Jewish Scene
Research unearths Jewish roots in Colorado Indians
Ynetnews
Published: 01.06.12, 15:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
31. No They are both from Turkic descent
Tayfun_Turkey   (06.02.12)
European jews are mostly from Turkic Hazar State which was converted judaism despite they could not because they were not real israili. After a while racial ancestry lost from memories. In fact most of Askenasi jews are Turkic origin. Only Sapharati jews are real jews. So what you find in common with Indians are in fact your turkic genes which is also case for indians who migrated from asia during Chengiz khans times!
32. more jews?
michael ,   usa   (06.02.12)
It is a relief that they are not jews. there are enough problem as it is, now days, with groups of people from around the world, mainly poor, who want to use the country's achivements to improve their lives.
33. Nr 20. You err -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (06.02.12)
Salomos Fleet went from Esiongeber in the Neighbourhood of Jordania and Northwest Arabia, to the land of Ophir for Gold. The land of Ophir was according to another tradition anexed by the King in Saba/Yemen, and was likely situated i Africa. Further - The Zuni Indians of Virginia and New Mexico speak fluent Hebrew. The Ten Commandments are carved on stones in New Mexico Comment - so when did this take palce, ?, under Salomos Rule ?, You err terrible. Arn.Sweden.
34. #31 you are wrong.
Ben Ze'ev ,   Panama City Panama   (06.03.12)
The ashkeni Jews have no more than 7% Turkic or Khazar genes. This was revealed several years ago. As for American indian jews speaking hebrew or yiddish this must be a joke. I can laugh at a joke.
35. Nr 31 and 34.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (06.03.12)
I dont know of any other German/Gotic/Askenasim, as oming from any other place than Kaukasus to Northern Europe. The Slavs/Tocharians/Sarmatians, comes from Bulun Tokai, in Northwest Sinkiang in China, and could have Mixed with som etnic Turks in that Region. Likewise the Hiung.-Nu, The Hungarians, a People of Turkic descent, comes from a Region, betwen Bulun Tokai and, Kasgar in Western China/Kasmir/Afhganistan/(T)askent , Peoples of German/Gotic/Askenasi emigration, from Kaska/Georgia in Kaukasus, in the 3rd Millenia B.C. Even those Hungarians Could have Mixed with those Askenasim to some extent. So - Only the Noth-Americas Indians is of Turkish Blood as such. and not the Askenasim. Arn.sweden.
36. MISLEADING DNA STORY & STUDY
Schelly Dardashti ,   New Mexico, US   (06.04.12)
BRCA1 and BRCA2 are NOT Ashkenazi. They are simply Jewish and date from before the split into Ashkenazi and Sephardic communities. They are found among Hispanics, Sephardim and Ashkenazim. Many Hispanics descend from Conversos, forced to convert to Catholicism during the Inquisition. This has been known for a very long time. MISLEADING ARTICLE AND STUDY. Neither the reporter nor the researchers seem to know anything about the history of the American Southwest, particularly New Mexico and Colorado, dating from 1598.
37. No. 15 is incorrect...
Aaron ,   Trenton, NJ   (10.08.12)
The closest genetic linkage between a middle eastern group and modern Jews is the Kurds. In other words, Jews are quite likely either a very distant offshoot or ethnic relatives of the Kurds. While there are genetic linkages among Palestinians, the group they most resemble genetically are peninsular Arabs with strong links to other middle eastern groups as well, such as Jews.
38. indian jew
GCU ,   Paris France   (10.09.12)
My name is Geronimo Cohen ;)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article