Jewish Scene
US Conservative Jews approve gay weddings
Associated Press
Published: 02.06.12, 08:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
1. If the US Conservative Jews approved it...
Anand ,   Delhi   (06.02.12)
would the pigs become kosher?
2. American Jewish life is all about feeling good and pretendin
Al   (06.02.12)
all is good. Its like a Seinfeld episode...all about nothing. Can I have a shmear with a bagel Ahmed?
3. בשנה הבא בירושלים!!
david ,   Jerusalem   (06.02.12)
4. Gays and "marriage"
Stan ,   Sydney, Australia   (06.02.12)
There is no such thing as an "orthodox Jewish movement" . However, there is the traditional Jewish religion and not Jewish - lite
5. Beauty in Judaism
Moshe ,   Jerusalem   (06.02.12)
Wonderful news!! Love to see that the beauty in Judaism is being welcomed in the US. Hopefully it will influence the religious intolerance here in Israel. Kol HaKavod!
6. TWISTING AND IGNORING TORAH
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
These " Conservatives jews-in-name-only " like to distort the Torah to suit their own views but the Torah ,which is after all the foundation of judaism and jewish values ,is clearly anti -homosexual and nothing can alter that fact.
7. MAKING A MOCKERY OF MARRIAGE
DA RAP ARTIST ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
These US conservative folk are making a joke out of marriage .It was Adam and Eve ,not Adam and Steve.
8. #1 and #2 VERY GOOD
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
I am tired of this pandering to gays and strays.
9. THE NEXT STEP
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
The next step ,or logical continuation of this trend ,will be that men and woman heterosexual relationships and marriages will be deemed to be " perverse and unnatural " .....my oh my ,how things have changed.
10. #2 SO TRUE
DA URBAN POET ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
Being jewish for these american folk is just about doing what feels good .A.K.A. Sex ,Drugs and Rock n' roll . Torah has no place in this scheme of things or has to be bent to shape in order to fit in with their "feel good " mentality/ viewpoint.
11. AN HONEST QUESTION :
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (06.02.12)
Why can't these gay folk just be content with co-habiting ( living together ) or just enjoying each others' company ? why do they need to be " married " like heterosexual folk ?
12. WHAT YOU CAN'T DO (CHOICES )
ALBERT EINSTEIN ,   SAFED LOONY-BIN   (06.02.12)
You can live your life as a jew ,or you can live a selfish and hedonistic lifestyle but you can not do both.
13. This is sad news
Michal   (06.02.12)
14. Death knell for Liberal Movements
LiberalJudaismDemise ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.02.12)
I truely believe ( as a secular Jew) that this will be fhe final deathknell for the liberal movements many more will now leave these movements either for more traditional synagogue movements or leave Judaism altogether not that they are homophobic but that they see this as an unhealthly lifetstyle to be promoted to their offspring. Already you can find huge white elephant Temple buildings empty on Friday and Shabbat mornings.They survive only because of their huge endowments they have almost ceased to be "living" entities.
15. All 3 denominations have equal numbers
MisleadingFigures ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.02.12)
Your figures re Conservatives being the second largest group may be true give a few thousand only members but most statistians now but them all neck to neck 1.2 million each Reform Conservative Orthodox separated only by a few thousands..The real difference however is that in the Orthodox communities 85% are active members where only 4% of Reform are and only 6% of Conservative are .The liberal branches do have large impressive buildings but they are basically empty white elephants and their movements survive only because of huge endowments but they are basically dead entities with little future so many have left for more traditional venues or assimilated.
16. mazel tov
twice blessed   (06.02.12)
17. Nothing against people living their life ,but
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (06.02.12)
what has this mess to do with our religion ?
18. Interesting
Magpie 101   (06.02.12)
Will Israel now sanction same sex marriage in Israel or risk splitting world jewry and claims that Israel no longer speaks for all Jews?
19. stop portraying God as a vengeful hater
geshmardo ,   Montevideo, Uruguay   (06.02.12)
a general message to all of you religious zealots (Jews, Christians and Islamic alike): stop blabbering in the name of God. It really sounds pathetic. And remember: if there's a God, he's nothing like the vengeful hater you're trying to portray. Stop quoting the Torah, or else we should also stone adulterer women to death and so on. And welcome to the 21st century. PS: my take is many of you who fear the gay are closeted gays who fear your own nature. You better assume your own nature, then, and leave your women to true heterosexuals like me.
20. congrats to Jews worldwide...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.02.12)
21. Another sign that America is going down like the Titanic...
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (06.02.12)
and the poor slobs don't even realize it. Oh well, the world and Israel will be all the better without it's corroding influence.
22. insanity
AaronA ,   Rayville,LA,USA   (06.02.12)
SODOM AND GOMORRAH! Anybody else remember this story.. If the rabbis cant make a stand against this behavior who will? I for one will never accept such behavior and pray that soon all will be corrected!
23. Have To Agree With Anand #1 In India, But
David H ,   Marietta, GA   (06.02.12)
We American Jews also have a saying that pork in a Chinese restaurant is kosher. I think that says a lot...God bless the feygelehs, their getting "married" has no effect on me or mine. Mostly harmless.
24. Conservative Movement comes around
praisethelorne ,   NYC, NY   (06.02.12)
With a vote of 13-0 I wonder what took them so long. To those who believe in a literal interpretation of the Torah, remember, this is the Conservative movement, not the Southern Baptist Movement. If Orthodox Jews believed in a literal translation then cheeseburgers would be Kosher.
25. And that does not include this Jew !
Moshe ,   Usa   (06.02.12)
And never will !
26. Thanks for the Anti-Semitism!
Eli ,   USA   (06.02.12)
G-d forbids homosexuality Lev 18:22...Does Sodom & Gomorrah ring a bell? What amazes me is that this sect of Jews tries an 'end-run' deliberately v. the Torah and accept homosexuality yet they do not recognize Messianic Jews! Oh yeah, thanks for the new wave of anti-semitism from this brilliant act!
27. Non-Jewish Jews have existed since the Reform
Aurora Aronsson ,   Malmö, SE   (06.02.12)
most of their kids assimilate (ALL of Moses Mendelsohn's grandchildren were Catholics) and disappear from the Jewish People... ONLY OBSERVANT JEWS (so-called Orthodox. which is a term that doesn't make sense in Judaism) have been constantly growing in the US...from about 4% to about 25%...while the total Jewish population has remained the same 5 Mil. instead of growing since 1945.... Which means from 12 to 18 Mil. disappeared in the SHOAH of assimilation favored by the Refor-vatvives, as pointed out by Rabbi Mordechai Eliahu...
28. A letter to USCJ rabbis
The Prophetess ,   SC, USA   (06.02.12)
I was brought up assimilated reform; and later in Life, I moved "right" and joined the Conservative movement, truly believing that "Conservative" meant holding more dear, the tenets of our Bible. The rabbis of the USCJ have turned the sanctity of marriage into a hollow joke.
29. US Jews approve assimilation....
ber ,   yahud   (06.02.12)
and that arrogant anti-Semite Obama, who constantly touts himself as the best friends the Jews ever had. The US Jews for their part created the civil rights movement through Hollywood productions with the lovable black characters(like blazing saddles), and the notion that there could even be a black secretary at the White House, let alone commander and chief. Stab in the back, well in all fairness, it was a dark moment in US history when we made the world economy collapse in the middle of the 2008 presidential race. Geez...economic collapse and a mendacious charlatan and demagogue made leader of a powerful western nation, when he would have been unsuitable at ANY other moment in history...hhhhmmm when has that happened before....
30. I guess this means
Salim ,   Canada   (06.02.12)
that non-Orthodox Jews will eventually become extinct. Unfortunately we can't afford to lose even more of our numbers to an even lower birthrate.
Next talkbacks
Back to article