News  World News
UK: Queen's Jubilee fest tainted by Nazi symbols
Ynet
Published: 06.06.12, 22:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. Total morons, but what a bizarre hobby. I dont think they
David ,   Tel Aviv   (06.06.12)
were anti semites, they just took their re-enactments way too far.
2. All Ynet could find on this fantastic weekend, was this?!
Shmuel..   (06.06.12)
Israelis and Jews were outside Buckingham palace waving flags too, it was a great party. Sadly, the talkbackers here don't see that.
3. Thats it Ynet, help keep blowing off any friends Israel has.
(06.06.12)
4. This news is few days old.. Ynet -great for "BREAKING NEWS"
(06.06.12)
5. Misleading Title
Aharon ,   Holon, Israel   (06.06.12)
Ynet, you should be ashamed of yourselves. The couple that was interviewed was quoted as saying that it was an innocent re-enactment. I don't see you posting articles about Civil War re-enactments in America. Stop trying to fan the flames of anti-semitism, there's plenty of it already!
6. #5 aharon
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.07.12)
The couple said it seemed to be an innocent question. They did not use the word 'reenactment'. I also think that there is quite a bit of difference between dressing up as Nazis and dressing up as Civil War soldiers. The two wars were different in many respects. One is recognized as a fight against fascism, the other is recognized as a war between brothers. And the point of banning Nazi uniforms, insignia, etc, is not "just" because of the Jews, but because of the British themselves, who were subject to a terrible bombardment by the Nazis, with the threat of invasion. It is a shame that the memory of many (but hopefully not all) people can be so short.
7. Well done ynet.....
Robert ,   Australia   (06.07.12)
.....this'll be fodder for the likes of Sarah B and other some posters to display their venom against Britain.
8. # 2,3 and 5
joemoer ,   israel   (06.07.12)
in the queen of englands 60 year reign how many times has she visited israel and why. are friends people who never come and visit you ? have we had any royals visit israel (only as they point out in a private capacity) just because you can visit england and stand outside the palace does not mean they like you (ever heard the joke ..some of my best friends are jewish). the britsh press have nothing good to say about israel and only report biased reports against israel.
9. The Queen never visited Israel in 60 years,
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.07.12)
she is NOT Israels friend...quite the contrary !
10. #9 you are perfectly right! The Queen is irrelevant
(06.07.12)
11. Very sad... and on this great day!
Roy Sheaperd ,   UK   (06.07.12)
The UK suffered greatly at the hands of the Nazis - what would push them to wear these garments I will never comprehend. In the UK there were 700000 military casualties and 60000 civilian deaths in W2 - these so called 'British' have zero respect for their own history, so please don’t be astonished if they have no respect for yours. As a British citizen , I apologise... but the UK is a democracy.... Just like Israel has its self hating Israelis who make Israel look bad, so too it seems the British have their self hating citizens.
12. WW2 reenactments are commonplace
(06.07.12)
This news is invented ''news''. Dressing up in WW2 gear for reenactments is not uncommon. Funny hobby but harmless. Where I live people do this for a popular airshow where the main feature is restored WW2 fighter planes. Very bad taste to ask a Jewish couple to dress up as Jews for sure. But for non Jews , whose forebears experienced the war ,the war was not about Jews but about their own country's role. . Americans think WW2 was all about them. Brits think it was all about the Battle of Britain. . Russians hardly even acknowledge that other countries had much role at all. Jews think it was all about the Holocaust and so on.
13. Not Israel's friend?
Robert ,   Australia   (06.07.12)
Who is? Also judging from the posts here Israel has no gratitude for the British who lost their lives helping to save Jews from concentration camps.
14. Bombing London,Coventry,Bristol was Hitlers Hobby as well
Alan ,   SA   (06.07.12)
15. #13.ON CONTRARY UK stopped Jews getting into Mandated Palest
Alan ,   SA   (06.07.12)
You need to read a bit wider than the Guardian.They sent Jews to CAMPS in Cyprus and Mauritius
16. #9 she never visited IRELAND until last year. It's not all
(06.07.12)
About Israel!!
17. #15 So, your "On the contrary" denies.....
Robert ,   Australia   (06.07.12)
.....the fact thousands of British troops, salors and airmen lost their lives during WWII and fighting their way in to Germany which contributed to the release of Jews from concentration camps. It seems from the many comments here that many of those lives were lost in vain. You are the one who should do a bit of reading, preferably with both eyes open.
18. # 11, # 13, # 16, # 17
Mike ,   Liverpool   (06.07.12)
Well said chaps. The problem is that most of the Israeli talkbackers view things from a narrow-minded and specifically Jewish perspective and fail completely to see the wider picture. They are also somewhat obsessed with hatred for anyone who points that out to them.
19. #7, #13, #15, #17, #18 - idiots
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.07.12)
Of course Jews (and non-Jews) are grateful to the Brits for their stand against the Nazis, and to the allies for winning the war and liberating the camps. But Jews also remember Englands actions in the ME, sending survivors of those camps to detention in Cyprus (see post #6). You therefore are also ’viewing things from your own narrow-minded and specifically British perspective and fail completely to see the wider picture’. You are also ‘somewhat obsessed with hatred for anyone who points that out to you’. Your easy acceptance of the posts of some posters as representing all of Jews and all of Israel shows your predetermined hate. It would surface no matter what was said. While posters do not represent all Jews or Israelis, I know that all you Brits (especially Robert from Australia) do not represent all, or even most of those living in the Commonwealth. There is also quite a difference between dressing up as Nazis and dressing up as other soldiers. WW2 was a fight against fascism, which the west ) incl. Britain, almost lost. What does it say about some of your countrymen that they find pleasure in dressing up as Nazis, the scourge of the earth? Most in the British Empire are not idiots. Some of them, however, show up in these posts.
20. #18 it's not Israelis commenting, they'd write in Hebrew.
(06.07.12)
These are mainly Americans. Who are generally too scared to actually join us here in Israel, or they just love Israel so much they only see one side of things and on an extreme level.
21. #20 noname - wrong
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.07.12)
Israelis know English. And some Americans who post live in Israel, while some Israelis who post do not. It is called human nature. It is a different kind of human nature to assume the worst without facts to back it up.
22. # 19
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (06.07.12)
Nice try Solomon. "Your easy acceptance of the posts of some posters as representing all of Jews and all of Israel shows your predetermined hate." That's a load of rubbish - Mike from Liverpool knows what he is talking about as he actually lives in Israel. He is myself. And I notice that YOU don't live here, but just spout your extreme opinions from across the water........
23. #21 why would they waste time reading english site when
Dror   (06.07.12)
there is an hebrew version of this site?! I live here, I socialize with Israelis, regardless if they know English or not they prefer to speak Hebrew, even when surrounded in English speakers, so why will they read this online paper? As for your comment on Americans in Israel.. well.... they are Americans in Israel, not Israelis, they may be Israelis legally but they are not native born and bred Israelis.
24. #23 dror
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.08.12)
Maybe they want to interact with Americans. Remember that they may post on both Hebrew and English sites. No one said that Americans who hold Israeli citizenship (like myself) are born and bred Israelis (neither am I).
25. #22 mike
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.08.12)
Just because Mike from Liverpool lives in Israel does not guarantee that he knows what he is talking about. And just because you say he does does not guarantee it either. Not that it matters, but I lived in Jerusalem. And a matter of curiousity: no one has ever accused me of having 'extreme opinions'. Me thinks thou doth protest too much. Read your posts and those I referred to in my post #19. You accuse others of what you yourself are guilty. Nice try, but no gold star.
Back to article