News  Mideast News
Experts: Israel could send Iran back to Stone Age
Ynet
Published: 09.09.12, 08:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
151 Talkbacks for this article
31. to no 21. So you propose what? Israel should sit and wait?
(09.09.12)
The article is not talking about a niclear bobmbardment, it's talking about electronic war. Most of Iran neighbors are not connected to Iran's electrical grid, so dont worry. Moast od the tiem Israel has avoided cicvilian casulties, nevertheless it has been accused of crimes against humanity. No matter what Israelies do they will allways be look upon as the bad guys. Let's be living bad guys that death good guys. As simple as that.
32. British now leaking for Obama.......
ralphrunner ,   atlanta, us   (09.09.12)
..............too close to the elections to be caught leaking Israel's secrets so use the British lapdogs instead this time around.
33. No. 22 Mahmood in London
Madeleine ,   Rehovot Israel   (09.09.12)
Please concentrate on setting up Sharia law in more areas of London and keep out of Israel's business.
34. great idea but why advertise it
zionist forever   (09.09.12)
Assuming Israel has EMP weapons and is thinking about using them do you really think it would be worried about minor issues like what the UN would have to say to it or how it would affect Iranians? The job of the IDF is protect Israelis not be the most moral army in the world. Israel's priority is stopping Iran developing nukes and if they don't think the US will do it then I can foresee them using it, Israel has always played dirty and if harming the civilian population through power outs if it will stop Iran getting a nuke then in the eyes of the Israeli government, the IDF top brass and I imagine alot of ordinary Israelis it will be viewed as an operation well done and all those involved will be praised. Personally I think it would be a great idea if it will allow the IDF to destroy the nuclear facilities.
35. the future is inevitable...
friend of israel ,   londonderry,n irelan   (09.09.12)
Israel is destined to be victorious, whatever course of action is taken by israel to defend the state and the chosen people of G*d will be successful, i just wish the world could see islam for what it is.... Take no shit Israel and stand strong.
36. #31
Henry from New York ,   In the Florentine Ghetto   (09.09.12)
I'm afraid you may have misunderstood how an EMP works. Think of tossing a stone in a body of water. Waves spread out in all directions. Now take those waves and put them in three dimensions so that now you have an expanding sphere. The sphere would spread towards the ground and keep spreading (while weakening in effect, I think) and not obey political borders. Could someone with a degree that gives them authority on this matter correct what I got wrong?
37. our lost 6 million say-do it. save yourselves. .
debra ,   usa   (09.09.12)
38. EMP is a form of WMD and could attract a WMD response.
WikiMiki   (09.09.12)
39. #31 - Actually Yes, the article is talking about
spyguy ,   seattle usa   (09.09.12)
nuclear bombardment because the ONLY way to produce Gamma rays with high enough energy level is to use a very large nuclear bomb and explode it high in the atmosphere. BTW - If Israel explodes a nuclear weapon of any kind it will not matter if they think they are good guys or bad guys because the entire world will severely punish Israel and most of the people in Israel will have to sneak into other countries to find any kind of life. Once Israel explodes a nuke, the US will be unable to protect it from the wrath of the other 7 billion people on earth. What part of ... a miniscule minority can not anger a huge majority without getting severely punished ... is so hard for you to understand.
40. Excuse me, but ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
... How is this news? Everyone with half a brain knows that Israel can completely cripple Iran. I think "diplomacy" and "sanctions" have gone on for far too long. It's time to send the Islamic Republic exactly where that primitive lot belongs -- the Stone Age.
41. To: No. 22
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
You fail to grasp the obvious. Do you remember when you scoffed at STUXNET? How about DUQU? TILDED? FLAME? GAUSS? Are you still laughing, Mahmood? Somehow, I suspect you are no longer finding this a joke at all, your false bravado to the contrary notwithstanding. I assure you that Israel did not lead with its trump card. The best (or, from your perspective, the worst) is yet to come. You have no idea. But Iran cannot say that Israel tried the most civilized method first. The problem is that Iran and civilization are two diametrically opposed concepts.
42. If so , Iran will do the same
Expert ,   Iran   (09.09.12)
I have confirmed information from inside the Iranian Intelligence Service that Iran has 2-3 nuclear weapons which have been imported from China couple of years ago (before 2003) and installed on Shahab-3 missiles. They are enough to destroy Tel-Aviv. Surely Israel knows this and never uses such destructive weapons against Iran. It will be an acceptable excuse for Iran to use nuclear weapons if Israel does it. Israel will never start such a dangerous game.
43. EMP is not a WMD
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
But those aren't the pulses that pose the greatest risk to Iran. ELF pulses, on the other hand -- which require a very particular terrain to launch -- can generate massive earthquakes. ELF is not a weapon of mass destruction, either. But isn't it gratifying to know that Israel can destroy Iran without firing a shot? Should give the world pause ... to admire.
44. To: No. 12
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
Yeah? Name one.
45. To: No. 21
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
You are assuming a great many facts not in evidence. 1. Chernobyl released more radiation over Europe than was released by the Hiroshima and Nagasaki blasts combined. 2. Fukushima released more radioactive materials into the air and into the oceans that Chernobyl released 3. Israel does not care about most of the rest of the globe and we do not count upon the United States to protect us. Israel's weaponology will have proven to be such that the world will be gathered at Israel's door, desperate to purchase Israel's technology. Israel's economy will flourish. Do you have any idea how many TRILLIONS of dollars have been offered to Israel by countries wanting to purchase a piece of the STUXNET, et al. pie? 4. Grow a brain. You are allowing your anti-Semitism and hatred of Israel to cloud your -- for lack of a better word -- "judgment." Has no one ever told you that there are no loyalties, merely interests? I assure you that Israel's weaponology -- passive and active -- is of very great demand throughout the community of nations.
46. To: No. 28
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.12)
Well, you are forgetting that you are talking about Israel -- where the impossible is commonplace. Of course, you are also forgetting about Israel's superiority in the sciences and technology. Just because you cannot wrap your brain around something doesn't mean that the Jews can't. Science and technology -- especially physics -- is a Jewish sport; hadn't you heard? The only power lifting we do is with our brains. It seems to work quite well.
47. Chosen People
Sassan ,   US   (09.09.12)
Well, is you really read between the lines, you see that Israel pretty much has always been given the green light t eliminate anything and anyone at any time if that could pose a threat to them in the future..and we all have been brain washed to accept that is their God-given right . after all they are the chosen people and the rest of the world do not measure up.
48. war of attrition
anton ,   istanbul   (09.09.12)
one can not understand some peoples logic how will you justify such attack that may harm civilians more than military installation? more importantly how will world respond you? you need to come terms with some painful truths you can nopt stop iran if they want to have nukes belive me they will eventually many of you would lıke to hear news like this to feel more safe but you should also use your heads regarding it:) dont act out of fear but with wisdom if somting will save you at the end thats will be it should israel choose to use unconventional means it would not be tolarated by world powers israel would be punished beyond your comprehension so ther you are left with less option the constant call from israeli leaders on world to stop iran reflects one simple trutht that israel without abovementioned means can not attack iran alone, even if she did the retaliation of iran may be not bearable for common israeli citizens living in israel if you belive war will save you then you are gravely mistaken
49. #36 - did you ever see the movie Ocean's 11?
Eyal ,   USA Israel   (09.09.12)
It is exactly what they used to down Vegas, but a much more powerful EMP that would take down all of Iran almost permanently.
50. The society of Iran has never been out of stoneage anyway!
EU   (09.09.12)
51. #47
Alex   (09.09.12)
Yes, we know you think the Jews should sit passive doing nothing with constant threats of destruction from à country developing nukes...
52. There are consequences to trying to end the Jewish state
Sam ,   Canada   (09.09.12)
Those people who love threatening the Jewish people will find that there is a price to pay.
53. We praying but no answer, oh Lord
Mark ,   U.S.   (09.09.12)
We the world are praying Iran and Israel stop this Eastern Euro-centric, Indo-Aryan communnist/shia propaganda game, bandering, posturing, threatning thespian play of villan, hero and just get it on, annhihlate each other, both are frauds and nothing in the sight of a living G-d. We pray you two destroy each other so we the world can have some peace. Iran needs Israel and Israel needs Iran, yes for this sh-t. And Israel stop firing rockets at yourself we know its election time but somebody could get hurt.
54. #49 - Are you aware that Ocean's 11 is PURE FICTION?
spyguy ,   seattle usa   (09.09.12)
There is no such things as the FANTASY machine in that movie. If you are going to use Hollywood fantasy as the basis for your decisions, you might want to be prepared to be badly hurt in the process. I find it amazing how extremely ignorant so many humans are (especially Sarah) when it comes to basic science.
55. No. 14 Empty Bravado from Jews
Elizabeth   (09.09.12)
as usual. somebody is scared. I can almost hear your boots "schlautering" 09.09.12. I guess you were born without a name, huh?
56. Looks like State is busy stabbing Israel in the back again
Yosi ,   Gilo, Jerusalem   (09.09.12)
and gotta love all the agency plant talkbacks, especially shake, rattle & roll. Talk about undue American pressure!!
57. ANYTHING is justified to prevent a new holocaust.
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.09.12)
Nothing is more clear, to every sane person, than the fact that Israel must stop Iran's Mad Mullahs from building nukes. ANYTHING is justified to destroy Iran's nukes and prevent a new holocaust.
58. Israel painted itself into corner, not even America can save
Steven Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (09.09.12)
...Israel now. In an Iran war, Syria will use chemical weapons on Israel, and US interests. Hezbollah will use missiles on Dimona, weapons plants, and petrochemical facilities. Iran will close the Straights of Hormuz, sink American warships, and oil will go to $300+ a barrel. Israel will use nuclear weapons. Superpowers East and West will clash, global economies will go into recession, and the entire world will blame Israel for causing this catastrophe, if Israel survives as a "Jewish State", or if Israel survives at all.
59. Why is Israel concerned only about Iran?
Eric ,   Toronto   (09.09.12)
Pakistan, another moslem country full of Islamist extremists who hate the Jews and Israel already has nuclear weapons! They might even fall in the hands of irrational fanatic Talibans! Why aren't Israel and the USA doing anything about that? Is it because it's already too late? If so, why didn't Israel and the USA stop Pakistan from obtaining the nuclear technology like they want to do with Iran? Any ideas?
60. to # 47
ChanahS ,   Israel   (09.09.12)
I wonder what you would say if it were the USA under threat of annihilation! As human beings each one of us has the God-given right to protect ourselves and families against those that threaten to annihilate us. In the last century the Jews sat back and waited, hoping the threat would pass - and we all know where that got them.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article