News
PM presents Ulpana eviction plan
Itamar Fleishman
Published: 03.06.12, 11:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Impossible to vote Likud any more!
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (06.03.12)
Mr. Feiglin wake up and get out of Likud! Mr. Orlev you are no leader. Mr. Eli Yshay, will you defend Bet-El even if it costs you your Audi?
2. Thousands of Jews are still homeless & jobless from Sharon's
Chaim ,   Migron   (06.03.12)
expulsion and foolish Barak and Bibi are following his dangerous footsteps.
3. What's that???
Keren ,   IL-BR   (06.03.12)
Have Bibi and "high court"pocket already the milions of US dollars that were recently given to them for their "aid"and they can not go back in their "international agreements"now?Is that it? BIBI IS AN IDIOT and should be thrown out of office NOW,before he imposes another Gush Katif to Israel and before he gives all Israel to Arabs,as he has already started by Hebron. This idiot knows how to cheat very well!! Wake up!
4. Bibi showing he is a true leader !
RH ,   Modiin Isral   (06.03.12)
A courageous and correct decision. The people of Ulpana are damaging Israel they are lucky to receive restitution. They knew what the story was when they moved in now they must pay the price for taking those risks Well done Bibi
5. Who are you, Chaim?
Aviela ,   Migron, Israel   (06.03.12)
Because I live in Migron and there's no Chaim here that speaks English. I don't disagree with what you're saying, but be honest.
6. BS
joe sombrero ,   usa   (06.03.12)
Why would bibi need to ask permission from the AG to build homes in Beth El? First Israel has a right under International Law to do it and second no law has been broken.
7. here we go (again)!
Jerusalemite ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
8. #5 why do you care?
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (06.03.12)
Chaim may or may not be from Migron, may or may not speak English and may or may not be called Chaim. What matters is what he writes. This is no different from #4 Mahmoud from Na'alin who pretends to be RH from Modiin.
9. A solution King Solomon would approve of
Robert ,   USA   (06.03.12)
10. 5 Aviela the sherif is in town !
Yehudit ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
11. Stop to the destruction of jewish homes by leftists
(06.03.12)
12. Bibi wants war while the Arabs weak now
N ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
The evacuation will follow by war.
13. Plenty of guilt to go around...
David ,   Israel, Israel   (06.03.12)
Between the Housing Ministry and the religious fanatics there is plenty of blame to go around. They both knew they didn't have any of the required building permits and they all knew that there wasn't any approved Master Plan for Ulpana. Many, if not all, also knew that the land was owned by Arabs but they couldn't let a little fact like that stand in their way...they've got God's work to do. Why do you think they are so desperate to live in the West Bank after all??? For people who hate Arabs so much they sure will go out of their way to try and live right in the middle of them. Only one possible explanation for that and it is religious fanaticism. They know what God wants and He just can't seem to get it done without their help. So, since we know we are right and the stupid Arabs are always wrong, it's okay to lie and steal a little bit if it makes God happy! The, tired, lame excuse that since the Housing Ministry (headed by religious zealot Atias - shock, shock) was involved with the infrastructure financing at Ulpana, that everything was ok and that the government sanctioned the building at Ulpana. This line of reasoning completely ignores the fact that the same type of criminals are operating in the government as well. Look people. There are two groups of people and two cultures living here. Get used to it because it ain't going to change. When you are dead and buried the Arabs will still be living here. Any questions? They can live in their half (sometimes called the West Bank) and we can easily live inside the green line. If we have to protect ourselves against their radical elements then by all means we will defend our citizens as necessary. But, in the meantime, just be smart and get the hell out of the West Bank. Netanyahu threatening to build 10 more for each house removed is merely red meat to keep the right wingers in the coalition. Either that or he is a nut himself. It's really not all that complicated. It only becomes complicated with greed or religious zealotry.
14. Netanyahu,More Twists and Turns Than A Ballerina
A Very heavy Stone ,   Florida   (06.03.12)
He's playing games with this stupid plan to move the homes. The poodle Netanyahu has to deliver more destroyed Jewish homes to his master in Washington and if he can deliver some Jewish 'settler' blood to Mr. Hussein Obama that will just be a bonus. Washington,the EU,UN love Jewish homes turned to rubble and that delivers many positive points to any Isralei Prime Minister. The prissy poodle wants so much to be loved and accepted by his master that he will do anything,no amount of treachery is beyond him and his Pogrom Minister Ehud Barak. The useless idiots of Likud have given the fraud Netahyahu a pass every time he screwed them and this has only emboldened him to serve his god in Washington with more destruction of Jewish homes. They love their Bibi when he delivers the rubble. The devious, pompous and arrogant puppet of the globalists has played the left, right game so well that he knows no matter what he does the useless ones will keep licking his boots.
15. Because Israelis do not stick together
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.03.12)
do not have compassion,Bibi can allow himself to be so cruel.
16. #13 Excellent post, David !
Eugene ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
17. One angry Jew
jan ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (06.03.12)
Everytime any idiot in the government starts to talk about giving away one inch of our country I get so angry, upset I scream to the heavens. The futility of it all. With nothing but sworn enemies around us what is the point!!! Plus I still have friends suffering from being thrown out of their beautiful world in Gush Katif how many years ago? This cannot be an answer for our problems.
18. #13. Judea & Samaria belong to Israel. We're staying forever
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
#13 David. I suggest your learn to read a map. If you do, you'll quickly discover that Judea and Samaria not only legally belong to Israel. They make Israel viable. If Israelis were ever dumb enough to follow your lunatic suggestions, and abandon our heartland, Israel would be finished within a decade. Countless world leading legal authorities, including Eugene Rostow, author of U.N. Resolution 242, have proven incontrovertibly this land is ours. We're staying in Judea and Samaria forever. Arabs are already leaving by the thousand annually and this wonderful trend will only accelerate.
19. Likud must dump Bibi.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
Bibi has a long history of betraying the huge patriotic majority of Israel. So this latest abomination is no surprise. Nor can it be said that Bibi wins elections. He literally threw away the last two elections. Likud must dump Bibi and get a leader who abides by the Likud Constitution.Likud's Constitution endorses Jewish sovereignty over all of Judea and Samaria So do the vast majority of Israelis. Bibi will destroy the party if he is allowed to remain as leader.
20. 13 David I do not trust the veracity
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.03.12)
of hateful statements.
21. Law
Ze'ev ,   Nbg, germany   (06.03.12)
in a democracy the law rules, that's it. Even when we dont like it, but the base of democracy is abiding the law. All other ways lead to anarchy.
22. David #13: Religious zealotry?
Steve   (06.03.12)
What about secular zealotry? You are complaining about Israel's 'conquest' of the so-called West Bank which is actually Israel's by right, both international and (yes) divine. Their radical "elements?" What percentage of these peoples -- what element -- supports suicide bombings (martyrdom operations) on innocent Jews? What element does not recognize or accept a Jewish state within any borders? Speaking of conquest, have you studied European conquest of North America? Whose god took all these lands from the natives, giving them over to these non-indigenous peoples?
23. 17 May G-D hear you, Jan.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.03.12)
24. David - 13
Aviela Deitch ,   Migron, Israel   (06.03.12)
You're saying that if there had been an approved master plan for the Ulpana neighborhood of Beit El, then everything would be okay? Because Migron has an approved master plan, put out by the ministry of housing, for 500 housing units on this hill. Doesn't seem to be helping us much.
25. #16 Eugene
DavidR ,   USA   (06.03.12)
One more ignorant lefty heard from.
26. #8, Why Do You Not Care?
Brana Lobel ,   Israel   (06.03.12)
Just because the Internet has trolls, does not mean that they should proliferate on Ynet. If this is not a forum for reasonable people who live in Israel, then what is it? Is it just the equivalent of a bathroom where people from wherever scrawl graffiti on the walls? It certainly makes a difference when someone misrepresents himself as being from Yesha and having an opinion emanating from Yesha. If this person is a Jew and he is no better than his lying enemies, what is he and where are we? That being said, Netanyahu has no place wanting to move Israeli homes around like a Potemkin village. It is spineless and clueless and actually counterproductive.
27. Houses only being moved and more souses being added in terri
Golda ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.08.12)
Calm down, Keren. Maybe you didnt notice that the homes are only being moved several hundred yards away and 10 houses will be built for every house moved. This only strengthens the settlers and Bibi isnt giving away Hebron
Back to article