News
MKs: 'We must recognize Armenian tragedy'
Moran Azulay
Published: 12.06.12, 18:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. IT IS HIGH TIME THAT THE TRUTH BE TOLD!
stude ham   (06.12.12)
erdogan lies about just everything including his gaza flotilla debacle.
2. Armenian genocide must be fully recognized
geshmardo ,   jerusalem, israel   (06.12.12)
how long are we gonna keep silent in the face of those atrocities. Time to recognize the obvious. Do not expect people to sympathize with our fate in WWII if we're not able to fully sympathize /not just in private but also publicly/ with the terrible genocide perpetrated by the Ottomans.
3. Why doesn't President Obama want the same as Senator Obama?
zionist forever   (06.12.12)
Senator Obama said he was determined for the Armenian genocide to be recognised as such and Congress has now voted to recognise it as genocide. President Obama refers to it as an UNFORTUNATE INCIDENT. It would be considered unacceptable for the President of the United States to call the Holocaust an unfortunate incident so why should it be ok for him to just describe what happened to the Armenians as that? Israel is a country built on the backs of survivors of the worlds greatest genocide and so we have a duty to recognise the 20th centuries first genocide even if its not good for diplomatic relations with Turkey there are some things that must be put above diplomacy. If its worth patching up relations with Turkey then Erdogan will accept that Israel has recognised the Armenian genocide and not make an issue out of it.
4. A RESOUNDING YES From Knesset
(06.12.12)
Minus the REPRESSIVE arabs of coarse. And MK Rvikin there Nothing Senstive about the Timing or the Issue my I please REMIND YOU that erDOGan and erDOGan ALONE stated and has provoked the Situation of Your Government!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please Stand Tall and The TRUTH for what it is!!!!! Israel has Nohing to be ASHAMED OF PERIOD!!!!!!!!! Your Right and erDOGan is WRONG like he Usually is Sing This Song From The Rafter's As It Should!!!!!! שלום
5. Nr 2. Exelent.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (06.12.12)
If Israel dont recognise the Armenian Genocide because of political Conserns as hithereto, Israel should not Expect any sympaty in response to their own suffering. This Hypocrisy of Israel because of Political conserns, has made many Armenians Hostile to Israel and the Jews. God will Rise Armenia and the Armenian People up, as Christian confesser they where brutaly Murdered, but Judgement Day will come to the Turks and Turkey, dont delude yourselves. Turkey will and shall go down !. Arn.Sweden.
6. israel does not have to fight every battle
alexi   (06.12.12)
israel can defend itself and should quit crying about threats. It has the muscle and weapons in the extreme situation. as for armenians and erdgoan who knows well how to kill, it is not for israel or bleeding heart meretz to stick the jews' into every dispute. its about time tha tisrael stayed out of some disputes.
7. recognize the Nakba first
Son of Yaffa ,   Palestine   (06.12.12)
its the mess U started
8. the chances
anton ,   istanbul   (06.12.12)
are israel wont recognize armenian genocide But i really do hope she does :) number 5 wanna bet? ;)
9. #4 Correction
(06.12.12)
Ment to spell RIVLIN and Speaker Rivlin. My Appologies. שלום
10. Anton: I wanna bet
David Israel ,   New York, U.S.A.   (06.12.12)
I bet you that (if AKP keps on winning elections and Erdogan gets his presidency with the powers that he wants) Turkey will cease the republic that we know today spanning from Greece and Bulgaria on the West to Ira, Syria and Iraq in the East in 20 years or less. This will not be because of outside forces (yabanci mihraklar as you say in Turkish) it will happen because AKP has been paving the path slowly and with lots of patience. Today I read a piece of news in Turkish press that they are trying to identify the grave of Said I Nursi. Why is this so important to the AKP? Why was a movie made about him last year praising him and humiliating the great Ataturk? In a country where one can end up in jail for holding a sign asking for free education how come such a movie was allowed to be screened? If you really are a secular modern democrat as you claim to be another tragedy is that the (AKP) convinced even you and people like you to be against the west (USA /EU and Israel) so that during their journey to split the country you will not stand on their way.
11. Son of Jaffa Israel
JUDAH THE LION   (06.12.12)
You started and you received the Nakba Blame your brothers in Egypt,Syria Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, and the rest of the Arab countries to leave Israel, and you Arabs will come back after killing all the Jews and will be thrown to the Sea. Better dont mess or $$$$ with the Jews & Israel, otherwise you will get Nakba no 2.
12. anton no 8
AL QUDS ALYAHUDI ,   QUDS HAKA ALYAHUD   (06.12.12)
Good chance Israel will recognize the Armenian Genocide.
13. 6
zionist forever   (06.12.12)
Israel more than any other country has a duty to recognise & condemn genocide. Nobody is saying we should componsate the Armenians or do anything else just recognise what happened. It may not do us any favors with Turkey which is trying to pretend it never happened but the Armenians will appreciate it and it will hopefully open doors to new trade as a nice little bonus. Patching things up with Turkey should not be conditional on us refusing to recognise an act of genocide that took place nearly a century ago. Its not often I agree with anything have to say espepcially thart Zehavia Gal-On who has tried to silence the right wing media before but in this case she is right.
14. #7... WE DO RECOGNIZE A NAKBA
(06.12.12)
except we call it THE CHURBAN which took place in israel some 2000 years ago... well before you were born.
15. I'm an Israeli patriot, but if there is one thing about..
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.12.12)
...Israeli foreign policy that I've disliked for a long time is the political establishment's willingness to suck up to the Turks - who are deeply anti-Semitic, and the unwillingness to recognize the genocide on the Armenians - who are mostly not anti-Semitic. It's true that the world has a moral duty to treat Israel and the Jewish people's human, civil and national rights and freedom with care and respect and to respect our ancient history and rights to Israel, but in all honesty Israel has the exact same moral responsibility towards other nations as well - that includes the Armenians. If Armenians out there have been emotionally hurt by the current and our previous governments' unwillingness to recognize the Armenian genocide, I am truly sorry. As a Jew/Israeli, I can understand the pain the Armenians are going through since my own people has suffered a lot as well - in the hands of the Arabs, the Turks and the Europeans. May justice be done and may Israel recognize the Armenian tragedy.
16. Son of Yaffa @7, nonsense. It is you who started the mess
leo ,   usa   (06.12.12)
and then, decided to make national holiday out of self-inflicted wound. And you are still at it, btw.
17. #7 - I, for one, celebrate it with JOY!!!!!
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (06.12.12)
18. To: No. 7
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.12.12)
Funnily enough, it would appear that the Arabs started the war -- all six of them, in fact. Moreover, it is not Israel's fault that so many Arabs heeded the call of their leadership to get out of the way of the conquering Arab armies while they threw the Jews into the sea. As an added incentive, they were told that if they left, they could have first rights of plunder of Jewish property that would be left behind. Well, it didn't quite work out that way, but that's not Israel's fault. Why are you people so incapable of assuming responsibility for your own acts, no matter how foolish?
19. Nr 8.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (06.12.12)
So you wanna bet about Genocide eh ? You are discusting in your haughtiness, but if you are a Turk they are used to be. Yiu will soon be expelled from Istanbul who is no more. Arn.Sweden.
20. Recognition is a holly duty
Anadelfos ,   Athens Greece   (06.13.12)
The people of Israel have to recognise the Armenian Genocide, because they also lived this owfull experience.The brutal incident of SS. Struma which took place 27 years later ,gave a very describing idea about turkish hospitality, towards defenceless people. Since they didn't hesitate to send to sure death innocent Jews who had nothing to do with their country, you can easily imagine how they treated the ones who were supposed to be hostile.
21. Be a moral light Israel, don't be overly politicized. The
hippocrates ,   earth   (06.13.12)
Truth shall set you free
22. Armenian Genocide
Lorik Papyan ,   USA GLENDALE, CA   (06.13.12)
Thank you and have my respect to all people who are with with us on the path of recognizing the Armenian Genocide. Help us to restore the fair truth! Let the truth come through!
23.  RECOGNIZING IT AS A GENOCIDE
American ,   Los Angeles   (06.13.12)
and show the world that Israel and the jews are true defenders of justice.
24. In the last 2000 years
American ,   Los Angeles   (06.13.12)
only one country didn't persecute the jews and lived with them in peace - Armenia.
25. Just an excuse to wind up the Turks
Marcus   (06.13.12)
Israeli politicians should be schooled in the fine art of tact and diplomacy, but they don't need any lessons in the art of behaving like spoiled spiteful children - that's in their DNA.
26. Politics of Horse Traders and the alleged Armenian genocide
Ergun Kirlikovali ,   Irvine, USA   (06.13.12)
I find this kind of tit-for-tat diplomacy quite immature. Israel, a country in its infancy, should stand on principles, not daily changing of political winds. Here is one useful principle: always stand for truth. And here is the truth: Armenian claims of genocide are long discredited political claims, while Jewish Holocaust is a court-proven truth. Equating the two would be an insult to the silent memory of 6 million Jews who were killed ny the German Nazis just for being Jews. Armenians were temporarily removed by the Ottoman government because of what Armenians have done: they took up arms against their own state and neighbors, resorted to revolts, treason, and terrorism.
27. Agreed but what about the killing of Kurds NOW!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.13.12)
The Armenian Genocide has been "swept under the rug" because Turkey become a democratic country and a member of NATO. Now with the new "Ottoman Emperor" Erdogan, NATO's ally has become Iran's eyes into NATO, the Turkish butchery of the Kurds is also being ignored by the West and the NATO countries, so high an mighty on the Palestinian cause, have given Erdogan carte blanche! Erdogan condemns Syria but does the same to the Kurdish people! Distgusting double standards again!
28. Israel's 'apology' to Erdogen?
American voter ,   United States   (06.13.12)
I love it! The worm has turned. Let Turkey apologize for the Armenians who were massacred by Turkey. Like that's gonna happen
29. Absolutely!!!
peter vojta ,   prag   (06.13.12)
Yes, if Nakba was recognized, so must be Armenian tragedy' recognized. peter czech
30. # 11 JUDAH THE LION
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (06.13.12)
Isn't it ironic that the same arab nations you posted are imploding upon themselves and that no Jew, or Christian, is responsible for the atrocities that have become known as their 'specialty'? While some low level trolls remain here trying to distract many from this truth, it proves their desperation. Civil wars all over the arab spring and, Syria isn't finished with her own bloodlust and massacring her unarmed babes and women. Im sooooo glad there is a "nabka' may they never forget what we will never forget, NEVER AGAIN!!!!
Next talkbacks
Back to article