter ,   Germany   (05.28.12)
Let's assume there is a god. Why should I worship him? He is almighty. He doesn't need me. He would be a very childish god if he would care. So if he would exist he would judge me by my behaviour on other people. I can't imagine a deity which welcomes Gandhi with the words: "You did not worship me - so go to hell!" If this would be the case god would be evil and should not be worshipped. But I can't find any evidence of god.
48. After reading the talkbacks of the readers...
Sebastian Kozuch ,   Jerusalem   (05.28.12)
After reading the talkbacks of the readers, I think I have an idea of what happens. For some, I have to believe that there was a revelation in Sinai. For others, I have to believe there was a Messiah born in Bethlehem. For others, I have to believe the biggest prophet came from Mecca. For all of them, if I don't believe in what they say I will go to hell, or something equivalent to their religion. And if I believe on what the others say, I will also go to hell (or equivalent). So most of the world is indeed going to hell, as most of the world does not share their beliefs. Please, bring me proofs of which religion is right or I will not believe in your "revelations". Meanwhile I'll stick to "no religion", since the chances are that I'm going to "hell" anyway, no matter which religion I choose.
49. He's in Argentina with his buddies
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (05.28.12)
... or so said the button (badge to you UK people) that was popular in the USA in the 60s.
50. To #48! Ignorance is bliss!
Taz Man ,   USA   (05.28.12)
Playing Russian roulette with your eternal soul is not wise...it's stupid! Putting your head in the sand won't change the fact that there is a literal Hell and judgment of God. As Christ stated: He is the way, the life, and the truth, and no one gets to the Father but by Him. Also, the bible (New Testament) states: there is no other name under Heaven, whereby one can be saved. Yes, Christianity (Christ) is the only way to Heaven; and yes, unless many repent, they will be going to Hell! I'd suggest (I pray) that all the Israelis' find a Jewish missionary in Israel and let them, through the scriptures (OT & NT), show them how they can be saved. Please, listen...because, the time is short; the "Time of Jacob's Trouble" is almost upon the house of Israel. God bless, Israel and His Jerusalem! A Christian Zionist
51. To #50, Taz Man,
Sebastian ,   Jerusalem   (05.28.12)
You don't get it. Most of the world think that your religion is not the truth. According to you, they are all going to hell. But according to most of the world, YOU are going to hell for not following their beliefs. YOU are playing Russian roulette with your soul. So why should I hear your warning and not theirs? It seems that choosing the right religion is like winning the lottery.
52. God does exist
Don ,   Indy USA   (05.28.12)
One day God says every knee will bow and every tongue confess. And that includes you David. You are a sorry lost soul like so many others.
53. Religious folk
Sagi   (05.28.12)
have no plausible explanation for the existence of a god, no evidence and of course there never will be any evidence. That he "revealed" himself once on Mt.Sinai is of course fairy tales, so there is nothing left for these folk to do but to concoct idiotic theses like the above writer in order to justify their stupidity.
54. Reveal
mark ,   Canada   (05.28.12)
Rabbi Levi, Are you telling us that we must open a barbecue stand at the foot of mount Sinai so go will reveal himself again? Where are we going to find the customers in that desert?Why don't you go first and we'll follow you.
55. To #51 & #53!
Taz Man ,   USA   (05.28.12)
Christianity is the only way to eternal life! It is very exclusive, and yet, all-inclusive for those willing to be saved by the blood of Christ shed for all lost souls. You both will bow before Christ as your Savior or as your Judge (you will remember my warning at that moment of truth--guaranteed)! Remember the Taz Man: he tried to warn you both! May God open your eyes; be careful of your foolish pride, because the great fall follows those who mock God and His Son--Jesus Christ.
56. a weak article which poorly explains
pinchas ,   boston   (05.29.12)
the ritural of animal sacrifice with but one reference (Hirsch). However, the talkbacks-- from ardent atheists Sagi and Tom especially-- are typically arrogant, know-it-all Israeli b.s. Atogether, an inappropriate discussion for ynet--- better for arutzsheva even jpost.
57. Reveal?
Leif Erik H.Niclasen ,   Faroe IIsland   (05.29.12)
He will in time, are you ready to meet him?
58. the truth, deal with it
Steve   (05.29.12)
God is not any of man's concern. The creator is beyond our comprehension. Rather than consume ourselves with idiotic and counterproductive hypothesis regarding god's will, we should be utilizing our intelligence to improve life on our planet for all it's inhabitents. A kindly deed directed towards a stranger is better than every holy book ever foisted upon an innocent child.
59. Followers of the imaginary friend
Haim ,   TA   (05.29.12)
followers/believers of the Imaginary Friend. They should have their full freedom to practice chicken-twirling and genital "adjustment" policy in their leisure time! I have no desire to interact in any pseudo-intellectual "dialogue" with these neurologically challenged individuals. The idea of "Holiness" is a con-man's invention meant to subdue any sane & sound revulsion one might feel towards primitive and obvious manipulation that the "Holy" MEN of various religions exert towards blind & dumb and unwashed masses. You can turn and twist it any way you wish, the result will always be : HUMBUG!!!!
60. Sacrificing animals iss horrible?
Reuven   (05.29.12)
Who is the author to write such drivel?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article