Jewish Scene
Soldiers' parents: Kahane supporter lectures our kids
Yoav Friedman
Published: 13.08.12, 14:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Kahane predicted Israeli current events in the 1970s.
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.13.12)
History has completely vindicated the late Rabbi Meir Kahane. Read his seminal book, "They Must Go", and you will quickly realize all Kahane's predictions, made in the 1970s, are coming true today. Ultimately, Kahane's solution; compensating many Arabs to leave Israel, is the only workable solution.
2. Beter a lecture from this rabbi than the not-supreme court.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (08.13.12)
3. baruch hasheam yisrael chai
alan ash ,   nyc ny   (08.13.12)
only the proud can properly teach . wonderful . lets all get back to being the nation wants us to be . strong. caring.and tough to your enemy.
4. Kach was banned because the Israeli elite were scared of him
Jake ,   USA   (08.13.12)
Rabbi Kahane did nothing more than voice his opinions. He was a courageous man who had bold solutions to Israel's many problems. Contrary to the lies spewed about him, he never called for the expulsion of Arabs, rather for there to be a state policy of persuading them to emigrate.
5. Disengagement brought on all this
Mike ,   Haifa   (08.13.12)
This phenomenon started because of the disengagement after which there was an unwritten consensus among political and IDF military brass to appease and pacify the terrible pajnful post-disengagement situation by allowing the religious zionist rabbis to propagate their ideas and get the anger out of their systems. And now Kahanism in IDF. It the fault of us the secularists that abandoned the Land so that today the only ones who cherish our land are the extreme religoius zionists who will dominate the future leadership when the bankrupt post-zionist politicians will disappear due to their failures.
6. Kahane was a Tzaddik
Dan   (08.13.12)
If only Kahane had become prime minister. Kahane was a true prophet!
7. The spirit of Rav Meir Kahane stile alive
Yoav ,   Germany   (08.13.12)
Baruch HaShem for that. Am Kahane Chai!
8. What next..... burn his books?
BH ,   Iowa   (08.13.12)
For the unforgivable crime of being a patriot?
9. Better than listening to peres and his
jason white ,   afula, israel   (08.13.12)
10. Population exchanges have been carried
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (08.13.12)
between Greece-Turkey , Germany - Poland etc.Is the ruling elite afraid of a jewish Israel ?
11. I wonder if the one who was behind
Samuel   (08.14.12)
the murder of Rabbi Meir Kahane was the one behind the mruder of Rabin.
12. I wonder
Paul ,   Australia   (08.14.12)
I wonder how much a "Intelligence Service" and some top brass in Israels Establishment were involved. Only time will tell and in the meantime all of Israel will suffer. Kahane had guts not like those whimps who run the country now.
13. Discracefull , discusting and should be banned
Haim ,   TA   (08.14.12)
These people should not be allowed to preach their particular brand of hatefull , right wing religious BS. Any decent human being with an ounce of decency should have nothing to do with these cult lunatics.
14. Why do they always kill the messenger?
Jake Stone ,   USA   (08.14.12)
Kahane was a patriot!!!
15. Even a hysterical secular like myself I must admit, that I'd
tom ,   tel aviv   (08.14.12)
rather have Kahane run the show than Peace Now or their ilk!
16. But it's ok to force IDF to attend pro-homo lectures?
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.14.12)
Only if it's the army of Sodom!
17. Rak "Kach"! Only thus!
Abrawka ,   Miami, FL   (08.14.12)
Whether leftists & liberals want it or not, future belongs to Rav Kahane's teachings. We are all Kahane!
18. leftie inquisition is better? shame on ynet
rivka ,   israel   (08.15.12)
lefties arrest rabbis, destroy their books and even helped to comeet the murder of Rav Kahana and family. They celebrate the criminals of oslo but Rav Kahana's teaching are forbidden. shame
19. Shame that only the Left isn't Lecturing, like the author
Netanya ,   Netanya   (08.15.12)
wants. Hearing another side is against the liberals, since then these young minds may think and decide not to be left wing idiots. But the author is a typical lefty who cannot stand the idea that the right is given any time or platform. If the author against the loads of left wing professors who are teaching their own idealism to hundreds of students every year?
20. The secular zionists are history they dont exist
Al   (08.15.12)
Secular zionism is history and if you are honest with yourselves you would admit it. What the bozos who advocated the expulsion of 10K Jews from Gaza didnt see was that they and their agenda will become poison to the Israeli people. Today Hamas Gaza bombs you whenever they want. Sinai will be the 1967 all over again. Egypt just found their excuse to bring a massive army into there to confront you at some future date. Should Obama be re-elected you will be screwed blued and tattooed. You can thank all these events to the piss poor leadership you have and have had over the past 25 years.
21. Legitimacy of K. given not by the army but by current events
Mark   (08.15.12)
It's the way Israel has slid down since 1967 that proves Kahane was right. Post by Chaim #1 is right on.
22. which of his positions were wrong? pray tell????
jack bauer   (08.15.12)
the one where he admits the arabs are our enemies who try to destroy us at ever turn? maybe the one that supports our enemies being sent out to the neighboring arab lands? I wonder why its taboo to mention what is obvious to a 10 year old who fears getting on the bus or running from rocket fire. Kahane was right!
23. Good
hippocrates ,   earth   (08.15.12)
24. Kahane's program was officially adopted in Knesset in 2005
Joe Six Pack ,   Sun House, SA   (05.06.13)
There were only three differences between the 2005 disengagement plan and the Kahane plan: 1. In 2005, The innocent were expelled instead of the guilty. 2. The expelled innocents were not given the option to stay, while Kahane's plan gave the guilty the option of staying. Kahane's plan was 10 times more humane then the disengagement was. Now that the precident has been set, there is no doubt that when Kahane's plan come to a vote in the future, all the parties which supported the disengagement plan will support the Kahane plan.
Back to article