Opinion
Muslims' sensitive issue
Yaron Friedman
Published: 14.09.12, 12:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. Islam, religion of peace. Islam, a great religion
John ,   NZ   (09.15.12)
32. #12 - Not really
Henry from New York ,   Under the Tuscan Stars   (09.15.12)
All it requires is a basic understanding of the archaeology of Israel.
33. 1.2 billion muslims
real vision ,   usa   (09.15.12)
Just amazing that there are 1.2 billion brainwashed muslims who have no respect for human life outside of frothing over mohammed and the trash he wrote. As #16 wrote "Tens of thousands Muslims are dying in Syria and there's hardly any protest in the Muslim world, but a 15 minute long YouTube video makes muslims go INSANE . "
34. Dear Moslems: NO to disrespecting other peopel's religions
and flags!   (09.15.12)
They might get angry too and make a movie and show the truth about Islam and the root of your behavior !
35. We kow why, don't bother
Libby ,   Boston Mass.   (09.15.12)
We know why you so-called Jews do not love Jesus, Sarah B. its obvious with you. Maybe you so-called Jews should go back to Europe as you are not decendants of the Hebrew people as Jesus was, maybe this is the reason for your disdain of this prophet,,,, Hebrew prophet.
36. Enough murders on behalf of cults!
Non-believer   (09.15.12)
There isn't much difference between the murderous mayhem perpetrated against Jews by Christians in the past or the identical deadly mayhem perpetrated by Muslims against Jews to this day (other non-believers also being frequent targets). The issues are always the same: the willful attempt by the local majority, be they Christians or Muslims, to eradicate a group of humans, the Jews, who don't accept the local majority's beliefs. The nub of the problem is that there is NOT a single shred of incontrovertible material evidence to justify the existence of any of these three religions other than the ardent beliefs of their respective adherents. What the Muslims are doing today is proving the complete invalidity and falseness of their beliefs; if their cult/beliefs were true their omnipotent deity would NOT need any human intervention, like the current murderous riots, to impose the supposed truth and correctness of their cult on others. That assessment is also relevant to Christians regarding their frequent murderous rampages against Jews and heretics in the past. As to Jews, they have not tried to eradicate any group for its "wrong" religious beliefs for at least 2,500 years...so Jews are relatively reasonable on this matter. In the final analysis, one can only conclude that religious fanaticism KILLS innocents; thus the perpetrators of these religion-based murders need to be eliminated to allow the rest of humanity to survive.
37. #11
Madeleine ,   Rehovot Israel   (09.15.12)
But why does it bother you that people follow religions other than Islam? they do so quietly, minding their own business, with no thought to insulting, defiling, ridiculing islam. so if Jews, Christians, Buddhists, Hindus, etc., can do so, why can't Muslims just get on with their own religion instead of finding any pretext for violence, threats to butcher/kill the infidel, burning, looting, rioting and so on. Islam is not a religion of peace, it's more like a terrorist organisation.
38. The koran is very clear on this issue...
David ,   Hartford USA   (09.15.12)
Non-believers are given the choice to convert, to flee with nothing, to pay the jizya (dhimmi) tax and live as third-class citizens, or die by the sword. That's it. It is Islam's singular goal to take over the world. It is Islam's highest honor to die in 'holy' jihad against us infidels. That was true 1400 years ago as Mohammad and his thugs terrorized the region, and it's true today as Islam terrorizes the world. Know this one fact: To be a good citizen, one must be a 'bad' Muslim. To be a 'good' Muslim, one must be a bad citizen. That's what is taught in mosques all over the world. Why doesn't the vast majority of 'peaceful' Muslims speak out against terrorism? Because in their hearts and minds, they agree with jihad and are 'good' Muslims.
39. To #35. Mind your own business !
Gabe ,   Canada   (09.15.12)
Get professional help and shut up !
40. #14 libby
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.15.12)
We Jews have had quite enough of "Christian love", thank you very much.
41. #11 We dont need you to wish peace on Moses
(09.15.12)
42. What a pity Koolaid wasnt around in 7th Century
Alan ,   SA   (09.15.12)
43. Proud to be an infidel.
Sam M ,   UK   (09.15.12)
You're everyone's worst nightmare a salesman that won't take no for an answer and keeps coming back for more. Why can't you get it into your thick skull that like hundreds of millions of other people I don't want to convert to islam and have no interest whatsoever in mohammed. Go away! Leave us in peace and take your fairy tale with you!
44. @Libby #35
deavman ,   Acco, Israel   (09.15.12)
Your obvious intolerance should be grounds enough for everyone to ignore you. But as you are delegimizing an entire people because we don't see Jesus as you do. It highlights how pathetic and also irrelevant you are. So if you dislike the Jews so much, just stay away from them. Also almost 60% of Jews in Israel are from Arab countries, they can't "go back" to Europe. PS Jesus was a cool guy and it's too bad he is being hijacked by people just like you. Peace...if you want it.
45. #14 and 35
Henry from New York ,   Under the Tuscan Sun   (09.15.12)
There is no reason for us to accept Jesus of Nazareth as our saviour or anything along those lines. I do not get where you get this idea that today's Jews are not the descendants of the Jews of old. The lion's share of scientific evidence has shown otherwise.
46. Grown men acting like hysterical children
Cameron ,   USA   (09.15.12)
The irrationality underlying it all! Cultural breakdown?
47. To: Cameron at No. 46
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.15.12)
"Cultural breakdown" assumes that there is culture to begin with. There isn't.
48. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.15.12)
No. I don't think so. But you can worship any false prophet you want. I'll stick with G-d, thank you very much.
49. My apologies for repetition, but...
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.16.12)
given some of the posts here from the same type of Christian and Moslem, I must again repeat (from Pat Condell): ‘While Christians and Moslems want you to believe the way they believe, Jews don’t care what you believe as long as you leave them alone.’ Very apropos. To those kind Christians and Moslems who are so concerned about the Jews welfare in the Kingdom to come, LEAVE US ALONE. PLEASE!
50. #12 actually moron there is evidence of both
but you dont care   (09.16.12)
51. #19 tracy
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.16.12)
They always blame the Jews no matter what, and are doing so now. An investigation is warranted, but it wouldn't make an iota of difference for them. Jews and Israel are to blame a priori, especially when they need to blame someone else, and not the real culprits; themselves.
53. Better analysis
Can   (09.16.12)
Jesus Christ said whatsoever plants his father never planted will be uprooted. The birth of Jesus was by promised announced by Archangel Gabriel. That same angel Gabriel was opposed and detained by the prince of Persia for 21 days until Archangel Michael came to his help. And he said he will go back and fight the guardian angel of Persia (Daniel Chapter 10). Forcing angel Gabriel to form Muslim religion? Well the fight might be on between angelic bodies*** bless them***to fight our battles.
54. Libby # 35
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (09.16.12)
If you loved Jesus you would not talk to Jews that way. You are an embarrassment. You should be ashamed.
55. #35 libby - Jesus was a Jew. Remember?
solomon ,   bklyn   (09.17.12)
56. #51 Solomon - Inaction sets a precedent
Tracy W   (09.16.12)
While there have been many libels against Jews before, this one is different. The power of the internet changes everything. To fall back on a sense of helplessness and fatalism may result in future loss of Jewish lives. There must be a strong effort to identify the authors of this libel and to use the courts to sue them. I'm appalled at the timid reaction by US Jewish organizations. They say they are "concerned". I hope you read another Ynet article today about how the Arab media are saying that the Jews were behind the movie, trying to whip up more rage against the Jews. This has to be stopped now, before they come up with another libel of this sort.
57. #35 Jesus...
Thinking Jew ,   World   (09.19.12)
No, IT was not. IT was the product of 2nd-4th century Hellenism and idolatry of Roman gentiles -- a fabrication and idol, not person, quite the opposite of the historical 1st century Jew.
58. Wall Street Journal Started the Rumor
Netanya ,   Netanya   (09.19.12)
So what will you do now? Maybe ynet and all the others who wrote the false report should all be held accountable. Al-dura still haunts us. Time for all these news sources to check the proof prior to spreading the rumors.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article