News
Haniyeh's brother-in-law was treated at Israeli hospital
Elior Levy
Published: 07.08.12, 20:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
31. Why israel ?
Tommy Tuck ,   Toronto   (08.08.12)
Why not go to Beirut ? Teheran ? Cairo ?
32. Jane # 19
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (08.07.12)
So if it's not the point why don't you enlighten us? I think Manny is right but if you think he is wrong tell us why.
33. Thank you Mark # 8
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (08.07.12)
You gave me an answer to the question I asked # 19. I didn't know that.
34. William # 23
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (08.07.12)
Thank you for adding to post # 8. Whoever ends up paying it's ironic that these people are able to get health care from an entity they refuse to acknowledge exists.
35. Terrorist's heart transplant
ik ,   USA   (08.08.12)
Then why did he go to an ISRAELI hospital instead of their own???
36. The question that beggs is:
m   (08.08.12)
Are we that stupid or that spineless that we need to "show" the world every day: look how GOOD we are, we too deserve living. I wonder how many German children or HItler brothers in law would have been treated during WWII in London. We have completely lost the right and wrong sense. An enemy who denies you the right to live and you have to threat him in the hospital with or without money, this is not the ISSUE. It shows we behave like worms not the G-d's children. Shame on all the Jews who feel it makes them higher for being "superior" to "them".
37. Their greatest dream is blowing up that hospital
Avi   (08.07.12)
This is as moronic as letting that terrorist woman who tried to blow up a hospital to be treated in it after being pacified by security forces. Its disgusting and cynical. I'm sure the Gazan media agencies did all they could to silence the story.
38. #15, Abu Jihad
Ehud   (08.08.12)
1. I doubt that that the PA which Hamas overthrowed (throwing them literally out of the window from the 11th floor) offered to pay; 2. Even if so, everybody here in the medical system and beyond knows that their commitment to pay is not worth the paper it's written on - it is simply never honored, so we write the damage off and do it anyway. 3. The fact that you think we "owe you something" because we won our War of Independence after you attacked us, destroyed all synagogues in Jerusalem's Jewish quarter and drove the Jews out of East Jerusalem baffles me. 4. Are you really Arab, or an extreme left wing Jew posing as an Arab - would 'Abu Jihad' not rather write 'Al Kuds' than 'Jerusalem' (the latter derived from the Hebrew 'Yerushalayim')? 3.
39. Always hatred & the begging bowl with you Arab lot
Cameron ,   USA   (08.08.12)
40. medical treatment
steven ,   us   (08.07.12)
they should have harvested his organs and sent him back dead and empty.
41. @5 yes, we no the drill
Ron ,   Melbourne, Australia   (08.08.12)
Yes, Mr. Abdullah from Jordan - it is always someone else never the Muslims. How did Islam spread ?? - by providing milk and cookies ? Did it not send Armies to concur , did it not have an empire which was longer then most in history subjugating people from the far reaches of India to the Eastern part of Europe, did it not kill numerous communities of Jews over the centuries, were there no progroms, forced conversions, etc in Muslims countries, there were massacres of Jews before Israel was created in most parts of the Muslim world, etc ,etc - the list is long, the numbers are large and the atrocities are huge. Forgetting the Armenians, the Bahais, etc, etc. By your concept all Israel has to do is blame everything on Muslims - they are the originators of the persecution and killings. How about setting the bar a little higher - not try and justify things to suit your primitive way of thinking - but use rationality , tools of inquiry, etc - or is that too much to ask.
42. Abdulah, you are going nowhere that way
Yossef   (08.08.12)
43. To #5 ..Arabs done a lot of uprooting of others
Oleg   (08.08.12)
and it was not a big deal for them...so take a hike with your hypocritical morality hear. Those people should not been allowed to Israel
44. Testimony to G-d's mercy & love for all
David ,   Sanda City, Japan   (08.08.12)
Eventually the force of justice will win over the fanatic barbarism of those who are hellbent on Israel's destruction by extending God's mercy in the world through these actions of loving kindness.
45. Now all we need ...
Ari ,   Haifa   (08.08.12)
Now all we need is for some good Israeli lawyer to to help him sue the Israeli doctors and hospital for malpractice.
46. War
Steve ,   Dallas USA   (08.08.12)
Would the US or the UK have treated the wife of a ranking Nazi, related to Hitler or Goering during the war? This is insane. She could have gone to Egypt - it was not a matter of leaving - and from Egypt to Europe. Once she crossed to Israel, she should have been held as an enemy alien.
47. Mark Vancouver.
Aaron ,   USA/Israel   (08.08.12)
A lie. Israel fits the bill as a charge off.
48. you expected decency? they're hateful, fanatical terrorists
rick ,   walnut creek   (08.08.12)
don't expect decency. don't expect gratitude. don't expect honesty. don't expect humanity. these are hateful, fanatical, despicable, islamist terrorists. can you imagine the family of Jewish leader (Israel has no extremist analog to the gaza terrorists) seeking help from gaza? and being helped and treated with kindness and respect? can you imagine that? if you can, you have a very inventive IMAGINATION.
49. to #2 Israel didn't caused nothing, next
ghostq   (08.08.12)
you blame Israel for the hole in the ozone layer. Israel didn't creat the refugee camps, the blue prints lay in the British archieve for some odd reason. will jordanian doctor give that much medical care to jews? I don't think so. as for the gazans were never habitats of jerusalem, only 20 families survived anchor mission.
50. And Abu Ala's daughter got expidited Israeli citizenship
Orly ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.08.12)
Thanks to expidited efforts of ex FM. Meanwhile Jews battle with the Interior Ministry and Jewish Agency for recognition to immigrate. In a Banana Republic like Israel, what do you expect?
51. to #15 there is no sea beween gaza and Israel
ghostq   (08.08.12)
he never had a home in Israel.
52. Hats off to the surgeons
Talula ,   Israel   (08.08.12)
whose hands didn't 'accidentally' slip during surgery. The thing about us, is that we respect the sanctity of life.
53. If he dies
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (08.08.12)
Jews will get blamed, if he lives, perhaps Haniyeh hates the guy, so Jews will get blamed. Hatred defines the identity of Israel's enemies, and Jews doing the good that comes naturally, will not melt their wicked hearts.
54. to tommy tuck ontario
miri ,   israel   (08.08.12)
because they have faith in our wonderful jewish doctors !
55. The other way around
Ronnie ,   Israel   (08.08.12)
If an Israeli needed specialized treatment only available in Ramalla would he be prepared to go there??
56. medical treatment in israel
Edy Burak ,   miami , USA   (08.08.12)
are you sure this guy have a heart ???? the palestinian stole the peoples money to buy weapons instead of build hospitals , schools , roads , etc....
57. Why treat any one from Gaza in an Israeli hospital?
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (08.08.12)
seems nuts to me, Israel treats the same terrorists that heal them so they can attack Jews once again. Isn't someone acting nuts here? Stop allowing Israel's murderers the privilege of fighting Israel another day. Make the pals pay for a better hospital and Dr.s who treat the living not burying their dead martyrs. STOP THIS!
58. Gaza has a reral up market new shopping mall, 5 star hotels
Arlene ,   Israel   (08.08.12)
and many other facilities you would not beleive...in fact its one 5 star so called "refugee" camp. AND they cant afford a better equipped hospital. Where has all the donations from the worlds naive gone??? what no money for what is very important! Something reeks of corruption in the strip!
59. I do wonder what those people that
Peggy ,   UK   (08.08.12)
live under shelling from gaza think of this!!!!
60. #15
Lippy ,   Proud Israeli.   (08.08.12)
OK you ungrateful misery. No more favors!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article