Opinion  Amnon Abramovich
Is IDF a hollow army?
Amnon Abramovich
Published: 31.05.12, 11:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. #13 # 20 Nonsense
Ohad ,   Israel/UK   (06.01.12)
You think the armies of the UK and India are among the best? IDF is better and more battle experienced than the armies of UK and India will ever be.Ironically, in contrast to popular anti-Israel feelings in the UK, the British military has a lot of respect for the IDF.
32. # 30 Simple
Stan ,   Israel   (06.01.12)
Start taking the negative results of 45 years of occupation seriously. 1. Anti Semitism is on the increase in many parts of the world 2. We see the first signs of boycotts against Israel. TIME IS NOT ON OUR SIDE. THE STATUS QUO IS LIKE A CANCER TO ISRAEL We must drag the Pals to the negotiation table and reach a solution giving the Pals a state alongside Israel. IF WE DO NOT DO THIS, ISRAEL WILL BE BOYCOTTED OUT OF EXISTANCEWITHIN 40 YEARS. (Israel is not an Apartheid state, but there are many other parallels with the SA that collapsed in 1990. ) 3. Start preparing the 100,000 or so settlers for the fact that Israel is going to withdraw from most of Yosh. (As said by Gilead Sher last night on Channel 10)
33. When a great officer like Lt. Col Eisner
Reu8ven   (06.01.12)
is punished, just to please foreign countries, that'sa demoralizing to the IDF. To bwe sure we win, we need more officers like him.
34. To Ohad, No 31
Allan ,   London, England   (06.01.12)
Did i say that? NO i did not.. Dont put words in my mouth..! And by the way, the UK has more combat experience, Iraq, Afghanistan etc.. and India has one of the worlds biggest armies and has had many wars with Pakistan.. But you knew that right??? And by the way.. doing checkpoints does not make you among the best...
35. #31 Ohad
kenny ,   new delhi, india   (06.02.12)
Well Ohad, we never claim to be the best. However, the track record of the British Army is impeccable and the Indian Army has fought against Pakistan and China, foes anytime more competent then syria, egypt or the unarmed women and children of the occupied territories. So, don't live in a dream world.
36. Army reflects society.
Jason ,   Australia   (06.02.12)
An army is a reflection of its society. The soldiers in the field reflect the values and attributes of its youth. So too do the commanders and political leadership reflect the attitudes of society. I feel Israel relies excessively on technology and is infected with an arrogance that affects its entire society. I'm not sure there is sufficient attachment to values of sacrifice and stoicism that are essential to a successful army within a successful society. I hope that if the day comes, I am proved wrong.
37. to Jason Australia
sewarmas ,   jerusalem   (06.02.12)
my mother used to say -- tha palm can not figt the needle directly --- it is not tech, nor sacrifice it is to think before the acte ....i think my mother was right and no days come to be wrong
38. #34 & 35 Reality check
Ohad ,   Israel/UK   (06.02.12)
#34 We both know that IDF does far more than checkpoints which is a necessary evil when your neighbors want you dead.IDF has far more experience since WW2 than any other army in the world including those of the US and UK. Only a tiny part of UK:s forces have been to Afghanistan and Iraq and both the US and the UK made many mistakes their. #35 IDF:s track record is second to none and IDF:s foes have also included Russia and today Iran. IDF has done far more to avoid civilian casualties than the US, UK, something that for example UK commanding officer in Afghanistan Col. Richard Kemp openly admitted. The British have slaughtered millions of innocent civilians around the world in the name of their empire so I don't give much for British "civilization".
39. reality
pm ,   india   (06.02.12)
who said indian army is best.It lost victory to china and to pak in cargil war instead of false propaganda other way.only bcs u.s.a behind the screen diplomacy india escaped that humiliation.also india is a shameless dependent on other advanced countries for her defence need .aft russia israel is the defence supplier of india.idf has very dominant experience in covert operations on a daily basis and aferocious fighting experience inherited from her inception as a nation.indians have a problem of self congratulation and exaggeration. Mere manpower and obsolete tecnology doesn't give u an edge over other.
40. Allan, London
Tal ,   brooklyn, USA   (06.02.12)
If you are niece enough o think that we are not operating in afghanistan and iraq then enjoy the thought.... Who do you think showed the americans and UK where to go and what to do? Do you really think we are not running black ops all over the place?
41. To N 17, Israel Israeli
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (06.03.12)
Dear brother. As a friend of your country and of your people, I think you have to be united, above political parties and ideologies. Like you wrote sometime ago, I honor Israel as a whole, without exceptions. Hence, I don't understand your so aggressive words about the refered Israeli Leftist leaders. Ben Gurion, Golda Meir, Abba Eban, Mosche Dayan, Yigal Allon, Itzhaack Rabin and Shimon Peres were, or have been, Social Democrats. I am sure you don't call them traitors. Israel needs to be ever strong, without dangerous divisions. Warm Salutes.
42. IS IT TRUE ?
Matk ,   T.a. Israel   (06.03.12)
THIS ARTICLE IS FROM A PERSON WHO IS NOT MILITARY AND UNFIT TO MAKE SUCH EVALUATION ! CLEARLY THIS IS A DEFAITIST ARTICLE TO SOW THE PANIC AMONG THE POPULATION ! OUR MILITARY CHIEFS HAVE ALREADY TAKEN LESSONS FROM THE TWO LEBANESE WARS ! DO NOT WORRY !
43. We need more high officers like
Reuven   (06.03.12)
Lt. Col. Eisner..a dedicated soldier who knows how to complete a mission.
44. Is Idf a hollow army?
Floriane ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
Completely out of line! Did you serve in the army yourself? You need to support our army that risks its life every day for our Survival and Our Soldiers can be Abducted any time!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article