News
Doctors blast hospital's African refugee isolation policy
Sarit Rosenblum
Published: 04.07.12, 20:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
1. Dying to please,only Ebola needed by the Lefties .150.000 pa
ab   (07.04.12)
ls(hundred fifty thousand) from WB&Gaza(yes,GAZA) treated each year in Israeli hospitals,so they could return healthy and perk to their "Death to Israel!" activities. And then Progressive Israeli Docs complain incidence of deadly penicillin-resistent bacteria in hospitals doubled last year. Doctor,cure yourself !
2. It is not apartheid
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.04.12)
African migrants have come with diseases that have been eradicated in Israel for decades. Tuberculosis. Diphtheria. Pertussis. Hanson's Disease. Measles. Chicken pox. Hepatitis A, B and C. Haemophilus influenza. It is incumbent upon the State of Israel to protect the weakest among us -- hospitalized Israelis -- who should not be brought into contact with these life-threatening illnesses. It is unfortunate that the World Health Organization and other United Nations agencies have not done their job with respect to infectious diseases in Africa, but it is hardly apartheid to want to protect Israelis from those diseases. It has nothing to do with religion; it has nothing to do with skin color. It has everything to do with public health. I invite every leftist tear-jerker to come and sit beside an African with late-stage tuberculosis. I invite every leftist tear-jerker to come and hold the hand of an African with contact-contagious Hanson's Disease. I invite every leftist tear-jerker to come and allow an African with pertussis to cough upon them. With any luck, the lefties will bring their children along, too. Somehow, I don't think there will be any takers. Hypocrisy at its finest from Israel's left -- but what else can one expect?
3. Enough
naava ,   jerusalem   (07.04.12)
This has to be one of the most stupid articles i have ever read, and the health ministry and doctors who are complaining are idiots. For God's sake, if a hospital cannot prevent people with deadly infectious diseases from entering the hosp. and maybe causing untold deaths of patients who are vulnerable, what's the point of their medical training?? A prestigious CA hospital won't let children in as visitors during flu season. Are they to be labeled as child abusers??????? shm
4. Why the fuss! That is nothing more than quarantine!
Harry Wright ,   UK   (07.04.12)
What is wrong with these people??? They want an outbreak of contagious diseases in Israel or what!
5. The sources please !!!
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.04.12)
of all those diseases on African migrants .
6. my # 5 is for # 2
charles   (07.04.12)
7. check out the hospitals in
sue ,   jerusalem   (07.04.12)
DENMARK. They have special departments for legal foreigners. Illegal ones would not even be admitted to a clinic.
8.  "isolate African women who were cleared of infection"
yael ,   canada   (07.04.12)
enough said
9. Deport illegal aliens, end of situation.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (07.04.12)
10. 6
Lauren ,   J'Lem   (07.04.12)
"Barbash's decision came after dozens of cases where infectious diseases such as tuberculosis were discovered among the African migrant population" Read the article. This is nothing to do with skin color. Nowadays you cant even bring fresh flowers into hospitals in Europe but somehow its ok to expose Israelis (of all backgrounds and colors!) to contagious illness' when their imune systems are already weak. Israel is the only country in the middle east that accepted and harbored refugees from Darfur and many other African countries when no one else would. This article and your remark are ridiculous.
11. 10% incudence of TB! Administrator has responsibilities to
PETER SM ,   AUSTRALIA   (07.04.12)
ALL patients and staff They are NOT being refused treatment on basis of race color etc, they have visitors who are at risk. It us a difficult situation not helped by shouting slogans
12. #4 is right on...
Malone ,   Hfx   (07.04.12)
It's called quarantine,not apartheid..this political correctness and never ending calls of racism must stop. To top it all off,these people are "illegal". These idiot lefties are simply too much.:(
13. exactly the wrong thing to do
zionist forever   (07.04.12)
If these people have infectious diseases then they need to be treated in hospital. Leave them running around the streets with an infectious disease and others can catch it and rather than having one sick African you have many sick Israelis. Reality here is the hospitals want to save money so they don't want to treat the people they know don't have the money to pay their bills.
14. Darn, where was Haaretz when my wife needed hospital
Miron ,   USA   (07.04.12)
on Hawaii. Amerian Yepertheid in hospitals... In the end we had to go to community hospital run by volunteer physicians free of chanrge. ( they pay rent for the building out of their regular salaries ). I heard hospital was closed during Obama tenure because it refused to cover health care tax. I mean for all this long winged tailes about yepertheid and schmepertheid there is a very simple reality. Doctors can be used to force money out of sick people. Not nesesserilly sick with cancer. We keep forgetting that without bottle of anti - biotics a mere infrction is a deadly disease that took lives of 60% of infected people merely 80 years ago. Those who tried to support our nation enlightened tradition, who tried to help free of charge to needy, like these African migrants, are being hunted down as undesirable elements by Obama because they deny him money he needs for his wars.
15. Illegal! Charge Barbash.
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.04.12)
16. Sourasky THANK YOU TO PROTECT US !
(07.04.12)
17. It's official
Avramele   (07.05.12)
We have become a nation like all others and have found a cure for the Jewish sensibility or what my grandparents called a yiddishe Kup. Ah the miracles of Israeli medical science!
18. The idea seems to make sense, but let the ministry decide
Avi   (07.05.12)
I do not see it as a decision based on skin color, but based on origin, and there's no racism in the fact that the states they come from is riddled with diseases, strengthened by the fact that indeed there have been many rare disease cases for Africans in Israel, as the article cites. It would make sense to label them as a population at risk and have them medically examined. They're getting a free x-ray check up, at the expense of the state, so I'm not sure what's the fuss.
19. Israel has the BEST medical care
Dan   (07.05.12)
The health ministry and some doctors must think that Israel really has the best and richest medical care facilities in the world. The way the hospitals are run -with direction from the health ministry- is the reason there are no superbugs in Israel, and a large number of free beds in all the hospitals. I just hope that when I catch tuberculosis on the bus or train, I will be able to get into one of these great centers of healing. The HM should actually send out mobile units to start checking EVERYONE for these contagious diseases.
20. RE: Very Ignorant and Stupid
Joseph ,   New Zealand   (07.05.12)
I can't believe that the policy makers are so ignorant. Why are you treating black people like animals? First you discarded their blood and now this?
21. WHO CARES?
Keren ,   IL-BR   (07.05.12)
Aren't they being treated?What the heck is this issue now? They are being treated and that's more than enough.Period! Hopefully they will get out of Israel soon and be treated without "apartheid"in Africa. This problem in Israel is a problem created by Yishai and his "religious"ilk in the Knesset.It was them who said that it was ok to let this people in .Now they saw the mistake and want them out. They can't decide what's right and what's wrong,so they are equal of others and can't be representative of Torah. To make Israel kosher,we don't need them in power. Israel will be kosher anyway.Perhaps more kosher without them making troubles.
22. Amazing (As the Racist state is busy persuading African
shaggy ,   Cape Town   (07.05.12)
African Americans to come make shows in Israel, These same people are busy treating Africans like trash. In fact if am to look for countries to visit , I would have considered visiting Nazi Germany because it was only against one race. And was in good terms with Africans.... What are isrealis doing in Africa ? They should also be sent back home , Nationalize all isreal owned hotels in Mombasa send the Jews back to the promised land. How do they manage to live along with black people in Africa ? hundreds if not thousands staying and visiting Africa , how comes they haven't been noticing that ?
23. Africans
Val P ,   USA   (07.05.12)
Once again Sarah, you hit the nail on the head. Black Africans don't get shots, accept. for the rich ones If anything, they should have their own clients to go to. Well, here. it is the 4th of July. Signing off for now. . .
24. To: No. 5
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.05.12)
Just google "Infectious diseases - Eritrea," "Infectious diseases - Ethiopia," "Infectious diseases - Sudan," "Infectious diseases - Ivory Coast" and so on ad nauseum. You'll get your answers. Frankly, the situation is far worse than the diseases which I mentioned.
25. What I hear
Barak ,   Toronto, Canada   (07.05.12)
I hear a lot of people pointing fingers at Israel, but I don't hear anyone offering to take the refugees in.
26. OMG!!!!!!
M ,   USA   (07.05.12)
Israel isn't being politically correct everyone!!!!!!!! OMG!!!!! The Left is upset and we can't have that!!!
27. # 2
Judith Horowitz ,   Los Angeles,USA   (07.05.12)
" With any luck, the lefities will bring their children along, too." You have truly sunk to a new low. What a disgusting thing to write about children. You are a completely revolting excuse for a human being. Judith Horowitz Los Angeles,U.S.A.
28. If Israel makes it easy on African/Moslems
Ron ,   OC US   (07.05.12)
Then Israel will get more African/Moslems. They can go to Egypt or Nigeria for their medical care.
29. are they all Sick?
Dah ,   Herzliya   (07.05.12)
Does every African Origin or black in Israel have an infectious diseases? very funny, but very disturbing racism, that attempts to justify actions. We got it.
30. oh for crying out loud
rm ,   A'dam Netherlands   (07.05.12)
I cannot believe the stupidity of some who are trying to make a case why it's a good idea to not let these people in a hospital.....riiiight....it's so much better to leave em out in the streets where it's so much less likely they infect others....Ofcourse they should be in a hospital...in isolation...anything other is sheer stupidity....
Next talkbacks
Back to article