News
Palestinian shot in clash with settlers
Omri Efraim
Published: 26.05.12, 18:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. 4 - Hasbara crap and step dancing ,...
split ,   US   (05.27.12)
They're unwelcomed settlers living on stolen land, period,...
32. #27 You are obviously not medically trained.
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (05.27.12)
I work as an emergency department doctor in our local district general hospital and I am an Advanced Trauma Life Support provider. During my 7 years of work in Palestinian hospitals in Beirut and Gaza I had extensive experience with abdominal injuries of all kind, wheter blunt or sharp trauma, bullit, shrapnel or blast injury. You cannot see bruising, but the limited information that the photograph allows shows discoloration to the right side of the umbilicus consistent with bruising. The history, namely that the young man was handcuffed and then kicked by Jewish colonists, is relevant here. You claim you are an attorney. I would like to see your qualifications. I have given you mine, i.e. my General Medical Council registration number in the UK, which is 4427928 and can be checked online. Give us proof of what you claim to be, namely a lawyer. I have my doubts. You are more like a paid propagandists with very little knowledge other than the usual Zionist propaganda. Oh, yes and you can speak of word of German too!
33. To: No. 32
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.27.12)
You're a nurse. You are also probably a paid propagandist for all manner of terrorist scum. Your job in Gaza was to train nurses. Don't you feel ashamed to have participated in promoting the well-being of terrorists? No doctor who has taken an oath would do that. Terrorists take lives; they forfeit their own. By saving the life of a terrorist, how many lives have you taken? Shouldn't that keep you awake at night? Obviously, it does not. That makes YOU a psychopath. I still do not see handcuffs, blood or bandages in the photograph. I do not see distension or discoloring. I see a terrorist lying on a stretcher, playing to the cameras. Do you remember the incident of the ersatz "Palestinian" girls who came down with a mysterious "illness" some years ago in the West Bank? When the cameras were trained on them, they wept, clutched their bellies, moaned and screamed. As soon as the cameras were turned off, they sat up, giggled, laughed, and seemed to have had a miraculous recovery. As soon as the cameras were turned back on, their "affliction" miraculously returned. Thanks to one enterprising American photojournalist, he filmed the girls surreptitiously, and the ruse was exposed to the world. You'll have to take my word about my professional qualifications. Or not; your choice.
34. To: No. 31
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.27.12)
Ever stop to wonder how native Americans feel about you?
35. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.27.12)
Oh, please. The ersatz "Palestinians" have been caught red-handed destroying their own olive groves, vandalizing their own mosques and defacing their own graves on any number of occasions. Secondly, this poor actor's navel is located EXACTLY where it is supposed to be. But I agree that the violence has reached an intolerable level. Israel has no choice but to fully and formally annex Judea and Samaria, and repatriate the illegal Arab squatters to Jordan, country of their citizenship. Seven decades of unremiting ersatz "Palestinian" violence and terror has been far too much.
36. #33 You are blinded by hate, denial and prejudice....
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (05.28.12)
You can only think about Palestinians in crazy caricatures, that have no relation to reality. You refuse to face the reality on the ground in the Occupied Territories. Your petty denial is such that you refuse to acknowledge my qualifications. You claim you are trained in the legal profession, but for that you need a measure of intelligence and basic manners, which you singularly lack. You refuse to show us your qualifications, and I know why. Because you are con woman, a fraud. You talk about "Ersatz" Palestinians. This is all projection. The surrogate wannabe lawyer is you.
37. Neighbors not respecting neighbors
Ezra ,   sandiego   (05.28.12)
I saw the video of the altercation. I saw the shot that hit Najah al-Safadi, and he was one of the stone-throwing adolescents instigating the trouble. I don't agree with shooting at kids, but they did present the appearance of gang members on the offensive. Why were the locals burning fires on Shabbat? Why aren't the locals more respectful of the Jews who live in the area? They act like out-of-control neighbors.
38. For anyone interested in what really happened
rachel   (05.28.12)
Instead of just more antiIsraeli propaganda. Read Arutz Sheva,they have video of the Arabs setting the fire, as well as the knife right next to the wounded Arab.
39. To: No. 36
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.29.12)
So, you haven't answered my question. How do you feel about saving the life of an ersatz "Palestinian" terrorist whose sworn duty it is to murder Jews? Does it make you feel good? Job well done? You are a monster. I don't know why you have singularly adopted the cause of terrorist murderers, and I don't much care why. I suspect that is why your credentials have been pulled, nursie boy, and you are no longer considered a physician in Great Britain. Yes, I checked. Not just on the Internet, either. You've lost your medical credentials. I'm the real deal, nursie boy. A credentialed lawyer. You, on the other hand, are a discredited disgrace. Care to explain that, or will you tuck your mangy tail underneath your discredentialed hindquarters and slink away, like the craven jackal you are?
40. #35
I Love Fanatics ,   Ohio, USA   (05.29.12)
In your response you stated, “Israel has no choice but to fully and formally annex Judea and Samaria, and repatriate the illegal Arab squatters to Jordan, country of their citizenship First, I’m sure you understand that the international community would never recognize this annexation. EVER! Not even the USA. Thus, an annexation would render Israel as the only country in the world with unrecognized borders - basically forever. As for your suggestion for repatriating the Arabs to Jordan, may I suggest that you do not use cattle cars – as it would really be in bad taste. P.S. - Still waiting for my previous response regarding #32 & #36 be to be OK’d
41. #33 & #39
I Love Fanatics ,   Ohio, USA   (05.29.12)
I found your quote to #32 regarding the fact that he was a doctor who work in Gaza absolutely stunning – You said: “Don't you feel ashamed to have participated in promoting the well-being of terrorists? No doctor who has taken an oath would do that.” Have you ever read the Hippocratic oath? In short, it states that a doctor “should do no harm” – a doctor’s mission is to apply the best medical service available - period – the doctor is not allowed to be judge and jury. Indeed, any denial of medical service would be considered intentionally doing harm. I believed your husband is a doctor. Does he subscribe to this philosophy? Does he render a moral decision on his patient before he performs his surgery? Does he adjust the quality of his work based on this decision? Does he ever deny his services to people he finds unworthy?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article