News
Yishai: Next phase – arresting Eritrean, Sudanese migrants
Omri Efraim
Published: 16.08.12, 18:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
31. Yishai: Next phase - No 5 Alexander
ADAM ,   LOndon   (08.16.12)
Honestly what a load of rubbish. Theres one born every minute.
32. YISHAI WE SUPPORT YOU. THANKS !
(08.16.12)
33. # 6 pathetic sentence
(08.16.12)
34. Yshai understands the lives of poor israelis
(08.16.12)
who live with those violent illegals
35. rich Leftists don't care about poor israelis from South TLA
(08.16.12)
36. the people against illegals ! Yishai thank you !
David   (08.16.12)
37. do u know what ILLEGAL MEANS ?! Deport them all !
(08.16.12)
38.  # 2 has just hate in his heart
(08.16.12)
39. I support the plan but Yishai needs anger management
INETFRAUD ,   US/IL   (08.16.12)
This man has more vengence in his blood than a jackal. Its not right to make the lives of human beings 'miserable'! How stupid and sub-human could a man be? SHAME ON HIM for even thinking such!!!! While I support the plan entirely, due to the severe problems the immigrants have caused and most especially because ISRAEL IS WAY TOO SMALL TO BE HOSTING REFUGEES!!!! I mean, get a clue!!!! Its an existential issue: the world has kicked our arses for over 2,000 yrs; we simply can NEVER allow our homeland to become populated with foreigners. Not apartheid: Not Divisive: SURVIVALIST! PERIOD!!! Sorry folks: we can't trust ANYONE but ourselves. Shame on Yishai; I;m embarrassed a Jew could openly state such a thing. AM YISRAEL CHAI.
40. Detention is just more expense for taxpayers.....!!!!!!!!!!!
Dora ,   Israel   (08.16.12)
You're head of Interior Ministry. Just deport them!!!!! For every one you deport, another 5000 enter this county.... How about you MOVE ON THIS ISSUE like its important?!!!
41. Eli Yishai is a criminal
jay abouaf ,   jaffa israel   (08.16.12)
This man is a sadist and a fool. He is seriously harming Israel and should be put away.
42. Very positive and taking a lead from Australia
aliza ,   Israel   (08.16.12)
whose government joined together with the Opposition passed legislation today that all illegals, asylum seekers that arrive by boat (over 7,000 so far this year) will be processed off-shore on islands in the Pacific and New Guinea and placed in detention centres. Many will stay there for years. Th aim of this is to deter so called "refugees"
43. Yshai so dangerous as migrants.
microbiolog ,   israel   (08.16.12)
44. you are a bastard
(08.16.12)
45. # 24
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (08.16.12)
With you a million percent on that Paul.
46. To nr 21 - It applies to all illegals of all ethnicities
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (08.16.12)
Africans, Asians, Arabs, Russians, Turks, Europeans - everybody who enters Israel illegally should be thrown out. If Jews enter Israel illegally they should be thrown out too. Jews for example have no reason to enter Israel illegally since they can easily buy an air ticket, go on vacation or make aliyah and settle down - there is no reason for Jews to enter Israel illegally since Israel's policy is to allow Jews to make aliyah. But the law is the law and this law is meant to 1) protect the Jewishness of Israel and 2) to protect the independence and sovereignty of Israel.
47. eli yishai and immigrants
joey low ,   new york, usa   (08.16.12)
eli yishai is far more dangerous to israel's well being then are the infiltrators. someone should point out to him the damage he is causing israel. he speaks like a real racist and is an embarrassment to the jewish people. how he can claim to be relgious is beyond my understanding. he would be wise to spend more time studying the bible and less time speaking. we would all be better off. joey low
48. #24 Paul
Keren ,   IL-BR   (08.16.12)
I agree with Alexander #5,and I can assure you that the great majority of Jews also agree.
49.  '17' Moragh
I am "Black"   (08.16.12)
What is wrong with Black? isn't just sight of color?, is there something rather than color? what do you think it would happen if Israel turn into black ? what is Israelis Color? are Israelis Pink,red,grey yellow or black, make no mistake, there is no white human colored , only milk is white. I hope you can answer, because it is more irritating when an idiots poolshit something they cann't expain.
50. What is wrong with black Isael
to 17 Moragh   (08.16.12)
What is wrong with Black? isn't just sight of color?, is there something rather than color? what do you think it would happen if Israel turn into black ? what is Israelis Color? are Israelis Pink,red,grey yellow or black, make no mistake, there is no white human colored , only milk is white. I hope you can answer, because it is more irritating when an idiots poolshit something they cann't expain.
51. # 24 - I agree with Alexander
Oded ,   Beer Sheva   (08.16.12)
We have too many non Jews here. It's one thing if non Jews are 1% or maybe 5% of the population - then Israel could maybe be a bit more generous with non Jews becoming citizens. But if non Jews are already 20% of Israel's population, letting them in would only jeopardize Israel's Jewish character. This is true to any nation state that wishes to maintain its identity - this applies to all nation states and not just Israel. So nice try evoking Jewish morality but we Jews are not that "moral" that we will end up in exile again without a homeland. Nice try Paul but it won't work. No sob story appealing to our famous Jewish morality will persuade us into destroying our own country just to make you happy. Won't happen. You are a foreigner in a Jewish state with equal civil rights. Just accept it. Japan, Finland and Denmark are very restrictive when letting foreigners becoming citizens. In Israel we have roughly 80% Jews and 20% non Jews. In Japan, you have 98.5% Japanese and 1.5% foreigners. Which of these countries do you think needs to defend their identity the most? Israel should be very restrictive. Japan on the other hand can allow itself to have a little bit more relaxed immigration laws. Yet no criticism against Japan, Finland or Denmark. No Paul you don't belong here. Since when are British people the natives of Israel? Are you related to our Jewish forefathers in Israel? I don't think the Israelites were English speaking mean called Paul nor were they any other identity but Israelites/Jews. You can stay here and enjoy civil rights, but you have no national rights in Israel. We Israelis have no Israeli national rights in UK. Isn't that racism too?
52. I'll lock them up to make their lives miserable,"
Afri   (08.17.12)
"'illegal migrant threat just as severe as Iranian nuke threat'" "until I can deport them I'll lock them up to make their lives miserable," said the minister. also Dear Israeli Internior Minister Eli Yishai publicly stated that Israel is not country of Black Man, as well as other accounts cancer, other constant bullshit statements everyday through the media , insulting illegal migrants from Africa. is something wrong with Eli Yishai, and do i consider as a god psychiac and fanatic, lunatic leader ,who is taking an advantage from both Israelis and illegal african poor who live miserably in Israel. or am I out of the whole Israeli thought,moral, human civilized "lines"
53. To #5 you are completely right
Clear thinker ,   TLV & NYC   (08.17.12)
Anyone who disagrees does not love Israel and what it stands for.
54. as equal to the idea of hitler
chipogoder ,   israel   (08.17.12)
Yishai be out of the errant idea.Do you want to revise the history of Hitler?
55. #23 Please ,Alan,note....
Keren ,   IL-BR   (08.17.12)
I AM NOT A WILD ANIMAL! I deserve something BIGGER than KRUGER! I deserve the WHOLE Israel-from the river to the sea- to preserve ME for posterity! ok?
56. daddy might be up in front of a judge next
zionist forever   (08.17.12)
By losing this court case and having to shell out $1.2 million to friends of the IDF I imagine that might be considerd brining shame to the family and we all know what Muslim daddies like to do to their daughters who shame the family.
57. yishai is right so give him what he needs now
zionist forever   (08.17.12)
Firstly lets give Yishai the money and authority he needs to take action because without that its pointless. Once the money is there build lots of these super detention centres enough to lock up all the people already here and the ones who are still coming. Create a new body whose sole responsibility is investgating illegals. Once we have people to do the investogating check out everybody and if they are found to be an economic migrant they are sent home at their own expenses ASAP. If they are legitimate refugees and if its now safe to send them home we do so. If they are refugees and we can't send them home then we keep them locked up in refugee camps until we can send them home, as long as they are in refugee camps we don't have to release them after 3 years and so we can keep them off the streets. Right now the police are part the problem because they have no real desire to arrest illegals unless the rape women of course. The police must be ordered to arrest all illegals and if they need more manpower then we can use soldiers. If they look like an illegal and they can't produce ID they are arrested sent to a detention centre until they can prove them belong here. Finally lets get minicipalities to reclaim reclaiim areas these people previously occupied make then nice so even those neighborhoods can be the kind of places where Israelis would want to live.
58. to 6
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (08.17.12)
Then go with them...Too bad, you can't see beyond your own shadow...
59. to 11
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (08.17.12)
It is indeed, Yishai's job to look out for the best interest of Israel and the safety of its Nation...Just as well, as it is not your job to write from London ( of all places) and dictate appropriatness to Israel and its ministers...You better worry for your own "backyard", David...
60. to 19
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (08.17.12)
Who do you think were be able to fool here ? There never was or could be an illegal immigration of Jews to Palestine/Israel, unless it is your perverted mind, that is tuned to wishful thinking...We were and are coming home...Throwing around fancy words, will not make you believable..
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article