News
MK El-Sana: Zionists to blame for anti-Islam film
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 13.09.12, 13:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ismalics Having Trouble With The Truth
emanon ,   USA   (09.13.12)
The clips I've seen of this alleged movie are technically awful, but Mo's actions are historically portrayed.
2. Freedom of speech
Standing Tall ,   USA/Canada   (09.13.12)
Funny how the muslims have no trouble trash talking other religions, especially the Jewish religion. They have no problem making anti-jewish films. Well, guess what, we have freedom of speech here and we can make films too.
3. So Muslims do believe in collective punishment
James ,   USA   (09.13.12)
Then I guess they'll think it's fair to carpet bomb Gaza over the rocket fire
4. BLAME JEWS.. Film was by an Egyptian who is Coptic Christian
Netanya ,   Netanya   (09.13.12)
Maybe when the Egyptians murdered the Coptic Christians he learned about islam, just like Brigitte Gabriel, a Christian from Lebanon who lost so many in her family by Muslims killing them. The man who wrote and made the film was a coptic christian of egyptian decent living in California
5. demonizing Muslims and Islam?
Kool Yao ,   Israel   (09.13.12)
"The West is responsible for demonizing Muslims and Islam"... And Islamists behavior confirms they actually ARE demons!!!
6. To the insane MK El-Sana
Susya Bar Dror ,   Israel   (09.13.12)
Dont blame Zionists. Blame your own ideology which is simpy outdated in this world.
7. WRONG
Ruthie ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.13.12)
According to this very site "Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, a Coptic Christian from California, says he produced film that sparked anti-US rage in Egypt and Libya; adds director is in hiding" http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4281000,00.html
8. What are these MKs' comments?
Raphael ,   Netanya   (09.13.12)
About "the Matza of Zion", "Rider without horse", "The eyes of Zahra", "the valley of wolves", only to cite some antisemitic blockbusters broadcasted by Hezbollah, egyptian, turkish, iranian TV nets - and not a confidential youtube video.
9. This movie is only the result of violent muslims
hadad ,   u.k   (09.13.12)
10. Freedom is speech is very selective in the U.S.
WikiMiki   (09.13.12)
11. Only 2000 clicks
Ezer   (09.13.12)
It was pointed out on US networks that the movie only had 2,000 clicks before the riots erupted. How can the movie have offended so many who never viewed it?
12. sana you are wrong
ishamel   (09.13.12)
sana, it is clear that no jew had anything to do with this film. Even with our differencesd, jews have respect for all religions and don't say a word more. It was more likely disaffected arabs living in the us, possibly copts from egypt or evangelical christian converts who have done this despicable film. On the other hand, views should be held peacefully not a wild mob mentality/ Sana, you ought to thank god that you live in a good country like israel
13. In my country is called pederast
Isaac ,   Texas   (09.13.12)
What Mohammed did, to marry a 6 years old, is called be a pederast and child abuser. So the truth hurts.
14. So what else is new? More pissing and moaning from Muslims
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (09.13.12)
15. ignorance. hatred, and violence
shloime ,   toronto, canada   (09.13.12)
yes, they correctly identified what is wrong: ignorance, hatred, and violence; but it is coming FROM the moslems, not at them. the murders in benghazi were planned long in advance by al-qaeda for the anniversary of 9/11. no, the "jooos" were not involved. but hate-filled islamist terrorists were. the "problem" is not jews, or israelis, or zionists, or the mossad - it is the notion, deeply rooted in islam, that humans are not equal, and that islam is to be "defended" by killing infidels. and this is the "demon", as implicit in these speeches, as it was in the 2,000 murders of 9/11. arab israelis should be ashamed to see the support that these "leaders" from their community provide to al-qaeda's mass murderers.
16. mk tibi Grow A Skin You Inciting, Provocateur
(09.13.12)
Sticks And Stones May Break My Bones But Names Will NEVER HURT ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Respect Is Due, Tolerance Is Universal! Oh Yea NOT FOR arabs They Due What They Want, Like Start War On JEWISH HOLIDAY'S, Desecrate Jewish Shul's, Make Movies Depicting IDF IN FALSE LIGHT?????? Maybe The Old Saying "The Truth Hurts" Should Apply To mooslums and isslim??????????????????????????
17. Is there any evidence at all that Israel had anything to do
a ,   canada   (09.13.12)
with the making of this film?
18. religion
john ,   toronto   (09.13.12)
The film is not about religion. The filmmaker's religion should not be made known. It is not the view of any society or religion, what a person has done with his money cannot be blamed on a religion or society. Most people are busy with their own religion , this is the work of a person who wanted to incite others.
19. I like how they complain about a bad movie
Ezra ,   San Diego USA   (09.13.12)
That movie is so boring I couldn't sit through 3 minutes of it. The kind of stuff that comes out of Hollywood these days is also filled with too much sex and violence. Maybe we should hire them to riot, burn some flags, and shoot up the set at Universal Studios when the next bad movie comes out? Never mind, we have the first amendment.
20. again
michel ,   Ashkelon   (09.13.12)
these people are toxic waste ;dangereous for the population and non recycleable. They will be certainly more happy in the islamic countries .Help them !
21. Coptic Christian made the movie!!!
American ,   Usa   (09.13.12)
Why the he'll are these blaming the USA again we did not make this movie and the reaction of the Muslims in the middle east showed their true colors again !!! Savages
22. wikimiki releasing details of intelligence agents is treason
PETER SM ,   MELBOURNE AUSTRALIA   (09.13.12)
Stealing information is stealing
23. it is time...
postroad ,   USA   (09.13.12)
for Muslim believers to get theitr act together and stop blaming everyone for everything. Insult, Jews, Christians and you may get a verbal slap in return. But Muslims act like frenzied mobs and destroy everything in the process of "complaining." Who would visit Egypt these days? And Egypt in great need of tourism.
24. Muslims
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim   (09.13.12)
B"H - Muslims don't like to be talked badly about, so they lynch 4 American diplomats, to protect their good reputation. I see. Makes sense, doesn't it?
25. I'm realy surprised more than 1,000,000
NATAN ,   ISRAEL   (09.13.12)
Videos in Youtube in all lenguages again jews, israel etc.. and nobuddy say nothing just incredible 1 video again Muslims and they took it away and all the world agree. We must make a boicot again Youtube, this is the number 1 place in the net whit antisemitic propaganda.
26. #4 Don't blame the Copts
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (09.13.12)
Do not collectively blame the Copts. The Copts are the natives of Egypt living under cruel Muslim occupation. Thanks to Obama, the Copts will lose everything with no connection to the film. As for the film, a single man with a questionable past and who might be Coptic made the movie. It's been on the Internet for six months and only now, with perfect timeing for Iran, it suddenly becomes an issue. I think the Iranians are playing Obama like a fiddle.
27. Say want you want about this film
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (09.13.12)
it is as provocative as you can get, poorly done and pretty vulgar. The problem is that this is a really low way to confront Islam. It's not Islam that is the problem, it is the world western leadership that aids, supports, tries to reform Islamic countries and in the process overlooks some serious moral issues for Arab good will. Let's face it Islam hates the West and the West hates Islam, and everybody hates the Jews. Same old story.
28. Shiite quality film...
Koose E Mack ,   US NY   (09.13.12)
It is not uncommon to hear Anti Semites say that "Jews Run Hollywood": If that is the case, the film would not have been such a crappy low rate production. Secondly, no Jew would make a public defamation of other religions. As harmful and toxic as Islam is to the world; we still respect the rights of all to observe their faiths. So to all my Muzzie cousins...this one shouldn't be blamed on Jews...but who cares if you do...It's typical of your "civilized" behavior.
29. I have a deal for the arabs and muslims: DONT B HYPOCRITES K
hippocrates ,   earth   (09.13.12)
Take down all the millions of anti semitic, racist, xenophobic, sexist, anti Christian, anti Buddhist films, satires, cartoons, books, textbooks, novels, comic books, trading cards, toys, videos, op-eds, artciles, newspapers, "documentaries (ha!)" that similalry insult otjhers. Deal? when you do that maybe we can talk, till then this discussion is absurdly hypocritical.
30. I hope the Egyptians, "palestinians"
A ,   Belgium   (09.13.12)
and the rest of the world wide islamic beggars remember how much they hate America and the West when it comes time to begging for more money. Sure would be nice if everyone stood together and in one united voice said ...NO!
Next talkbacks
Back to article