News  World News
'US sees Israel as counterintelligence threat'
Yitzhak Benhorin, AP
Published: 28.07.12, 18:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
85 Talkbacks for this article
31. An eye on them
R. Brosilow ,   Rehovot, Israel   (07.28.12)
Glad to know that we are keeping an eye on our so-called 'best friend.
32. Pollard should never ever be released, period!
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A.   (07.28.12)
33. RE: US sees Israel as counterintelligence threat
Ephraim ,   Las Vegas NV US   (07.28.12)
Compared with Iran's efforts since 1979? Brilliant thinking. Under the Obama administration, up is down and black is white. What could anyone who voted for him thinking? Apparently, the CIA needs to brush up on the differences between Israeli democracy v. Iranian theocracy. I wonder how the CIA compares Obama's - oops, sorry - "the White House's" LeakGate affair as a threat to U.S. security?
34. This is public knowledge...
Persian CAT   (07.28.12)
In the US, Israel and the whole wide world. I'm surprised some consider this as "news"!
35. sensitive equipment
arthurf ,   amsterdamn   (07.28.12)
What? The guy left his special communication device unattended? The poor bastard will surely lose his job...
36. Come CIA boys, it was only a warning to be more careful .
deavman ,   Acco, Israel   (07.28.12)
37. RE: 12 Get away from here. We don't need you
Ephraim ,   Las Vegas NV US   (07.28.12)
Hopefully, by: "We are tired of all these Americans around." Karen IL-BR referred to American spies, as in CIA staffers. I suspect that average Americans would wish nothing more than for Israelis to be free to live their lives in peace, and the same for those in their neighboring states.
38. Pollard
Joe ,   USA   (07.28.12)
Israel is considered the number one threat to America as a thief of US technology. It is for these reasons that Pollard is treated harshly as a deterrent to other ''Israel firster'' Americans. Supporting Israel has destroyed America. Look at its craven cowardly politicians who are afraid to criticize Israeli policy because they know that organized Jewry will destroy their careers if they do. . Look at the American media... the least free press in the entire world ( you need to read Israeli press to find any real free discussion about Israel). Woe is America...once a proud nation. It has been destroyed from within.
39. Spies in Israeli Goverment
Joe Sombrero ,   Usa   (07.28.12)
Want to bet there are Spies in the Israeli Cabinet and goverment working for the CIA. Arrest them and trade them for Pollard.
40. Remember 73
Joe Sombrero ,   USA   (07.28.12)
The United States backstabbed Israel in 1973 causeing the deaths of 3000 Israelis I have a feeling they are setting Israel up for a fall. Be careful don't trust the US.
41. #2 Who is we?
Phil ,   USA   (07.29.12)
You are "Tom from the USA" and you use the terms like "WE protect OURSELVES" and "our existence". I have no problem with Israelis believing in Israeli interests, but I assume you are an American..... The major difference the US spying on Israel (if you read the article it says they need high level permission to recruit sources from israeli govt) is that #1 the US isn't using religion as a basis to recruit someone to betray their country which is utterly disrespectful and offensive to US Jews and #2 Israel does not have troops and equipment stationed in the US and doesn't pour tax payer money into the government and military like the US does in Israel
42. American Conspiracy
David Cohen ,   L A U S A   (07.29.12)
If it is true then we shouldn't be wondered that C I A does the same thing to us. they are afraid of our Super Technology and We are certainly afraid of their Known Strategy to sell their best allies to their Enemies when it is necessary !. Pollard found out that in spite of exchanging security information Strategy agreement between both countries ( Israel and U S ) the Americans were hiding very sensitive information from israel and deliver them in to the hands of the most dangerous enemy of Israel at the time, Saudi Arabia . Let's talk about the American involvement of spying against Israel in the 6 days War that they were sending informations by using their battle ship facilities in the Mediterranean sea to the british in Cyprus and from them to the enemies of Israel . Or The Nasty Role Of the U S Government in Yom Kippur War that not only they had conspiracy with the Egyptians behind the scene to fail Israelis in the battle! even they put embargo on sending the weapons that we already paid for them . those were 3 samples out of 100s of plot from Our Best Friend! The United States Of America , Certanly There Are More!.
43. You are correct
Johanna ,   Orlando USA   (07.29.12)
Obama is simply a Chicago backroom ward boss. Nothing more, nothing less. He's also overtly a president who favors anything islamic. So, the idiots who voted for him got what they wanted. Unfortunately, the rest of us are stuck with him.
44. #26 Joe Alon And what the CIA knows
Joe Sombrero ,   USA   (07.29.12)
That is a answer I would personally like to know.
45. Pollard was caught with
SD Charger ,   San Diego   (07.29.12)
sensitive material pertaining to the US. Our spooks are in Israel in case something drastic happens suddenly in the ME. Of course they are there to gather as much information as possible. You can swap one of ours when he is caught with sensitive intelligence pertaining to Israel, deal?
46. The CIA is much different post 9/11
SD Charger ,   San Diego   (07.29.12)
I would also see what they were up to if I was in Israel. They have been taught by the best (Israel) and their network is everywhere now. Everywhere!
47. Go İsrael go!
kuzeykan ,   Turkey   (07.29.12)
do everything to make your country an isolated and lonely country in the world...No friend , no ally...Because you do not need anyone and you are the strongest state in the world...And conditions never change..the world order will be always same... You know, in 2020,or 2040 , everything will be same today..Your are the celeverest and your prediction for future can never be failed... İf you fail, you will find yourself alone... you are living in not this world, in another planet...So you do not need any friends...
48. #42
Malcolm Blankenship ,   Salisbury, NC USA   (07.29.12)
keep spitting the hasbara. We invent everything and you just add to it. Example, the Patriot, you took existing tech built off of it. Must be nice working off the sweaty R&D the west does (Lavi Too F-16 copy). You people had no idea about missile defence before the early 90's. The only thing Israel is really good at is theft and deception. One state, one vote. Also, screen for zionist for US gov positions. And no,I'm a Presbyterian from NC.
49. Compilation of lies
idan ,   tel aviv   (07.29.12)
50. Ha!
Daniel   (07.29.12)
Fine, #12, you want America to stay away? Then reject the $3 billion a year the US gives Israel. Reject the US technology that allows Israel to stay ahead of its neighbors militarily. Oh right, sorry, Israel needs that American technology so it can sell it to the Chinese. I see you sign your comment "USA/Israel" - move to Israel and give up your US citizenship, it's clear where your loyalties lie.
51. 23 - Ruby, excellent observation about timing
Mark   (07.29.12)
52. Yeah, well
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.29.12)
The United States is entirely dependent upon the Mossad for highly important intelligence that the United States cannot acquire on its own. Without Israeli intelligence, the United States wouldn't have a clue as to what is going on. Did not Israel warn the United States that the U.S. Embassy in Lebanon and the Marine Barracks were going to be attacked? Did the United States pay attention? No. Of course, several hundred Americans paid the price, but I guess the United States just didn't care. Going back even further, when the United States had absolutely no idea what was happening in the Soviet Union following the death of Stalin, it was Israel that gave the United States a word-for-word transcript of Khrushchev's famous de-Stalinization speech. In the early 1960s, it became very evident to Israel that there were high-ranking Soviet moles operating in the United States under the guise of being British diplomats. The United States shrugged it off, and James Jesus Angleton of the C.I.A. called the warning "patently ridiculous." Yeah, right. Can anyone spell "Kim Philby?" There are so many more examples. If the United States cannot stand the heat, it needs to get out of the kitchen. Do you really think that Aldrich Ames or Robert Hansen were the last of your problems? Guess again. United States foreign intelligence and domestic intelligence services are riddled with paid spies for some VERY nasty foes. Fortunately, the Mossad remains professional. The United States wants -- and it does -- and needs -- and it does -- Israeli intelligence. Otherwise, just go ask the Egyptians -- oops, big no there! -- or the Saudis -- oops, even bigger no there! -- or .... or ..... or ..... get the point?
53. What is the CIA doing in Tel - Aviv anyway
Arnold ,   Canada   (07.29.12)
They are using Israel as a base to spy on all the other countries in the region. Including Israel. DUHHHHHH. What a non-story story. I wonder what "tricky Dicky Nixon" would think. He spied on his own country and lied about it.
54. # 26 joe allon was a ladies man, it's possible
ben   (07.29.12)
that he messed with the wrong woman. unlike Ahmed Bouchiki
55. Other mideast countries are not capable
Johanna ,   Orlando, USA   (07.29.12)
Let's face it: the only reason the CIA considers Israel the top counterintelligence threat is because surrounding countries do not have the intelligence capabilities that Israel has. And, why does the CIA have personnel living in Israel, if not to conduct its own intelligence operations? This isn't exactly news, but friendly nations spy on each other too. Every nation does it. Unfortunately, the Pollard case really soured relations as far as Washington is concerned. That blunder cost the Israelis far more in the long term than it was worth in intelligence that the traitor Pollard volunteered to give Israel. And, he took money from Israel while doing it. That makes him something different from a misguided supporter of Israel. That makes him a spy and a traitor. The CIA isn't going to forgive and forget anytime soon.
56. Dual Loyalty?
Frank Owen ,   Miami, USA   (07.29.12)
Are American Jews not citizens of the United States? So why the use of "us", "our" and "we" in reference to Israel? Dual loyalty? It sounds more like single loyalty.
57. #41.Phil "WE" are the Eurasian Jews
Tom W ,   USA   (07.29.12)
FYI; Not American but Eurasian Jews (Holocaust survivors, Sephardim and Mizrahim) founded, built and fought for Israel. Pres. Truman ordered an arms embargo on Israel when the British 'Sir" John Glubb pasha attacked the nascent state, American arms embargo was in force between 1947-1962. During the '67 war Pres. Johnson reinstated the embargo, so did Nixon and relented only when Israel was ready to use nuke. I was born during the Holocaust in E. EU and I have nothing to do with the American leftist Court Jewry. I hope it explains everything.
58. #42.David: You & I we have good memories
Tom W ,   USA   (07.29.12)
During Israel's most fateful hours and wars of Independence American gov.ments, Truman, Johnson, Nixon ordered an arms embargo against Israel as if she were an enemy state. Whenever Americans start bragging about their magnanimous support of Israel our moral duty is to remind them to their duplicitous policy vis á vis Israel.
59. #55 No, Johanna, Pollard was worth it.
Vlad   (07.29.12)
Jonathan Pollard gave extremely valuable intel on Arab military capabilities, especially on Tunisian air defenses, which helped Israel bomb the PLO HQ near Tunis. He allowed Israel to anticipate what Washington was going to do next in the region, and prepare a response. And most importantly, he gave Israel information which allowed it to fire cruise missiles from submarines. It was worth it 100% to recruit him. The only mistake came in there being no escape plan which would have been put into effect the moment the FBI had begun interviewing him. Or denying him shelter at the embassy. Or refusing to exchange him for Yosef Amit.
60. Keren
Vlad   (07.29.12)
These spies have to be in Israel. They are part of the embassy's intelligence section. Israel is not going to have any Mossad stations at its embassies abroad if it doesn't reciprocate.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article