News  World News
French weekly publishes Mohammed cartoons
News agencies
Published: 19.09.12, 13:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. WOW france
John ,   London   (09.19.12)
props to you, may america learn from you, there is no reason to allow violence over this, finally a country that has the guts to say it like it is, funny this is most muslims dont want violence over this movie.
2. Oh dear what bravardo!! seems the
Arlene ,   israel   (09.19.12)
French are showing us all how it should be done....No apologises, no trying to kiss butt and beg forgiveness...Obama take note! so no more white flag jokes about France!!!!
3. Photo of Publisher
Prometheus ,   Spain   (09.19.12)
That guy is brave and stupid; incoming Fatwa
4. very brave or very stupid?
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (09.19.12)
It is hard to tell, but for certain he will sell many issues. I guess it is good business??
5. vive la france.
mriam ,   israel   (09.19.12)
brave canada now france we need time there is hope
6. #3, brave or stupid
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (09.19.12)
Brave or stupid? Zapata answered that question "It is better to die on your feet than live on your knees".
7. (4) very brave or very stupid?
tiki ,   belgium   (09.19.12)
That we even have to ask this question shows what we have lost! Our 'freedom of speech! Question comes to mind: What will be lost next? Our dress-code? Our school curriculum? Our freedom?
8. Freedom has a price.
Jusanz77 ,   Vzla.   (09.19.12)
Freedom has a price, something that many in the West seem to have forgotten. There are still some who are willing to pay the price of freedom.
9. The freedom has price.
Jusanz77 ,   Vzla.   (09.19.12)
Freedom has a price, something that many in the West seem to have forgotten. There are still some who are willing to pay the price of freedom.
10. Prophet Mohammad Caricatures
Imad ,   Israel   (09.19.12)
Nothing smart in intentional hurting the feeling of others by showing stupid portraits of the prophet of Islam by some ignorant journalist who knows from Mohammad's life as much as I Know of nano-physics, and I do not know what exactly nano-physics means.
11. Bravo! Free speech!
Tzipora David ,   Belgium   (09.19.12)
Why can everyone depict G-D, Moshe and Jesus and no Muhammed? or Alah? Why? Because Christians and Jews have evolved and arn't barbaric. Everyone has the right to free speech in a democracy and if they don't like it then they don't have to live there....
12. mohammed cartoons
benny ,   jerusalem   (09.19.12)
Imad,every year they holding caricature championships in Iran about the holocaust etc, I never saw your name at y-net condemning this.... This is not intentional hurting!!!
13. Mohammad Caricatures
TONI T.   (09.19.12)
Hurting Islam's prophet is not wise and not acceptable, but when Muslims intentionally say that Jews (and Christians) must dissapear is it okay?
14. To: No. 10
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.19.12)
How do you feel about the insulting cartoons denigrating Jews and the State of Israel that are a daily feature of Arab and Moslem press? Do they trouble you at all? Or is it just unflattering depictions of your precious "prophet" that raises your ire?
15. French Publication
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (09.19.12)
Bravo...well done....fredom of speech can not be "BULLIED".....word of your "six"......good luck
16. What's with the Jew pushing the wheelchair???
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (09.19.12)
Can someone explain that??
17. For a religion that beheads people (for,
DT ,   TA Israel   (09.19.12)
attending parties )abuses women, advocates and trains child suicide bombers it does not deserve to exist let alone be respected. Instead the cowering West does the opposite.
18. Adding fuel to the fire does not make sense.
miri ,   israel   (09.19.12)
How intelligent is it to do so ? Are we beginning to lose our minds ?
19. Not brave: French cartoon exploits Jews.
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (09.19.12)
France should be protecting Jews instead of implicating them more into falsified satire messages. The cartoon idea is great as it does not make any anti-Islam slants but merely presents a topical joke of Muslims in the News. Nothing to do with Jews.
20. Close all embassies in the Arab world
steve from raleigh   (09.19.12)
21. the white flag
real vision ,   usa   (09.19.12)
It is time to stop raising the white flag to islam. It is our right to criticize a religion that kills, destroys, creates havoc in the name of their god and prophet and disrespects every other religion on the planet. And if this criticism create more islamic havoc then the criticism is the TRUTH about islam. The battle for freedom is upon us. Tolkien was right...the battle with the dark lord(islam)must be fought and won by he west
22. To No. 16
Alan ,   Canada   (09.19.12)
The Jew pushing the weelchair is a play or imitation on one of the most popular film in France titled "Les Intouchables" in which a rich paralyzed white Frenchman hires a Black man to be his helper. The comedy deals with their differences in background & attitudes towards each other
23. Power to free speech!!
Audrey Russo ,   New York   (09.19.12)
When will the West collectively declare the problem to be the ideology of Islam...when they have to self-incarcerate??
24. Cartoons
Natan ,   USA   (09.19.12)
So what is the difference wether we publish muhammed cartoons or not. They try to kill us no matter what. And as far as the cartoons with the orthodox Jew pushing the wheel chair, we do not see the cliff.
25. "A Riot Is A Terrible Thing. I Think We Need One Now!"
David H ,   Marietta USA   (09.19.12)
Quoted from Mel Brooks, another Dhimi from "Young Frankenstein". Let 'em riot and kill each other. It's part of making the world a better and safer place.
26. Bien joue'! France
Jake Stone ,   USA   (09.19.12)
I'm not a Frenchman, so I hope I got the French-part right in my subject title? Here it is in English: way to go, France! You can't offend a lie--period! One only needs to read-up and get the facts: Islam is a cult, formulated by a demented clown (the false prophet) with the help of Satan himself (how's that for being politically un-correct, for you?)! I normally don't think too much of the French, but, in this case, they're showing more chutzpah than any of the Western world leaders! Islam is nothing more than a bad cartoon--period! There's nothing peaceful about this cancerous plague; it must be eradicated--NOW!!! Its very core, of evil, is the antithesis of God's true nature; the true God of Israel (and we Christians) will destroy this great paganistic lie that holds (most of) the world's weak leaders' hostage. America and Israel need to team-up and destroy these animals--period! God bless, America and Israel!!!
27. Funny, France didn't have to close it's embassy in Israel...
Tevye ,   Chelm   (09.19.12)
out of fear for Jewish reprisals...
28. Do these people not have jobs?
Emma ,   London   (09.19.12)
They seem to spend an awful lot of time screaming, shouting and generally rioting.
29. chapeau canada and
miriam ,   israel   (09.19.12)
i hope israel can do it .but usa help is crutial.
30. It does not bode well
Haider ,   Gothenburg, Sweden   (09.19.12)
Different cultures react differently to what they consider is abuse of their beliefs. Why the provocation? I don´t think that Christians would not react if someone replaced the head of Jesus on the cross with the head of a pig. We have all seen the nasty pictures portraying Jews. Is a second Crusade of some kind on its way? If so then the difference will that the first one did not spare the Jews. The one that is coming needs the support of the Jews.
Next talkbacks
Back to article